Sunday, January 07, 2007

Canada's New Justice Minister and Attorney-General, Rob Nicholson

The Hon. Robert Douglas Nicholson has been appointed Canada's new Attorney General and Minister of Justice by Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

Nicholson, a 54 year old lawyer, was first elected to Parliament in 1984 in his hometown of Niagara Falls. He has previously held several cabinet posts, including his most recent stint as Conservative House Leader.

Blogger Cathiefromcanada comments on the Nicholson appointment:

I know the big news of the day was the replacement of Rona Ambrose as Environment minister, but I actually thought the replacement of Vic Toews as Justice Minister could turn out to be pretty significant, too.What's going to happen to all the Conservative "let's send more Canadians to jail" law proposals, like the three-strikes idea (which is, I think, both contrary to natural justice and unnecessary), not to mention "let's staff our courts with more right-wing, ideological judges" and then"'let's tie their hands with more mandatory sentences."

The new Justice Minister outlined his immediate agenda in Cracking Down on Criminals, a report in last Friday's Niagara Falls Review:

Canada's new justice minister, Rob Nicholson, vowed to continue the Conservative party's law-and-order push for tougher sentences for criminals and more protection for law-abiding Canadians. "This effort to make our streets and communities safer is really one of the government's priorities. There won't be any doubt about it," Nicholson said after Thursday's cabinet shuffle.

... Nicholson inherits responsibility for three bills the Conservatives introduced last year - to impose mandatory jail time for criminals who use guns; to raise the age of sexual consent to 16 years old from 14; and to end the use of conditional sentences for people convicted of serious crimes.

"There are a number of bills that have my attention. Certainly, I'll want to do what I can to get those things through," he said, adding he wants to see them become laws before an election is called.

Allan Woods of The Toronto Star indicates that "conservative insiders" view this appointment as a "rebuke" to Toews, and reports:

Parker MacCarthy, president of the Canadian Bar Association, said his group hopes there will be more time and opportunity to provide "meaningful input" on justice bills, which he said was lacking under Toews.

But questions remain about whether Nicholson, who declined an interview request, will have a mandate from the Prime Minister's Office to engage in the necessary negotiations, and submit to legislative amendments, needed to win opposition support – something Toews seemed unwilling or unable to do.

"The Conservatives realized that Toews was not portraying an image that was acceptable to Canadians in the sense that so many of the proposals in the legislation that he's brought before the House were overreaching and, in some cases, just way over the top," said NDP justice critic Joe Comartin.

"Nicholson ... is a person that is prepared to make compromises and help build consensus and I think that is the kind of image that they would prefer to portray."

For more background:
  • Nicholson's home page online is here.
  • Wikipedia's extensive biography is here.
  • A partial history of his voting record in Parliament (to November 2005) is here
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: http://www.wiselaw.net/

Saturday, January 06, 2007

Bush Getting "Defence Ducks" in Order?

As I said earlier - the impeachment drumbeats have quietly begun to sound.

And in the backrooms, the decider is apparently preparing to become the defender.

From CNN: President uses secret memo to block access to White house visitor logs

The chief counsel to another Washington-based group suing to get Secret Service logs calls the creation of the memo "a political maneuver couched as a legal one."

"It appears the White House is actually manufacturing evidence to further its own agenda," Anne Weismann, a Justice Department lawyer for 19 years and now chief counsel to Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, said Friday.
The White House and the Secret Service declined to comment.

From the Washington Post: White House Counsel Hariet Miers resigns - Bush to "lawyer up"

Republican advisers have been telling the White House to be ready for war, and many cited Miers as the wrong general. "The White House knew they needed to get a tough street fighter - that's what this is about,'' said one such adviser, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to preserve access to the White House.

The advice, according to this person, could be summed up this way: "You guys better lawyer up, and lawyer up in the right way. You better understand the need and the peril and the urgency. . . . You need somebody as tough as [Clinton aides] Harold Ickes or Bruce Lindsey. Because they're coming for you.

And the Democratic Party has now controlled congress for all of two days.

Fasten your seatbelts.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our website: http://www.wiselaw.net/

Thursday, January 04, 2007

B.C. Court of Appeal Upholds Sulz $950,000.00 Damages Award

I originally wrote on the trial decision in Sulz vs. Attorney General of Canada in March, 2006.

This important decision addressed the ongoing, serious harassment of a female RCMP officer by a superior officer. Ms. Sulz suffered very significant damage, emotional harm and long-term disability. Ultimately, the harassment she was subjected to led to the end of her career with the Force.

Recently, the B.C. Court of Appeal rejected an appeal of the British Columbia government, and upheld the trial court's damages award of $950,000.00 in favour of Ms. Sulz.

The Appeal Court's decision is here.

I am excerpting below from an interview with Ms. Sulz in the Merritt-Herald newspaper, following the December 21, 2006 appellate decision:

For Nancy Sulz the end is in sight.

B.C.’s court of appeal has upheld the ex-Mountie’s victory in the harassment case she filed against the RCMP. They ruled that the provincial government would have to pay $950,000 in damages.

Sulz says it feels like another victory, but she is still apprehensive because the province has 60 days to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

“There’s always that hesitation – are we done?” she explains. “Typically that wouldn’t happen, but they have given us no indication as to whether they plan to take it further.”

Sulz filed the suit after being harassed by her boss when she served as a constable with the Merritt RCMP. She returned to work after a medical leave following the birth of her second child and found her commanding officer, Donald Smith, began treating her in a demeaning manner that left her unable to do her job. Sulz says the treatment only continued to escalate, and it eventually became clear it was not going to end.

In 1996, after almost a year, Sulz went on paid long-term medical leave. In 1999, it was requested that she ask for a medical discharge. She did and in 2000 her time as an RCMP officer officially ended.

Unfortunately, the stress didn’t end when she left the department, and so she filed a suit against the province, Smith and the Attorney General of Canada.

Almost a year ago, in January 2006, the B.C. Supreme Court ruled in her favour based on what they believed to be extensive harassment by her superior officer. It was “so debilitating, the woman was left unable to work” according to Justice George Lamperson, the B.C. supreme court judge who originally ruled in Sulz’s favour.


- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

Ontario Court of Appeal: Child Can Have Three Parents

The Canadian Press reports today on a precedent-setting ruling by the Ontario Court of Appeal in a case referenced as A.A. v. B.B.:

TORONTO -- An Ontario boy can legally have two mothers and a father, the province's highest court ruled Tuesday.

The same-sex partner of the child's biological mother went to court seeking to also be declared a mother of the boy.

... [The] Court was told the child has three parents: his biological father and mother (identified in court documents as B.B. and C.C., respectively) and C.C.'s partner, the appellant A.A.

In affirming the non-biological mother's legal parentage, the Appeal Court exercised its inherent parens patriae jurisdiction to remedy what it found to be a "legislative gap" in the current statute, the Ontario Children's Law Reform Act.

The Act, on its face, clearly precludes a finding of dual motherhood. The Appeal Court, however, held that following the statute in this regard was contrary to the child's best interests, and issued a declaration affirming the parental status of the non-biological mother, in addition to the boy's two biological parents.

Excerpts from the ruling of Justice Rosenberg, for the Court, are below:

[1] Five-year-old D.D. has three parents: his biological father and mother (B.B. and C.C., respectively) and C.C.’s partner, the appellant A.A. A.A. and C.C. have been in a stable same-sex union since 1990. In 1999, they decided to start a family with the assistance of their friend B.B. The two women would be the primary caregivers of the child, but they believed it would be in the child’s best interests that B.B. remain involved in the child’s life. D.D. was born in 2001. He refers to A.A. and C.C. as his mothers.

The Importance of a Declaration of Parentage
[13] A.A. seeks a declaration that she is a mother of D.D. She and C.C. have not applied for an adoption order because, if they did so, B.B. would lose his status as D.D.’s parent by reason of s. 158(2) of the Child and Family Services Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.11. That section provides: “For all purposes of law, as of the date of the making of an adoption order … (b) the adopted child ceases to be the child of the person who was his or her parent before the adoption order was made and that person ceases to be the parent of the adopted child, except where the person is the spouse of the adoptive parent”.

[14] A.A., B.B. and C.C. seek to have A.A.’s motherhood recognized to give her all the rights and obligations of a custodial parent. Legal recognition of her relationship with her son would also determine other kindred relationships. In their very helpful factums, the M.D.R. Intervenors and the Children’s Lawyer summarize the importance of a declaration of parentage from the point of view of the parent and the child:

· the declaration of parentage is a lifelong immutable declaration of status;
· it allows the parent to fully participate in the child’s life;
· the declared parent has to consent to any future adoption;
· the declaration determines lineage;
· the declaration ensures that the child will inherit on intestacy;
· the declared parent may obtain an OHIP card, a social insurance number, airline tickets and passports for the child;
· the child of a Canadian citizen is a Canadian citizen, even if born outside of Canada (Citizenship Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-29, s. 3(1)(b));
[2]
· the declared parent may register the child in school; and,
· the declared parent may assert her rights under various laws such as the Health Care Consent Act, 1996, S.O. 1996, c. 2, Sched. A., s. 20(1)5.

[15] Perhaps one of the greatest fears faced by lesbian mothers is the death of the birth mother. Without a declaration of parentage or some other order, the surviving partner would be unable to make decisions for their minor child, such as critical decisions about health care: see M.D.R. at para. 220. As the M.D.R. Intervenors say: “A declaration of parentage provides practical and symbolic recognition of the parent-child relationship.” An excerpt from the M.D.R. record dramatically demonstrates the importance of the declaration from the child’s point of view. I resort to this part of the M.D.R. record because D.D. is too young to provide this kind of information. The twelve-year old child of one of the applicants said this in her affidavit:

I just want both my moms recognized as my moms. Most of my friends have not had to think about things like this—they take for granted that their parents are legally recognized as their parents. I would like my family recognized the same way as any other family, not treated differently because both my parents are women....

[21] The CLRA was progressive legislation, but it was a product of its time. It was intended to deal with the specific problem of the incidents of illegitimacy – the need to “remove, as far as the law is capable of doing so, a stigma which has been cast on children who in the nature of things cannot be said to bear responsibility for it” (p. 11). The possibility of legally and socially recognized same-sex unions and the implications of advances in reproductive technology were not on the radar scheme. The Act does not deal with, nor contemplate, the disadvantages that a child born into a relationship of two mothers, two fathers or as in this case two mothers and one father might suffer. This is not surprising given that nothing in the Commission’s report suggests that it contemplated that such relationships might even exist.

[22] When the scheme of the CLRA is considered, especially the relationship between the various provisions in Parts I and II, it is apparent that the Act contemplates only one mother and one father. The application judge drew attention to many of these provisions. He referred in particular to s. 8, which deals with the presumption of paternity. He was of the view that this section contemplated only one father. This view of the legislation is also consistent with the adoption provisions in the Act whereby no more than two persons can apply for an adoption order and the order extinguishes other parental status. I agree with that interpretation of the legislation.

[23] Further, in my view, an interpretation of the Act that allows for a declaration of a single father and a single mother is fortified by s. 12(2) of the Act, which provides that:

Two persons may file in the office of the Registrar General a statutory declaration, in the form prescribed by the regulations, jointly affirming that they are the father and mother of a child. [Emphasis added.]....

Parens Patriae Jurisdiction

[27] The court’s inherent parens patriae jurisdiction may be applied to rescue a child in danger or to bridge a legislative gap. This is not a case about a child being in danger. If the parens patriae authority were to be exercised it would have to be on the basis of a legislative gap.

[37] It is contrary to D.D.’s best interests that he is deprived of the legal recognition of the parentage of one of his mothers. There is no other way to fill this deficiency except through the exercise of the parens patriae jurisdiction. As indicated, A.A. and C.C. cannot apply for an adoption order without depriving D.D. of the parentage of B.B., which would not be in D.D.’s best interests.

[38] I disagree with the application judge that the legislative gap in this case is deliberate. There is no doubt that the Legislature did not foresee for the possibility of declarations of parentage for two women, but that is a product of the social conditions and medical knowledge at the time. The Legislature did not turn its mind to that possibility, so that over thirty years later the gap in the legislation has been revealed. In the result, the statute does not provide for the best interests of D.D....

[39] This holding would, it seems, be consistent with the position of the government. As stated earlier, the Crown in Right of Ontario did not intervene in this case, but its position on this issue is known. In M.D.R., the Crown took the position that the CLRA in fact could be interpreted to allow for a declaration that two women were the mothers of a child. Since I have found otherwise, it does no violence to the government's position to make the declaration sought by the appellant in this case through exercise of the parens patriae jurisdiction...

[41] Accordingly, I would allow the appeal and issue a declaration that A.A. is a mother of D.D. I would order that there be no costs of the appeal or of the application.

Full text of the Court of Appeal's decision in A.A. v. B.B is here.
For more background on parens patriae jurisdiction, see Answers.com's article, here:

...the parens patriae doctrine has had its greatest application in the treatment of children, mentally ill persons, and other individuals who are legally incompetent to manage their affairs. The state is the supreme guardian of all children within its jurisdiction, and state courts have the inherent power to intervene to protect the best interests of children whose welfare is jeopardized by controversies between parents. This inherent power is generally supplemented by legislative acts that define the scope of child protection in a state.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net/family.html

Monday, January 01, 2007

E.U. Air Passengers: Email Messages and Credit Card Records to be Scrutinized by U.S.?

The U.K's Telegraph reports on an agreement between the U.S. and the E.U. to permit American authorities to scrutinize air travellers' credit card records and email messages:

Britons flying to America could have their credit card and email accounts inspected by the United States authorities following a deal struck by Brussels and Washington.

By using a credit card to book a flight, passengers face having other transactions on the card inspected by the American authorities. Providing an email address to an airline could also lead to scrutiny of other messages sent or received on that account.

The extent of the demands were disclosed in "undertakings" given by the US Department of Homeland Security to the European Union and published by the Department for Transport after a Freedom of Information request.

About four million Britons travel to America each year and the released document shows that the US has demanded access to far more data than previously realised.

Not only will such material be available when combating terrorism but the Americans have asserted the right to the same information when dealing with other serious crimes.

Shami Chakrabarti, the director of the human rights group Liberty, expressed horror at the extent of the information made available. "It is a complete handover of the rights of people travelling to the United States," she said.

Happy 2007. Is even the pretense of respect for privacy rights now a thing of the past?

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website www.wiselaw.net

Saddam Execution: Frantic Quest for "Legal Workarounds" in Sectarian Hanging?

Many developments from Iraq today, including a whole lot of fallout from the Saddam execution.

From Reuters:

The Iraqi government launched an inquiry on Monday into how guards filmed and taunted Saddam Hussein on the gallows, turning his execution into a televised spectacle that has inflamed sectarian anger.

A senior Iraqi official told Reuters the U.S. ambassador tried to persuade Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki not to rush into hanging the former president just four days after his appeal was turned down, urging the government two wait another two weeks.

News of the ousted strongman's death on Saturday and of his treatment by officials of the Shi'ite-led government was blamed by one witness for sparking a prison riot among mainly Sunni Arab inmates at a jail near the northern city of Mosul.

An adviser to Maliki, Sami al-Askari, told Reuters: "There were a few guards who shouted slogans that were inappropriate and that's now the subject of a government investigation."

After a weekend of digesting (and subsequent viewing of the gruesome cellphone video of the Saddam execution that has gone viral on the internet), I am better able to articulate the unease I felt in advance of this execution.

This was a blatantly sectarian execution. It was conducted under a cloak of legitimacy lent by U.S. support for the current Iraqi regime and facilitated by the voluntary American handover of Saddam to Shiites for hanging.

As a matter of law and practicality, Saddam was executed solely for his crimes against Shiites. To his captors, judges and executioners, this was apparently enough.

His regime's atrocities against Kurds, Sunni dissenters and Jews were reduced to irrelevance in the rush to the gallows, even as trials were ongoing or pending.

As this L.A. Times report notes, many secrets have gone to the grave with Saddam, and questions remain unanswered:

Mahmoud Othman, a Kurdish legislator, said he had hoped Hussein would be questioned about the Anfal campaign, a brutal military operation that killed as many as tens of thousands of Kurds by gunfire and poison gas. Hussein was the chief defendant in the ongoing Anfal genocide trial, and Othman said he was worried that the ex-dictator's execution would undermine those proceedings and other planned cases.

Othman said Hussein should have been forced to testify about his involvement in poison gas attacks in the Kurdish town of Halabja, where 5,000 are believed to have died; his brutal crackdown on southern towns after a 1991 Shiite uprising; his destruction of the southern marshlands and the homes of the Marsh Arab tribes and his alleged assassination orders against political opponents.

"Had these cases been brought to trial, a lot of information would have been revealed … about the bad policies of the old regime," said Othman, who believed that so many terrible revelations would have undermined support for the Sunni Arab-led insurgency in Iraq.

"No one could have defended the things we would have brought out in these trials," Othman said. "Shedding light on all that has happened is more important than the execution of one man."

The embarrassing details of the execution itself included onlookers with cellphone cameras chanting the name of Moktada Al-Sadr.

In U.S. Questioned Iraq on the Rush to Hang Hussein, the New York Times reports:

Iraqi and American officials who have discussed the intrigue and confusion that preceded the decision late on Friday to rush Mr. Hussein to the gallows have said that it was the Americans who questioned the political wisdom — and justice — of expediting the execution, in ways that required Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki to override constitutional and religious precepts that might have assured Mr. Hussein a more dignified passage to his end.

The Americans’ concerns seem certain to have been heightened by what happened at the hanging, as evidenced in video recordings made just before Mr. Hussein fell through the gallows trapdoor at 6:10 a.m. on Saturday. A new video that appeared on the Internet late Saturday, apparently made by a witness with a camera cellphone, underscored the unruly, mocking atmosphere in the execution chamber.

This continued, on the video, through the actual hanging itself, with a shout of “The tyrant has fallen! May God curse him!” as Mr. Hussein hung lifeless, his neck snapped back and his glassy eyes open.

The cacophony from those gathered before the gallows included a shout of “Go to hell!” as the former ruler stood with the noose around his neck in the final moments, and his riposte, barely audible above the bedlam, which included the words “gallows of shame.” It continued despite appeals from an official-sounding voice, possibly Munir Haddad, the judge who presided at the hanging, saying, “Please no! The man is about to die.”

The Shiites who predominated at the hanging began a refrain at one point of “Moktada! Moktada! Moktada!”— the name of a volatile cleric whose private militia has spawned death squads that have made an indiscriminate industry of killing Sunnis — appending it to a Muslim imprecation for blessings on the Prophet Muhammad. “Moktada,” Mr. Hussein replied, smiling contemptuously. “Is this how real men behave?”

American officials in Iraq have been reluctant to say much publicly about the pell-mell nature of the hanging, apparently fearful of provoking recriminations in Washington, where the Bush administration adopted a hands-off posture, saying the timing of the execution was Iraq’s to decide.

While privately incensed at the dead-of-night rush to the gallows, the Americans here have been caught in the double bind that has ensnared them over much else about the Maliki government — frustrated at what they call the government’s failure to recognize its destructive behavior, but reluctant to speak out, or sometimes to act, for fear of undermining Mr. Maliki and worsening the situation.

Blogger and lawyer Glen Greenwald comments:

This depressing New York Times article by John Burns and Marc Santora details the frantic, reckless manner in which Saddam Hussein was shoved into the noose in clear violation of Iraqi law. We can't even get a hanging right. With all of the world watching, we yet again were the primary authors of a violent, uncivilized, and primitive act which -- no matter how justified in some ultimate moral sense -- was carried out in the most thuggish, wretched, inept, and (we now learn) patently illegal manner.

It really is striking, and a potent sign of just how absurd is our ongoing occupation, that the "Iraqi Government" which we are fighting to empower could not even conduct this execution with a pretense of legality or concern for civilized norms -- the executioners were not wearing uniforms but leather jackets and murderers' masks, conducting themselves not as disciplined law enforcement officers but as what they are (death squad members and sectarian street thugs).

And the most revealing, and most disturbing, detail is that Saddam's executioners -- in between playground insults spat at a tied-up Saddam -- chanted their religious-like allegiance to Moktada Al Sadr, the Shiite militia leader whom we are told is the Great Enemy of the U.S., the One We Now Must Kill. This noble and just event for which we are responsible was carried out by a brutal, murderous, lawless militia. Freedom is on the march.

... The article details the "frantic quest" by the Iraqi government to concoct legal contrivances -- any at all -- to "justify" the immediate hanging despite the court's order.

They finally compiled enough pretty, signed "decrees" to secure the Bush administration's approval to carry out the hanging. But the rush to snap Saddam's neck did not allow enough time for all laws to be "workedaround." Some laws standing in the way of the hanging had to be deliberately disregarded:

Mr. Maliki had one major obstacle: the Hussein-era law proscribing executions during the Id holiday. This remained unresolved until late Friday, the Iraqi official said. He said he attended a late-night dinner at the prime minister’s office at which American officers and Mr. Maliki’s officials debated the issue.

One participant described the meeting this way: “The Iraqis seemed quite frustrated, saying, ‘Who is going to execute him, anyway, you or us?’ The Americans replied by saying that obviously, it was the Iraqis who would carry out the hanging. So the Iraqis said, ‘This is our problem and we will handle the consequences. If there is any damage done, it is we who will be damaged, not you.’ ”

Or, put another way, the Iraqi Government -- revealingly "frustrated" by the need to pretend to operate within the law -- knew that hanging Saddam in this manner was illegal, but they did it anyway because they know there will be no consequences.

And now, MSNBC reports that the predictable Sunni backlash has apparently begun:

Enraged crowds protested the hanging of Saddam Hussein across Iraq's Sunni heartland Monday, as a mob in Samara broke the locks off a bomb-damaged Shiite shrine and marched through carrying a mock coffin and photo of the dictator.

The demonstration in the Golden Dome, shattered in a bombing by Sunni extremists 10 months ago, suggests that many Sunni Arabs may now more actively support the small number of Sunni militants fighting the country's Shiite-dominated government. The Feb. 22 bombing of the shrine triggered the current cycle of retaliatory attacks between Sunnis and Shiia, in the form of daily bombings, kidnappings and murders.

Until Saddam's execution Saturday, most Sunnis sympathized with militants but avoided taking a direct role in the sectarian conflict -- despite attacks by Shiite militia that have killed thousands of Sunnis or driven them from their homes. The current Sunni protests, which appear to be building, could signal a spreading militancy.

Sunnis were not only outraged by Saddam's hurried execution, just four days after an appeals court upheld his conviction and sentence. Many were also incensed by the unruly scene in the execution chamber, captured on video, in which Saddam was taunted with chants of "Muqtada, Muqtada, Muqtada."

The chants referred to Muqtada al-Sadr, a firebrand Shiite cleric who runs one of Iraq's most violent religious militias. He is a major power behind the government of Shiite Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.

It is ever-increasingly clear that the longer the U.S. presence in Iraq remains, the dirtier (and bloodier) its hands will inevitably become.

-Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: http://www.wiselaw.net/

Friday, December 29, 2006

The Execution of Saddam

The execution of Saddam Hussein, now expected tonight, should not occur until each and every charge against him has been heard and decided in a legitimate court of law.

With the U.S. handover of Saddam reportedly imminent, and Iraqi officials publicly differing on execution timing, the Associated Press reports that the U.S. Courts are now being asked to intervene:


Lawyers for Saddam Hussein on Friday made a last-minute appeal to an American court to avert execution in Iraq, asking a judge to block his transfer from U.S. custody to the hands of Iraqi officials.

Hussein's lawyers filed documents Friday afternoon asking for an emergency restraining order aimed at stopping the U.S. government from relinquishing custody of the condemned former Iraqi leader to Iraqi officials, a spokeswoman for a federal court in Washington D.C. said.

... The appeals court did not indicate when it would rule on the issue

I have always found the death penalty barbaric in all circumstances, including this one.

I will admit, however, that while I remain opposed to this execution, the implementation of the death penalty against an actual barbarian such as Saddam troubles me quite a bit less than is often the case.

What does acutely trouble me , however, is the obvious rush to the gallows.

Leaving aside all the irregularities regarding his trial, and the obvious issues surrounding hanging as a mode of execution, Saddam has to date been tried for but one set of his many atrocities, the 1982 killing of 143 Shiite civilians in the Iraqi village of Dujail.

These murders, however brutal, did not represent his most evil and premeditated crimes against Iraq and humanity.

In fact, even now, a second trial is ongoing with respect to charges that chemical weapons were used against Kurds during the "Anfal" campaigns in the 1980's. See this April 2006 report from Jurist Legal News and Research regarding the remaining charges:

The Iraqi High Criminal Court announced Tuesday that new genocide and crimes against humanity charges have been filed against Saddam Hussein [JURIST news archive] and six others in his former regime's crackdown against the Kurds during the 1980s.

The new charges were filed with a different judge than the one handling his current trial for the 1982 massacre of 148 Shiite villagers in Dujail.

According to Iraqi law, the second trial against Saddam may begin in as soon as 45 days. The charges stem from Saddam's role in Operation Anfal that culminated in a gas attack against Kurds in the village of Halabja, which killed 5,000 civilians including women and children. The current Operation Anfal charges, however, do not cover the Halabja attack.

Court spokesman Raid Juhi has said that there will be a separate trial on that attack. Reuters has more.

The Saddam Hussein Trial Blog has background on whether Operation Anfal constitutes genocide. Iraqi President Jalal Talabani also said Tuesday that he expects Saddam to be tried in all the cases against him before the court reaches a final verdict. (emphasis added).

Authorities have said there could be up to a dozen proceedings against the former dictator and each case could result in a death sentence if the court finds him guilty.

In this context, I would like to address the too-often overlooked history of Saddam's brutality against the Jews of Iraq.
The Iraqi Jewish community, numbered at around 150,000 in 1948, was almost entirely driven out of the country by increasing persecution from the 1940s onwards. Today, fewer than 100 Jews remain.
Carole Basri, adjunct professor at the University of Pennsylvania Law School and author of a case study of the ethnic cleansing of Iraqi Jews, indicates that while the vast majority of Jews had fled Iraq by the mid-1960's, the persecution continued:
There was a rather gruesome public hanging in 1969,for example.

... Nine Jews were hung in the public square. Actually, Saddam Hussein was behind that hanging. In 1968 there was a coup by the Baathists, with al-Bakr, who is the uncle of Saddam Hussein, installed as president.

He tells Saddam to put together a security force that was similar to the Gestapo and to start the torture chambers. As the first group of victims he picks the Jews; they were the most defenseless. At this point, the Jews were not allowed to have telephones in their homes or offices, and they were not permitted to travel more than three-quarters of a mile from their home - there were 3,500 Jewish people left at that point, and this was after the 1967 Six Day War.

Yet in a community under that kind of repression they were charged with being American spies. So under this situation Saddam brought to trial nine Jews, who are hung in the public square. Now what this does for Saddam is it gives him a way to test out how much repression he can allow in the country and whether anyone will speak out.

He also hung a few other people, who were not Jewish. But there was an outcry after this incident, as well as after some hangings in August 1969 of Jews in Basra. After that, the Arab world said "We're looking barbaric to the world, we can't do this anymore." So then Saddam had his agents pull people who were Jewish off the streets and they were never seen again.
Among the missing and murdered were Daoud Zubaida, the late grandfather of my significant other, and many others whose legacies will forever live on in the hearts and memories of their families, now dispersed worldwide.
Executing Saddam before he has answered for all his crimes is a moral, legal and political outrage.

If this "process" is partially about healing and putting the past behind in troubled Iraq, this imminent execution is about to deprive most of his victims of the opportunity to voice the truth regarding the man responsible for the death, degradation and suffering of so many.

While I understand that trials of Saddam are expected to continue, even after his death in his absence, I doubt that many will be listening.

The rush to bury Saddam before his entire legacy of brutality is exposed will do little to bring about reconciliation and healing.
It will simply silence him - and his remaining, unheard victims, forever.

That is an offense to the memory and suffering of far too many.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, December 15, 2006

Toronto Family Court Judge: Move Christmas Tree from Courthouse Lobby

Has the "War on Christmas" come north?

This AFP report seems to imply as much:

A Canadian judge has ordered the removal of a Christmas tree from a Toronto courthouse lobby, saying it might offend non-Christians.

In a letter to staff on Wednesday, Justice Marion Cohen said the decorated tree made non-Christians feel "they are not part of this institution" and was an inappropriate symbol to greet visitors.

But the judge's order prompted an angry reaction on Thursday.

"There's no reason why a Christmas tree can't be put wherever people want it to be. It's by no means an offense, I believe, to any religion," an attorney told broadcaster CTV.

Ontario premier Dalton McGuinty called the decision "unfortunate."

"We enjoy the wonderful privilege of building a pluralistic, multicultural society," he told the Toronto Star. But no one should be "asked to abandon their traditions

... Still, the artificial tree was moved to an administrative corridor in the courthouse.

More than 70 percent of Canadians identified themselves as Christian, including almost 13 million Roman Catholics, in the last census in 2001. Muslims account for about two percent of the population. Jews, Buddhists, Hindus and Sikhs each represent about one percent.

CTV news had a similar take:

A Toronto judge has ordered a Christmas tree out of a downtown provincial courthouse lobby, saying it's not an appropriate symbol to non-Christians.

The move by Justice Marion Cohen has upset staff, some of whom call the decision stupid and insulting.

Cohen says she understands the small tree has stood in the lobby at 311 Jarvis St. for years during the Christmas season, but in a letter to employees says non-Christians are "confronted" with the artificial decoration, which makes them feel "they are not part of this institution.''

The judge, who oversees administration at the courthouse, said it's inappropriate that a Christian symbol is the first thing visitors see when they enter the building.

A number of Christmas trees are on full display inside other public institutions, including at the Ontario legislature, Toronto City Hall and at Nathan Phillips Square. There are also trees inside the Old City Hall courts.

Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty on Thursday slammed the judge's order. "I think that's unfortunate,'' McGuinty said. "I think it represents a misunderstanding of what we are working so hard to build here in Ontario."

I wasn't expecting this issue to emerge in Toronto.

In fact, until reading the Premier's comments, I wasn't even aware we had a recent tradition of Christmas trees in courthouse lobbies. Silly me... now I know.

I can already hear the Bill O'Reilly gang jumping all over this as Friday's "outrage of the day."

I am left wondering a bit about how and why this tree became an issue at all. It seems a rather contrived "controversy."

We are all better served when these polarizing cultural flashpoints are avoided.

On balance, however, if any decision had to be made at all, I think Madame Justice Cohen is probably right about this.

The public attending at this particular courthouse is comprised of as diverse an ethnic mosaic as will be found anywhere in this City. Justice Cohen's intervention was a small gesture, cognizant of the many sensibilities of those "stakeholders" we hear so much about, these days.

It hardly constitutes headline news, folks .

The tree was not incinerated by judicial edict, for goodness sake! It was simply relocated to a less central location.

That said, I still can't help the fleeting thought that anything that might inspire a bit of added, seasonal goodwill at Family Law courthouses like "311" can't be that bad an idea...

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, December 11, 2006

The Impeachment Drumbeat Quietly Begins

Update:

January 1, 2007

I started writing this entry in mid-December, around the time James Baker's Iraqi Study Group Report was released.

I never got around to finishing it, but with the official changeover of the U.S. Congress tomorrow, I thought this would be a good time to post it.

....................................................

It's beginning...

Firedoglake identifies the problem presented by the status quo, in this quote from the New York Times:

Andrew H. Card Jr., the president’s chief of staff until last spring, said that whatever Mr. Bush did in Iraq would probably fall short of many of the commission’s recommendations, and that he was likely to continue making decisions that he believed were right even if unpopular. Referring to Mr. Bush’s secret intelligence briefings, Mr. Card said, “The president by definition knows more than any of those people who are serving on these panels.”

Vanity Fair's James Wolcott nicely frames the question:

So how long is Bush going to be allowed to persist in his folly, to stubbornly reiterate his determination to see the mission through as if he were Captain Ahab on the heaving deck? Too many American lives hang in the balance to indulge his delusions any further, or those of his knavish footmen.

In Particles Of Impeachment, Poputonian adds:

So what are we waiting for? George W. Bush had better strap on his Codpiece, and Dick Cheney had better grab his cholestrol-infested ass. I think the rank and file are coming after them.

At Huffington Post, Steve Young's If Lying About War's Reality is Impeachable, Start the Proceedings lays some groundwork.

Lie once, you're a liar.

If this administration has been deceiving the American public over what has been taking place in the war, can we believe them when they say they do not torture? Can we believe them about anything?

Impeachable? Sending the country into a war based on lies still must be investigated to nail down any culpability. Keeping this country in a deadly war based on lies?

Friend of the family, Jim Baker, just confirmed it: this President is guilty.

The impeachment drumbeat. Quietly, but surely, it has begun.

I suspect its volume will only increase in 2007.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Sunday, December 03, 2006

Stéphane Dion: "Under my leadership, Canada will not fail the world"

Stéphane Dion has been elected the 11th leader of the Liberal Party of Canada.

He outdistanced Michael Ignatieff at this weekend's federal leadership convention in Montreal, with a fourth and final ballot win. Dion drew 2,521 votes (54 %), ahead of Ignatieff's 2,084 votes (45%).

Considered a "dark horse" candidate by some, Dion rose to victory from a fourth place finish on Friday's first ballot. The first ballot had been won by Ignatieff, widely regarded as the early frontrunner.

Dion, a 55 year old native of Quebec City, was first elected to Parliament in 1996. He previously served in the Cabinets of Prime Ministers Jean Crétien and Paul Martin.

He is perhaps best known to Canadians for his previous role as Unity Minister, in which he initiated the 2000 Clarity Act, establishing firm federal protocols for dealing with Quebec sovereignists' aspitations within a Constituitional framework.

His leadership campaign adopted a "three-pillar approach," focusing on social justice, economic prosperity, and environmental sustainability.

In his speech to the Leadership Convention on Friday, Dion had rallied the party for an imminent election, and directly challenged the Conservative government of Prime Minister Stephen Harper:

Eleven years ago, Jean Chrétien invited me to join his government to help keep Canada united, to bring clarity about the unity of our country. I stood up for Canada. And I delivered for my Prime Minister, my party and my country.

Two years ago, Paul Martin invited me to stand up for Canada’s environment – the most important challenge of our generation and the next. And I delivered for my Prime Minister, my party and my country.

Today, I humbly stand to serve you once again.

...Today we face a very right-wing Government, much more like the current US Republican Party than the old Tories, the former Progressive Conservative Party of Canada.

Canada has a Prime Minister who thinks that the United States is not only our ally, but also our model.

A Prime Minister who would have immersed us in the Iraq nightmare.


A Prime Minister who, last Spring, blackmailed Parliament with the threat of an election, in order to impose on Canada, blindly, two more years in Afghanistan with no clear mandate.

A Prime Minister who is mirroring the style of his hero to the point that President Bush should be getting royalties from Mr. Harper’s speeches.

A Prime Minister who imposes ideological cuts to women, aboriginal people, official language communities, literacy, arts and culture.

...A Prime Minister who – make no mistake -- is undermining the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, sending a chilling signal for what he intends to do if he gets a majority government.

... A Prime Minister who tore up our Climate Change Plan, Project Green, which would have allowed us to honour our international Kyoto Commitments. Instead, he’s put forward an inept Clean Air Act, which is nothing more than an excuse not to act, a smokescreen.

A Prime Minister who is virtually pulling us out of Kyoto.

Remember that a year ago, here in the Montreal Convention Center, in the name of Canada, I presided over a United Nations conference which brought the world together, 182 nations, for a joint action plan against the greatest ecological threat facing humanity: climate change.

And this year, at the same Conference in Nairobi, this Conservative government has shamefully failed the world and tarnished Canada’s international reputation.

What a disgraceful way to govern.

I helped bring the world together to fight Climate Change. Since then, Stephen Harper has wedged the world apart.

Well, my fellow liberals, the world needs Canada. Under my leadership, Canada will not fail the world.

For more background, extensive biographies of Dion are here, here and here.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Saturday, December 02, 2006

The Saudi Executioner



Meet Abdallah Bin Sa'id Al-Bishi, the Saudi Executioner.

Full video is here of a shocking, almost numbingly matter-of-fact interview, conducted by Lebanese television network LBC-TV in November, 2006.

No further commentary could do justice to this repugnance. The banality of evil, to borrow from Hannah Arendt, lives on.






















For more on Saudi "justice," including reference to Al-Bishi, see Amnesty International's Saudi Arabia report.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, November 23, 2006

Israeli Court: Israel Must Recognize Canadian Same-Sex Marriages

Haaretz reports today that on November 21, 2006, the Israeli High Court ruled that the State of Israel must register the marriages of five same-sex couples who were married in Toronto:

In a precedent-setting ruling, the High Court of Justice on Tuesday ruled that five gay couples wedded outside of Israel can be registered as married couples. A sweeping majority of six justices to one ruled that the civil marriages of five gay couples obtained in Toronto, Canada, can appear as married on the population registry. The gay petitioners sought to force the state to give equal recognition to common law marriages of heterosexual couples to those of gay marriages, which can be performed in certain countries.

... The court rejected the position of the State Attorney, that states recognizing single-sex marriages cannot expect Israel to recognize such nuptial agreements drawn in these countries. The state told the High Court that "Israel lacks the appropriate legal framework for such marriages," and therefore it cannot register them. After the ruling was issued, the Civil Rights Association said it is "all the more important in the wake of the [recent] public turmoil stirred by the gay pride parade in Jerusalem."

Haaretz is an independent Israeli daily newspaper published in Tel Aviv.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net/family.html

Wednesday, November 22, 2006

B.C. Native Justin Morneau wins AL MVP

While it has nothing to do with the usual content of this Blog, in the interests of CanCon and Canuck pride, it's worth noting that New Westminster, British Columbia's own Justin Morneau has been named the American League's Most Valuable Player.

A first baseman with the Minnesota Twins, Morneau had a .321 average, 34 homers and 130 RBIs in 2006, helping the Twins to make the playoffs.

A bit more background, from his Wikipedia bio:

Morneau is a 1999 graduate of New Westminster Secondary School, where he was named the New Westminster High School Athlete of the year and was a member of Canadian national champion baseball teams in 1997 and 1998. In 1998, he was selected the best hitter and catcher of the National Championships.

He was selected by the Twins in 3rd round as the 89th overall pick of the 1999 MLB amateur entry draft.

And from Yahoo:

Morneau became the second Canadian-born player to win [a baseball] MVP following Colorado's Larry Walker in 1997. He is the third Canadian-born athlete to win an MVP in a major pro league this year, following Phoenix Suns' guard Steve Nash and San Jose Sharks' center Joe Thornton.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, November 20, 2006

List of Lawsuits against Bloggers

A site link to start off the week....

The Media Law Resource Centre's listing of Libel and Related Lawsuits Against Bloggers, compiled by MLRC Staff Attorney Eric P. Robinson, provides an interesting look at what may apparently be a growing, new legal enterprise in America.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, November 14, 2006

Toronto University Professors win Right to Use Medical Marijuana at Work

While a bit lean on details, an interesting development in Ontario human rights and employment law was reported today by CNN:

Canada profs win right to smoke pot

The use of medical marijuana has given two Toronto professors the right to something that many students could only dream of -- access to specially ventilated rooms where they can indulge in peace.

The two, at the esteemed University of Toronto and at York University to the north of the city, suffer from chronic medical conditions that some doctors say can be eased by smoking marijuana. They are among nearly 1,500 Canadians who have won the right to use the drug for health reasons. Using human rights legislation, the two petitioned their employers for the right to light up in the workplace. They faced a legal struggle, but the universities eventually agreed.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Google Opposes Australian Copyright Law: May 'cripple' online searching

ABC (Australia) reports that Google is lobbying Australian lawmakers in opposition to proposed copyright legislation in that nation.

According to the article, Google is concerned that the new law may place constraints on the legal entitlement of search engines to maintain cached copies of copyright-protected materials.

These cached page "snapshots" are collected and maintained by Google and other search engines for indexing and search retrieval purposes:

"Plugging a word or phrase into a search engine may soon give you fewer results if proposed new Australian copyright laws are adopted, according to internet giant Google.

The laws could open the way for Australian copyright owners to take action against search engines for caching and archiving material, Google says in a submission to a senate committee considering the legislation.

This could potentially limit the scope of the search engine results, which the internet company describes as effectively 'condemning the Australian public to the pre-internet era."

"Given the vast size of the internet it is impossible for a search engine to contact personally each owner of a web page to determine whether the owner desires its web page to be searched, indexed or cached," Google submits."If such advance permission was required, the internet would promptly grind to a halt."

- Garry J. Wise Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Ex-Rock Star John Hall Wins Upset for Congress

While I'll have more to say later on the big-picture of yesterday's mid-term elections, this story is an interesting political sidebar for music fans.

Editor and Publisher reports that John Hall, former leader of Orleans was one of the many Democratic Party candidates to have a surprise victory yesterday:

John Hall, leader of the rock group Orleans that recorded such hits as "Still the One" and "Dance With Me," has won a stunning upset in his race for Congress in upstate New York, narrowly defeating Republican incumbent Sue Kelly 51%-49%.

Update: November 9, 2006:
Crooks and Liars now has video of Hall's appearance last night on the Colbert Report. Hall sang the national anthem with Colbert (who wasn't too bad at all as a harmony singer) at the segment's end.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website - www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, November 07, 2006

Tuesday's Legal News

Here are today's headlines:


-Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net

Saturday, November 04, 2006

Net Neutrality Debate Comes to Canada

According to this article from Canadian Press, the debate in Canada over internet neutrality - or regulation of internet service providers' (ISP's) ability to favour selected content - has begun:

Industry Minister Maxime Bernier is currently poring over a report by the federally appointed Telecommunications Policy Review Panel that recommends changes to the Telecommunications Act, including replacing a clause on "unjust discrimination" that does little to either uphold the principles of Net neutrality or prevent it from being violated.

What telecom companies most want is to promote their own content, says Ben Scott of the American media watchdog Free Press and SavetheInternet.com. "If I'm Telus and I've just created my own Telus iTunes and I decide I want my Telus iTunes to work better than Apple's, well, too bad for Apple," says Scott in a telephone interview from
Washington, D.C.

"Essentially they set themselves up as gatekeepers and they say: 'Well, we own the wires and instead of treating all bits alike in a non-discriminatory fashion, we're going to set up special deals and if you have the money, you can pay us to make your websites go much faster. And you can pay us to set up an exclusive deal where your website goes very fast and your competitor's doesn't.' "

Net neutrality has been a cause celebre for bloggers and media watchdogs in the U.S. for quite some time. It has critical implications for the future direction of the internet in Canada.

The current internet environment is one of unfettered, equal opportunity for small businesses and previously unheard voices.

Professional marketers often remark that the internet is a "level communications playing field" that makes it possible for smaller enterprises to compete globally with ease and clout. The costs of global access would have been entirely prohibitive in prior times.

Net neutrality is the legal vehicle for maintaning democratized, equal access. The emerging debate is a critical one.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: www.wiselaw.net