Tuesday, February 18, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Monday, February 18, 2014

 Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Monday, February 18, 2014:

- Elysia Cherry, Legal Assistant 
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, February 14, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Friday, February 14, 2014

- Elysia Cherry, Legal Assistant 
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, February 13, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Thursday, February 13, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Thursday, February 13, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Jones v. Tsige - Revisiting the Tort of Invasion of Privacy

BY NITIN PARDAL, LAWYER, WISE LAW OFFICE

A year and a half ago, Ontario's highest court took the "incremental step" of recognizing the tort of invasion of privacy in the seminal decision of Jones v. Tsige.  In the first of a two-part series, this blog post will summarize this cause of action. In a follow-up post, we will examine how this tort has been interpreted and applied by lower courts.

Brief History:

The plaintiff and defendant worked at different branches of the Bank of Montreal, but never knew or worked with one another. Over the course of four years, the defendant used her workplace computer to access the plaintiff’s personal bank accounts. The information displayed included transactions details, as well as personal information such as the plaintiff's date of birth, marital status and address. The defendant did not publish, distribute or record this information in any way.

The plaintiff asserted that her privacy interests in her confidential banking information were “irreversibly destroyed” and claimed damages of $70,000 for invasion of privacy and breach of fiduciary duty, and punitive and exemplary damages of $20,000.

The Tort of "Inclusion upon Seclusion"

Recognizing that "the time ha[d] come to recognize invasion of privacy as a tort in its own right," the Ontario Court of Appeal laid out a four-step test, whereby a plaintiff must establish:

1.   that an unauthorized intrusion occurred;
2.   that the intrusion was highly offensive (according to the standards of a reasonable person);
3.   the matter intruded upon was private; and,
4.   the intrusion caused anguish and suffering.

The first element of the tort requires that the defendant’s conduct be intentional (irrespective of whether or not it is reckless). The court insisted that the first element focuses on the act of the intrusion, rather than the dissemination or publication of information. Accordingly the first element is satisfied if an unauthorized intrusion occurs, regardless of how minor.

For the second element to be satisfied, factors to be considered are the degree of the intrusion, the context, conduct and circumstances of the intrusion, the intruder's motives and objectives and the expectations of those whose privacy is invaded.

The third element of the test places a burden on the plaintiff to establish that the expectation of seclusion or solitude was objectively reasonable. Considering privacy is both a subjective and objective right, this is a two-step analysis, first considering the actual subjective expectation of the privacy interests involved and then looking at whether that expectation was objectively reasonable.

Finally, at the fourth element anguish and suffering are generally presumed once the first three elements have been established.

What Breaches does this Tort Cover?

Cognizant of the fact that recognizing privacy as a tort had the potential of opening floodgates of claims from individuals who were overly sensitive or unusually concerned about their privacy, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that a claim for intrusion upon seclusion would only arise if there was a deliberate and significant invasion of one's personal privacy.

The Court provided examples of intrusions which would justify this threshold:
  • Intrusion upon one's financial records;
  • Intrusion upon one's health records;
  • Intrusion pertaining to one's sexual practices and orientation;
  • Intrusion pertaining to one's employment;
  • Intrusion pertaining to one's diary or private correspondence.
Quantum of Damages under this Tort

Considering the intangible nature of an individual's privacy interests and the fact that a plaintiff typically does not suffer pecuniary losses as a result of an invasion of privacy, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that damages ought to "be modest but sufficient to mark the wrong that has been done." Accordingly, the maximum award one can receive under this head of damages is limited to $20,000.
- Nitin Pardal, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

“Assisted” Reproduction – Oh, the Irony!

BY ANA KRALJEVIC, LAWYER, WISE LAW OFFICE

The federal government enacted the Assisted Human Reproduction Act in 2004 in an effort to regulate reproductive technologies and to prevent its commercialization.  However, when examining the practical effects of its provisions, it would appear that the title is a complete misnomer insofar as it has effectively rendered the most routine and elementary aspects of assisted reproduction illegal.  The Act prohibits the purchase and sale of sperm and eggs, and, in doing so, has virtually eradicated the legitimate supply of genetic material in Canada. 

The purchase of sperm and eggs in Canada invokes severe criminal sanctions – ten years in jail and a $500,000 fine.  Infanticide, prohibited by S. 233 of the Criminal Code, carries only a five year sentence thus leading to the legal anomaly that it is criminally worse to make a baby than to kill one.  However, despite the severe punitive consequences that accompany breaking these laws, the utter lack of enforcement seemed to suggest the condonation of these activities.

Unlike other regulated products, the business of paying for sperm, eggs, and surrogates, is not as covert and hush-hush an operation as other illicit markets.  The sale of sperm, eggs, and the marketing of surrogates is conspicuous and widespread across the internet on popular websites like Kijiji and Craigslist.  There are also fertility clinics that have not been complying with law as a matter of routine business practice.  The utter lack of enforcement of the laws, despite the severe punitive sanctions, is likely what encouraged a laissez faire attitude towards its adherence and lulled the fertility industry into a false sense of security.  That is, until February 2013, when a fertility company, known as Canadian Fertility Consultants (CFC) was raided by the RCMP.   Leia Picard, an Ontario surrogacy consultant, and her company, were charged with 27 offences under both the Assisted Human Reproduction Act and the Criminal Code.  
This occurred after a year-long investigation into the activities of the full-service consultancy firm in Brighton, Ontario, which also had a branch in Comox, British Columbia.  For what Ms. Picard’s web site describes as a “fixed price,” she provided assistance to parents in finding a surrogate mother to carry their child and sometimes arranged for a donor to provide eggs, alongside other services. 


This type of crackdown, the first Canadian enforcement of its kind, will deprive vulnerable parents of the assistance of companies like CPC who help navigate them through the complex and emotional process of surrogacy motherhood without being exploited.  


Ms. Rhoads- Heirich, who runs Surrogacy in Canada Online, a company similar to CPC, comments:   “It’s a really sad day for Canadians, and for the babies that won’t be born.  If we have to cease working, it means they’re on their own and more subject to being taken advantage of … They’re just left with Kijiji and Craigslist.”

- Ana Kraljevic, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Wednesday, February 12, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Tuesday, February 11, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, February 10, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Monday, February 10, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Monday, February 10, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, February 07, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Friday, February 7, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Friday, February 7, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, February 06, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Thursday, February 6, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Thursday, February 6, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, February 05, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Wednesday, February 5, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, February 04, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Tuesday, February 4, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law 
Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, February 03, 2014

140 Law - Legal Headlines for Monday, February 3, 2014

Here are the leading legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter for Monday, February 3, 2014:
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net