Showing posts with label Quebec Civil Code. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quebec Civil Code. Show all posts

Friday, July 17, 2009

Quebec Common Law Spouse Loses Constitutional Challenge, Denied Spousal Support, Property Division

A Quebec billionaire's former common-law spouse has lost her constitutional challenge against provisions of Quebec's Civil Code that narrowly limit the entitlements of unmarried partners in the Province upon relationship breakdown.

She claimed payment of spousal support from her former spouse as well an entitlement to sharing of the family's property.

According to media reports, the former spouse already receives child support and related payments in excess of $35,000 monthly. The couple cohabited for approximateky ten years.

The former spouse indicates that she intends to appeal the decision.

Montreal Gazette reports on the ruling of Quebec's Superior Court:

MONTREAL — The former common-law spouse of a Quebec billionaire has lost her bid to get the same rights and obligations as people who are legally married.

After a heated and sometimes emotional court case last January, Superior Court Justice Carole Hallee issued her 63-page judgment Thursday, saying that recognizing all couples as "married" would remove some people's freedom of choice not to marry.

She also said that no evidence was presented that showed treatment of common-law couples was discriminatory — a comment that had lawyer Anne-France Goldwater scratching her head, wondering "if we were in the same trial."

Goldwater, who represented the woman, said she will appeal all the way to the Supreme Court if necessary.

"Social change comes slowly (because) you have to fight people who are entrenched," she said. "Nobody fights discrimination who hasn't lived it and it's going to take going to higher courts."

The woman known as "Lola" lost her constitutional challenge on Thursday to try to get unmarried couples treated the same as married couples when their relationships end.

Lola asked the Quebec Superior Court to strike down a series of federal and provincial laws. She also asked for a $50-million lump-sum payment from her former spouse and $56,000 a month in alimony.

...Quebec Superior Court Justice Carole Hallée said under existing law, partners in a common-law relationship have no rights, no duties and no responsibilities to each other; no matter how many years they've lived together.

...The judge said current laws do, in fact, protect the rights of unmarried people who choose to live together.

We have previously written about this case in March, 2008 and in January, 2009:

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Parental Authority in Quebec

On April 6, 2009, the Quebec Court of Appeal issued an interesting decision about parental authority.

In this case, the father has custody of his daughter, a 12 years old child. The child was represented by an attorney with respect to the court case pending between her parents.

At one point, as a matter of punishment, the father decided not to authorize his daughter to participate in an activity organized by her school, a trip to Quebec City. The mother was agreeing to have the child go to this trip, but she did not institute any proceedings with respect to this situation.

The child herself, represented by her attorney, petitioned the court in order to be authorized to go to this trip and, in fact, to contest the father’s decision.

According to the Civil Code of Quebec, the child is under the parental authority of both parents. Whether custody is entrusted to one of the parents or to a third person, and whatever the reasons may be, the father and the mother retain the right to supervise the maintenance and education of the children, and are bound to contribute thereto in proportion to their means.

In this case, the Quebec Court of Appeal has ruled that the decision relating to this trip was not of a routine nature, but something that is within the scope of the common right to supervise attributed to both parents.

Consequently, the father had no right to oppose a veto to that trip to Quebec.

In this case however the tribunal had not been seized by the mother but by the child herself. So, it was not court litigation on difficulty in exercising parental authority, but rather on effect of parental authority over the child.

The Civil Code of Quebec states that a minor may, with the authorization of the court, institute alone an action relating to his or her status and to the exercise of parental authority (among other situations).

Of course, the authorization to institute such court actions alone cannot be granted for reasons that are not serious, and it is true that the Court cannot be a place where all the children could contest any punishment from one of their parents (or both).

In this case, the Court of Appeal has ruled that the judge had reasonably exercised her discretionary power to authorize the child to institute her motion.

On the merit of the case, the father’s decision not to authorize the child to go to this trip to Quebec City was set aside.

This shows that, in theory, in Quebec any important decision taken by a parent with respect to parental authority could be contested in court by a minor child.

Distinct society, as we say.

- Christian Dufourd, Montreal

Me Christian Dufourd is Member of the Bar of Quebec
(Montreal section)and practices law in Montreal with
Dufourd, Dion Avocats. The firm focuses on family law, civil law, immigration, criminal law and business law. He can be reached by email at cdufourd@dufourdion.com. This commentary is intended for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult with a lawyer for information regarding your own specific circumstances.

.........................................................................

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG