Showing posts with label child support guidelines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label child support guidelines. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 09, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday August 9, 2017.

Today we are talking about Family Law.


The amount of child support payable by a non-custodial parent is strictly governed by the Child Support Guidelines. The Guideline tables establish basic child support obligations and are based solely on the payor’s income, number of children, and province of residence.

In addition to the basic child support payable under the Guidelines, additional amounts may be payable to cover special and extraordinary expenses incurred for a child’s daycare, medical care, education and extra-curricular activities like hockey and ballet. These additional expenses are shared by the parents in proportion to their respective incomes
For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit our website at http://www.wiselaw.net.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, May 03, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday May 3, 2017. Today we are talking about Family Law.





The amount of child support payable by a non-custodial parent is strictly governed by the Child Support Guidelines. The Guideline tables establish basic child support obligations and are based solely on the payor’s income, number of children, and province of residence.

In addition to the basic child support payable under the Guidelines, additional amounts may be payable to cover special and extraordinary expenses incurred for a child’s daycare, medical care, education and extra-curricular activities like hockey and ballet. These additional expenses are shared by the parents in proportion to their respective incomes.

For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit our website at www.wiselaw.net.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday April 12, 2017.

Today we are talking about Family Law.


The Child Support Guideline Table Look-up is a free tool to calculate child support payable according to the Canadian Federal Child Support Guidelines.

The table look-up allows you to determine the base amount for child support by inputting your annula income, number of children, and province of residence.

For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit us at www.wiselaw.net

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, February 01, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday February 1, 2017. Today we are talking about Family Law

For more information on employment law, family law, and wills, estates and estates litigation, visit our website at www.wiselaw.net.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

The Child Support Guideline Table Look-up is a free tool to calculate child support payable according to the Canadian Federal Child Support Guidelines.

The table look-up allows you to determine the base amount for child support by inputting your annual income, number of children, and province of residence.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, January 25, 2017

20 Years of Canada's Child Support Guidelines: Some Key Stats

BY PAUL B. ADAM, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 

Canada's Child Support Guidelines are 20 years young this year.

The guidelines were enacted in 1997 and created a single, comprehensive guideline for how child support payments are calculated. The Child Support Guideline tables can be looked up and used online by anyone a web browser.

Since being enacted, the guidelines have received both accolades and criticisms, as you would expect from a piece of legislation that has an impact on virtually every couple with children that separates in Canada.

But leaving all arguments aside, a survey of some key statistics involving children, women, and family law litigants show that transfer payments to divorced and single mother fill an important social need, and the current child support system works pretty well at getting those payments made.

It's worth re-examining what the goals of the Child Support Guidelines are, in order to understand why and how they fulfill those goals, however imperfectly:


 The objectives of these Guidelines are
  • (a) to establish a fair standard of support for children that ensures that they continue to benefit from the financial means of both spouses after separation;
  • (b) to reduce conflict and tension between spouses by making the calculation of child support orders more objective;
  • (c) to improve the efficiency of the legal process by giving courts and spouses guidance in setting the levels of child support orders and encouraging settlement; and
  • (d) to ensure consistent treatment of spouses and children who are in similar circumstances.

A: Fair Standard of Support:

The Guidelines were formulated in answer to the deceptively complicated question "How much does it cost to raise a kid?"

The answer, according to the guidelines is "40% of the cost of providing for an adult for the first child, and 30% for each additional child".

When looking back at the process that led to the creation of the guidelines, a formula was selected that yielded a higher "cost" per child than other economic formulas that were considered by the government during the consultation process.


An argument  cited by the advocacy group Fathers Are Capable Too is that this was a piece of social engineering that was intended to increase the amount of money that support recipients (who were- and are- overwhelmingly female) receive. Another argument, cited by the Conservative thinktank the Fraser Institute is that the "40/30" formula was developed to measure childcare costs at the poverty line, and that as incomes increase above and beyond $150,000, the Guidelines tend to overestimate the cost of child support.

Let's say one or both of these arguments was true. Is this fair?

Whatever one thinks about the guideline as a solution, the problems it attacks are real. Most children live with the mother, and mothers earn less than their male counterparts, and are over-represented in poverty statistics:
  1. 85% of child support payers are men and 70% of children primarily reside with their mother [Divorce Fact Sheet, 2016]
  2. Women still earn 73.5 cents for every male dollar, as of 2016. [Statscan/Globe & Mail, 2016]
  3. Single mothers have the highest poverty rate in Canada of any family type and are more likely to fall into poverty than single fathers following a separation. [Gadalla, 2008]
  4. In 2013, the median income among single parent families was $51,800 for male-led families and $39,400 for female-led families [Statscan]
  5. "Women's median income for the year of their separation or divorce dropped by about 30%, whereas men's median income decreased by only 6%" [Department of Justice, 2016]
  6. Children are 11 times more likely to fall into poverty following a separation or divorce [Statscan]
At the time the guidelines were enacted, the income disparity between women and men was worse than it was today. The penalty to women was exacerbated by the fact that child support used to be taxed in the hands of the recipient parent, but not the payer, an issue that was litigated up to the Supreme Court in Thibaudeau v Canada (1995).

Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms spells out that this is a country that believes in substantive equality, not just formal equality. That means it's possible, and appropriate, to create legislation that tries to proactively address social ills.

Legislation that addresses these problems was (and is still) necessary, especially when it minimizes the legal cost to parents of obtaining support for children.

Which brings us to Objectives B and C:

B+C: Reduce Conflict and Tension/Improve the Efficiency of the Legal Process:

Family Law is an incredibly expensive proposition. A huge portion of litigants are self-represented (estimates of this number are around 64%, but the real numbers may be higher), due in large part to unaffordable lawyer's fees. Yet despite the costs, family law cases are also extremely prevalent in Court. They make of 35% of all civil cases, far more than any other single type of litigation.

What the Child Support Guidelines help to do is take the issue of child support off the table, quickly.
Statscan published a valuable survey about our country's court system in 2012. It showed that while Child Support continues to be an issue, it is no longer a driving factor in most family law litigation, and it does not tend to tie family law cases in court for long.
  1. In separation cases that have gone to court, where the only issue relating to the children was child support, the issue is resolved in one third of cases after 6 months. Child support was resolved in just over half of cases after a year. In over 70% of cases, the issue is resolved after the two year mark.
  2. Cases where the only issue is child support make up only 8% of family law court cases. 
There used to be prevailing stereotypes about "deadbeat dads" in their legion who refused to pay child support. The reality is, though, child support is paid, at least in part, in the majority of cases where it is ordered.

In the provinces were data was collected from the government agency that was responsible for collecting child support (like Ontario's Family Responsibility Office), Statscan found in its most recent snapshot that around 70% of spouses enrolled in a program for collecting child support pay, and only about 10% of those enrolled don't pay regularly. Over the first few years of enrollment, most (80%) of child support owed gets paid. 

It's hard to know how many children of separated spouses are falling completely outside the legal system and are not being tracked by these numbers at all. But inside the legal system, there is some compelling evidence that child support gets paid most of the time, and that it happens without the issue being expensively litigated.

D: Consistency:

It's hard to argue that the Guidelines have not achieved consistency. Even if you do not agree with the scientific basis of the formula that the Guidelines have imposed, the rap on the Guidelines is that they sacrifice nuance and variability for the sake of achieving results, and certain socio/political objectives.

The biggest tribute to how well the Guidelines have worked is that the Court system has tried to replicate their success with the introduction of the Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines. The SSAG's are the statistical engine that drive automated software such as Divorcemate and they are nearly as influential as their older sister, though not technically even part of the law.

Since the introduction of the Child Support Guidelines, there have also been calls, including by this blog, for the further streamlining of family law cases by imposing a doctrine that all family law cases start with a presumption that the parents are entitled to joint custody, and then requiring a dissenting parent to prove a departure from this presumption is justified in the best interests of a child.

This, if implemented, would not be a perfect solution to the issue of custody, but would likely further reduce the number of litigants in the family law system.

The Child Support Guidelines are far from a perfect or precise measuring instrument, but I think the numbers unequivocally show that twenty years on, this piece of legislation is still useful and necessary. 
- Paul B. Adam, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, January 04, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday January 4, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


The amount of child support payable by a non-custodial parent is strictly governed by the Child Support Guidelines. The Guideline tables establish basic child support obligations and are based solely on the payor’s income, number of children, and province of residence. 

In addition to the basic child support payable under the Guidelines, additional amounts may be payable to cover special and extraordinary expenses incurred for a child’s daycare, medical care, education and extra-curricular activities like hockey and ballet. These additional expenses are shared by the parents in proportion to their respective incomes.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, October 13, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Thursday October 13, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.


A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

The Child Support Guideline Table Look-up is a free tool to calculate child support payable according to the Canadian Federal Child Support Guidelines.

The table look-up allows you to determine the base amount for child support by inputting you annual income, number of children, and province of residence.

Visit the Child Support Guideline Table Look-Up online for more information.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, September 21, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday September 21, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

In addition to the basic child support payable under the Guidelines, additional amounts may be payable to cover special and extraordinary expenses incurred for a child’s daycare, medical care, education and extra-curricular activities like hockey and ballet. 

These additional expenses are shared by the parents in proportion to their respective incomes. 

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, September 14, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday September 14, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

The amount of child support payable by a non-custodial parent is strictly governed by the Child Support Guidelines. 

The Guideline tables establish basic child support obligations and are based solely on the payor’s income, number of children, and province of residence.


- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, July 20, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday July 20, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

In difficult custody cases, a Court may request that the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL) become involved to investigate and make recommendations to the Court or to provide legal representation for a child.


The OCL is an Ontario government agency that employs lawyers and social workers. It works to provide independent information to the Court about a child’s needs, wishes and legal interests.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, June 02, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Thursday June 2, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


In addition to the basic child support payable under the Guidelines, additional amounts may be payable to cover special and extraordinary expenses incurred for a child’s daycare, medical care, education and extra-curricular activities like hockey and ballet. 

These additional expenses are shared by the parents in proportion to their respective incomes. 
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, January 31, 2014

The Post-Secondary "Child:" Guidelines Need Not Apply

BY ANA KRALJEVIC, LAWYER, WISE LAW OFFICE

Once a child reaches his or her eighteenth birthday, the age of majority, the question of whether that child is entitled to support becomes highly fact-driven and contextual. 


As J. D. Payne and M.A. Payne note in their text, Child Support Guidelines in Canada, 2012,:
Once a child attains the age of majority, the child is no longer presumptively entitled to support. The onus falls on the applicant [in this case the mother] to prove that an adult child who is pursuing post-secondary education is entitled to support...
The first question that is normally asked is whether the child can still be considered a child of the marriage.  

Canada's Divorce Act defines a “child of the marriage” as:
The child of two spouses or former spouses who, at the material time, 
(a) is under the age of majority and who has not withdrawn from their charge, or 
 (b) is the age of majority or over and under their charge but unable, by reason of illness, disability or other cause, to withdraw from their charge or to obtain the necessaries of life.
Once it is determined that the child over the age of majority is indeed a “child of the marriage,” the next question becomes whether the Guideline table amounts are applicable, having regard to the “means, needs, and other circumstances of the child” as well as the “financial ability of each spouse to contribute to the support of the child.”

Pursuant to s. 3(2) of the Guidelines, the court must decide whether the usual Guidelines approach is appropriate and is permitted some discretion in departing from the standard Table amount:
AMOUNT OF CHILD SUPPORT 
Child the age of majority or over 
3(2) Unless otherwise provided under these Guidelines, where a child to whom a child support order relates is the age of majority or over, the amount of the child support order is 
(a) the amount determined by applying these Guidelines as if the child were under the age of majority; or 
(b) if the court considers that approach to be inappropriate, the amount that it considers appropriate, having regard to the condition, means, needs and other circumstances of the child and the financial ability of each spouse to contribute to the support of the child.
Wesemann v. Wesemann, a 1999 British Columbia Supreme Court ruling, sets out a four step test that determines the appropriate model to be applied for the support of a child over the age of majority:
Step 1: Determine whether the child is a "child of the marriage" as defined in the Divorce Act.
Step 2: Determine whether the approach of applying the Guidelines as if the child were under the age of majority is challenged. If it is not challenged, determine the amount payable based on the usual "Guidelines" approach.
Step 3: If the usual Guidelines approach is challenged, decide whether the challenger has proven that the usual Guidelines approach is inappropriate. If not challenged, the usual Guidelines amount applies. 
Step 4: If the usual Guidelines approach is inappropriate, it is necessary to decide what amount is appropriate, having regard to the condition, means, needs and other circumstances of the child and the financial ability of each spouse to contribute to the support of the child.
In Gagnierv. Gagnier, [2003] O.J. No. 2183, the court noted that if the circumstances of a child over the age of majority closely resemble that of a child under the age of majority, it is likely that that usual Guidelines approach would be appropriate.  Therefore, if the child continues to reside at home with one or both parents, earns little to no income, and is generally dependent on others for support, then the usual Guidelines approach will probably be followed.  However, if a child over the age of majority resides away from home in order to attend a post-secondary school in another city, or, that child earns a sustainable income and shows self-sufficiency, the usual Guidelines approach may not be applicable. 

In this case, the child, Matthew, was nineteen years old when he left home in Ottawa and began attending Queen's University in Kingston on a full time basis. He was found to be “a child of the marriage.” As the mother challenged the Guidelines approach, the judge proceeded to Step 3 of the test.  The judge found that it would be inappropriate to apply the usual Guidelines approach to a determination of child support for the following reason:
The costs of attending university in another city are significantly greater than attending university while living at home. In addition, Matthew does not have a job or a significant income.
In applying Step 4 of the test, the judge found: “Considering all the circumstances of this case, I find it is reasonable that Matthew contribute $7,000 towards his university expenses from employment income, scholarships, student loans or gifts leaving a balance of $8,700 to be apportioned between the parties.”

In arriving at those two specific figures, the judge conducted a thorough analysis of Matthew’s reasonable needs, with respect to both post-secondary and personal expenses.  Given the judge’s finding that Matthew was a “bright, capable young man” he concluded that it was reasonable that he make a contribution towards his own education to help defray the costs of his education.  It was estimated that he could earn approximately $5,000 during the summer months through full-time employment and could apply for student loans to make up the rest.

The finding in this case is echoed in many other judicial decisions wherein the courts have found it appropriate for children to make reasonable contributions towards their education expenses. With the rising costs of post-secondary education and children taking longer to leave the nest, courts strive to create a balance that apportions the obligations of support fairly among all parties, and that includes the parents as well as the child. 

- Ana Kraljevic, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Intentional Under-Employment - Judges Tell Payors "Get a Real Job!"

When will Ontario's courts impute income to a parent for the purpose of calculating his or her child support obligations?

Section 19(1)(a) of the Child Support Guidelines grants the court the right to impute income to a parent if deemed appropriate to do so under the circumstances.  For example, the court may impute income to a payor parent above and beyond his or her reported earnings if the evidence indicates that the parent is intentionally under-employed or unemployed.  The decision of whether to impute income is guided by the consideration of the following factors: the age, education, experience, and skills of the parent as well as the parent’s past earning history and the projected quantum of income the parent could potentially earn if he worked to his capacity. 

A three-step test for imputing income was enunciated in the case of Drygala v. Pauli, 2002 Carswell Ont 3228 (C.A.):  
  1. The first step is to ascertain whether the father is intentionally under-employed.  The onus to establish this is on the parent seeking to impute income.  
  2. If the answer to this question is answered affirmatively, the second step is to ask whether the intentional under-employment is by virtue of the reasonable needs of the child or the reasonable educational or medical needs of the payor parent.  The onus to establish this second part of the test falls on the payor.  
  3. If the answer to this second question is no, the third and final step is to determine the amount of income that should be imputed.
The case of Rodrigues v. de Sousa, 2008 ONCJ 807 highlights the fact that the determination of what quantum to impute is highly discretionary and each case turns on its own individual and unique set of facts.  

For example, in Rodrigues, the court unequivocally found that the payor father was under-employed. 

Background:  

The parties lived together from 1992 until September 19, 2005 and had one child together.  At the time when the mother made a motion for interim child support against the payor father, he was sixty years old.  The mother took that position that the court should attribute income of $100,000 to him in light of his notable work history and credentials.

The father was an experienced life insurance salesperson and financial advisor and was employed in those fields since 1973.  From 1990 to 1998, he worked for Standard Life as a branch manager.  At the time that he left this company, he earned over $150,000 per annum.  He subsequently began working for Edward Jones as a financial advisor.  In 2002, he incorporated his own business, called Previdente Financial Corporation, which sold life insurance policies and RRSPs.  He worked nowhere else but this business since 2002.

The father also held the following certifications: Certified Financial Planner, Chartered Life Underwriter and Chartered Financial Consultant. For the past three or free years, he earned less than $2,500 in self-employment income according to his income tax returns.   Prior to the motion, he was paying child support pursuant to an interim order based on an income of $15,828.  At the motion, the mother entered into evidence a transcript from a discovery that was conducted.  The transcript revealed that during the past six years, the father had applied for only one job. 

Judge’s Findings:

The motion judge was clearly unimpressed with the father’s efforts to gain reasonable employment:“It makes no sense to me that someone with the father’s skills and experience would, for six years, choose to continue a self-employed venture that provides him with an income that would make him eligible for social assistance.  The one job application he referred to was only made in April of 2008.  His failure to seek employment in these circumstances is unreasonable.  The first part of the test in Drygala v. Pauli is met.  I find that the father is intentionally under-employed.”  The court found that the second part of the test was not met as the father provided no evidence to support a claim that he was unable to work due to medical reasons.

When it came to the third part of the test and determining the appropriate income to attribute to the father, the judge found that the mother’s position was overreaching in light of his circumstances.  The mother filed into evidence reports published by provincial and federal governments demonstrating that the average annual income in the father’s line of work ranged from $70,000 to $110,000.  She argued that these figures were representative of the income that should be attributed to him.  The judge, however, was reluctant to impute this income to the father for a number of reasons.  First, it was found that this evidence should be treated with “considerable caution” in that it was unsworn hearsay evidence untested by cross-examination.  

There were practical considerations that militated against imputing income of a managerial level to a payor who had not worked in that post for many years and who, at his age, was unlikely to be hired by anyone at such a high starting wage.  Ultimately, the judge rejected the published figures and found that while the payor was indeed under-employed, he was reasonably capable of earning $45,000, either through his own employment venture or by procuring employment.   He deferred to the trial judge to adjust the temporary support order after all of the evidence had been heard and tested at trial.

Rodrigues demonstrates that the courts will not countenance parents shirking their ongoing obligation to support their children and, to that end, will ensure that child support orders reflect what the parent is reasonably capable of earning.  

- Ana Kraljevic, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net