Arar to receive $10.5 million settlement - Canada Apologizes

Kudos to the Government of Canada for acknowledging its role in the blunders that led to the wrongful deportation, imprisonment and torture in Syria of Maher Arar, a Canadian citizen.

From Yahoo news today:

OTTAWA (Reuters) - Canada apologized to Maher Arar and his family on Friday and said it would compensate him C$10.5 million ($8.9 million) for its role in his deportation by the United States to what he said was a year of repeated torture in a Syrian jail.

U.S. officials deported the Syrian-born Canadian citizen after the Royal Canadian Mounted Police said he was an Islamic extremist, but an official Canadian inquiry said there was no evidence he was linked to terrorism.

The deportation has become a sore spot in relations between Canada and the United States, and Prime Minister Stephen Harper renewed his call for Washington to remove Arar from its security watch list as he announced the settlement.

"On behalf of the government of Canada, I wish to apologize to you, Monia Mazigh (Arar's wife) and your family for any role Canadian officials may have played in the terrible ordeal that all of you experienced in 2002 and 2003," Harper said in a letter of apology which he read at a news conference.

... In Washington, Democratic Sen. Patrick Leahy issued a statement saying he was seeking answers as chairman of the Senate judiciary committee as to why Arar was sent to Syria.

"The question remains why. Even if there were reasons to consider him suspicious, the U.S. Government shipped him to Syria where he was tortured, instead of to Canada for investigation or prosecution," Leahy said.

The U.S. ambassador to Canada, David Wilkins, said this week that it was presumptuous of Ottawa to try to determine whom the United States would put on its security watch list, but Harper said he would keep up the pressure.

"We will not drop the matter ... just because we disagree and they don't like hearing our position," Harper countered.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: http://www.wiselaw.net/

A.G. Gonzales: Arar to Stay on Watch List - Wants "Confidential Meeting" with Canadian Government to Explain

After being grilled last week by Senator Patrick Leahy, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales remains firm in his resolve against Maher Arar.

Leahy blasted Gonzales for the U.S. Government's actions against Arar at a Judiciary Committee hearing on January 18, 2007:

Leahy: "We knew damn well if he went to Canada he wouldn't be tortured. He'd be held and he'd be investigated. We also knew damn well if he went to Syria, he'd be tortured. And it's beneath the dignity of this country, a country that has always been a beacon of human rights, to send somebody to another country to be tortured."

Maher Arar is a Canadian citizen, originally born in Syria in 1970, who came to Canada in 1987.

The U.S. government wrongfully deported Arar to Syria in September 2002, where he was tortured by his Syrian captors while in prison.

In September 2006, a Canadian Commission of Inquiry ultimately cleared Arar of any connection to terrorist activity.

Apparently, that comprehensive investigation has done painfully little to influence administration officials in Washington.

CNN reports today as follows:

American officials said Monday that a Canadian should remain on a U.S. terrorist watch list despite the Canadian government's conclusion otherwise and its apology after the designation led to his detention in Syria.

In a joint letter, U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff informed Stockwell Day, Canada's minister of public safety, that they had again looked at intelligence in their possession concerning Maher Arar."Based on this re-examination, we remain of the view that the continued watch listing of Mr. Arar is appropriate," the U.S. officials said.

"Our conclusion in this regard is supported by information developed by U.S. law enforcement agencies that is independent of that provided to us by Canada regarding Mr. Arar."

The Arar case has been politically charged. Last week, Sen. Patrick Leahy, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, sharply criticized Gonzales about the case during the attorney general's appearance before the panel....

On Monday, Leahy complained the letter does not address what he called "the larger issues surrounding this case."

"The reason the Arar case is such a sore point and such an offense to American values is that he was sent to Syria on the Bush administration's orders, where he was tortured," Leahy said in a written statement.

He said he was puzzled by the decision to keep Arar on the watch list, but said he would await a promised briefing by Gonzales.

Justice Department officials said Monday that the attorney general will inform the lawmaker why the Bush administration believes Arar should remain on the watch list.In their letter to the Canadian minister, the U.S. officials said they would like to brief the Canadians "in a confidential meeting with appropriate Canadian officials at their earliest convenience."

The history of Arar's ordeal is documented at maherarar.ca:

Maher Arar is a 34-year-old wireless technology consultant. He was born in Syria and came to Canada with his family at the age of 17. He became a Canadian citizen in 1991. On Sept. 26, 2002, while in transit in New York’s JFK airport when returning home from a vacation, Arar was detained by US officials and interrogated about alleged links to al-Qaeda. Twelve days later, he was chained, shackled and flown to Syria, where he was held in a tiny “grave-like” cell for ten months and ten days before he was moved to a better cell in a different prison. In Syria, he was beaten, tortured and forced to make a false confession.

During his imprisonment, Arar's wife, Monia Mazigh, campaigned relentlessly on his behalf until he was returned to Canada in October 2003. On Jan. 28, 2004, under pressure from Canadian human rights organizations and a growing number of citizens, the Government of Canada announced a Commission of Inquiry into the Actions of Canadian Officials in Relation to Maher Arar.

On September 18, 2006, the Commissioner of the Inquiry, Justice Dennis O'Connor, cleared Arar of all terrorism allegations, stating he was "able to say categorically that there is no evidence to indicate that Mr. Arar has committed any offence or that his activities constitute a threat to the security of Canada."

To read the Commissioner's report, including his findings on the actions of Canadian officials, please visit the Arar Commission's website or click here.

So now, Gonzales wants a confidential meeting with Stockwell Day!

Is there something new to discuss - something vitally relevant about Arar that will change everything?

Or perhaps, something so "sensitive" that Gonzales has withheld it from the O'Connor Commission and the Government of Canada to date (but is now prepared to disclose to Stockwell Day and his Conservative cronies in Ottawa)?

You gotta be kidding...

It would be an international embarrassment to Canada if Stockwell Day or any government official participated in such a meeting.

Too little. Too late.

The Government of Canada would be well-served to publicly decline Gonzales' self-serving overtures.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Website: http://www.wiselaw.net/