Showing posts with label employment agreements. Show all posts
Showing posts with label employment agreements. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Employee or Contractor? Apply the Duck Test...

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER

How do Ontario Courts determine if someone is really a contractor or an employee?

It may surprise you to learn that the answer is actually quite simple and straightforward.

Just apply the duck test: If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, then lo and behold, it probably is a duck. 

In other words, if the “contractor” works like an employee, is managed like an employee, and overall appears to be like an employee, chances are this “contractor” is actually an employee under Ontario employment law.

As the Supreme Court of Canada perhaps more eloquently summarized:
47      Although there is no universal test to determine whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor, I agree with MacGuigan J.A. that a persuasive approach to the issue is that taken by Cooke J. in Market Investigations, supra.  The central question is whether the person who has been engaged to perform the services is performing them as a person in business on his own account.  In making this determination, the level of control the employer has over the worker’s activities will always be a factor.  However, other factors to consider include whether the worker provides his or her own equipment, whether the worker hires his or her own helpers, the degree of financial risk taken by the worker, the degree of responsibility for investment and management held by the worker, and the worker’s opportunity for profit in the performance of his or her tasks.
While an employer may have many cost incentives for prefering to work with a contractor rather than an employee (some being of dubious legality), denying a worker the protections and entitlements that come with employee status can be a very costly mistake for both employer and employee. 

We often hear our employer clients say, "but we agreed in writing that this person would work with us as a contractor", to which we just as often have to respond, "unfortunately given the nature of your working relationship, this contracting agreement is probably not legal or binding." 

It is not enough to simply call someone a contractor.  For the contracting relationship to be legally binding, the very essence of the working relationship itself needs to have the markings of independence and exclusivity. 

Perhaps our best advice to our employer clients is to start from within, by frankly considering how a worker is likely perceived within the company itself.  If there is a degree of control, dependency and answerability, it is quite possible that this individual is an employee, no matter what you call him or her, and has legal status as an employee that provides for numerous employment  entitlements, and entitlements upon termination of employment and wrongful dismissal. 

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, December 13, 2016

Are Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Clauses Actually Enforceable?

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 

Employment agreements will often include language that is intended to restrict the actions of employees following the end of their employment. These types of clauses, typically relating to confidentiality, non-solicitation and non-competition, are aptly referred to in the employment law world as restrictive covenants.

Most commonly, many employers will seek some assurance that their once all-star employees do not solicit business away from the company. In some cases, employers may even be concerned about former employees leaving a company and going on to compete against it in the same market.

The interests of employers in protecting their businesses must of course be balanced against the rights of employees to pursue their trade of preference

Given their competing interests, it is not all that surprising that restrictive covenants are often controversial and subject to challenge before the Courts.

In determining whether such terms should be enforceable, the Court will not only give weight to the parties’ respective interests, but will also consider the context in which the restrictive covenants were agreed to. While the Court will look to give effect to the parties’ freedom to contract with one another, it will also consider the power dynamics of the parties in negotiations of terms of employment.

The legal test developed by the Supreme Court of Canada in view of these varying interests is as follows:
  1. Does the employer have a proprietary interest entitled to protection? In other words, an employer must have a legitimate reason for seeking to restrict a former employee from having contact with clients, soliciting business or otherwise competing.  Common proprietary interests often include protecting trade secrets, confidential information and trade connections. As an example, it would likely be unreasonable for an employer to include a non-competition clause for its junior administrative support staff, unless of course it had legitimate reasons for doing so.
2.     Are the temporal and geographic elements of the agreement too broad? What this means in plain English is that the restrictive clause cannot be unnecessarily broad. In order to assess this, the Court will consider whether the geographic and time restrictions imposed are reasonable, having regard to a number of factors including: the nature of the industry; the type of relationship between the parties; and the position of the departing employee including the level of trust and confidence he or she enjoyed. While it may for instance be reasonable to limit a senior financial adviser from soliciting the clients that he or she worked with while at the company for a one-year period, it would in all likelihood be unreasonable to impose an indefinite restriction for a junior level bookkeeper to have contact with any of the company’s clients, past, present and future;

3.     Is the covenant unenforceable as being against competition generally, and not limited to proscribing solicitation of clients of the former employee? In other words, did the employer really need a non-compete clause to serve its interests or would a non-solicitation clause have sufficed? As a general principle, non-competition clauses are generally frowned upon in the employment context, though it may have some greater enforceability in circumstances involving the sale of business. That is, preventing an employee from competing in some form or capacity with the employer is not generally practical. However where one party sells its business to another, it would make sense to have some limitations in place to bar the seller from opening shop down the street.

The question of whether a restrictive covenant is reasonable, and accordingly enforceable, must be viewed in context of the employment circumstances overall. What is the nature of the industry? How were the terms of employment negotiated and agreed to? Did the employee bring his or her own clients to the company? Did he or she develop clientele from the Company’s contacts, and/or using its resources? Are clients likely to leave with the employee? Is he or she in a position of trust and confidence? 

Given the nuances involved, it Is highly recommended that you consult with a lawyer, whether you may be subject to a restrictive covenant or seeking to enforce such a clause.

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer Toronto

Tuesday, November 29, 2016

Enforceability of Employment Agreements: Termination Clauses in Ontario

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 

In the excitement of finding a new job, it can be tempting to overlook the importance of the termination provisions that might be included in the employment contract you have been asked to sign.

Employment agreements in non-union environments typically govern the terms of the working relationship itself, but they may also set out exactly how the employment relationship may be brought to an end.

Generally, termination provisions in employment agreements are crafted to reduce employers' severance obligations upon termination. In fact, that employment agreement you barely remember signing might be at the center of your wrongful dismissal claim of the future.
 


ENTITLEMENTS WHERE THERE IS NO EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT CONTAINING A TERMINATION PROVISION

At common law, an Ontario employer may usually dismiss any employee without cause by simply providing reasonable notice of termination or pay in lieu of that notice to the departing employee.

(Like virtually everything in the law, there are definite exceptions to this general statement. For example, if the termination is inherently discriminatory or a retaliatory reprisal after a legitimate workplace safety complaint by the terminated employee, termination may be legally prohibited, and reinstatement of employment could be ordered by a court or tribunal.)

Where there is no employment contract that provides for entitlements upon termination, "reasonable notice" is determined at common law by Ontario's courts upon considering a number of factual issues about the employment, including:

  • the length of the employment
  • the employee's age and seniority
  • the level of the position held (e.g. managerial or entry level)
  • the expected difficulty in finding comparable employment, and 
  • An extensive and still-developing list of other considerations. Collectively, these considerations are known in case law as the "Bardal factors," after being outlined by the court in a landmark 1960 case called Bardal v. Globe and Mail.

DOES YOUR EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT OPT YOU OUT OF THE COMMON LAW?


By signing an employment contract that includes a termination clause, an employee essentially agrees to opt out of his or her common law entitlement to reasonable notice of termination, and instead agrees to instead accept the specified, usually reduced compensation upon termination that is set out in the employment agreement. 

Typically, a termination clause will limit your notice entitlements to only the statutory minimum that must be provided at law pursuant to the Employment Standards Act (ESA) or Canada Labour Code (CLC). 

The legal validity and enforceability of a termination clause in an employment agreement might therefore become critical in determining the amount notice an employee is entitled to when the employment ends.

IS A TERMINATION CLAUSE IN AN EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT ENFORCEABLE?

The law will not enforce an employment agreement that provides (or may in the future provide) for less compensation and benefit than the applicable employment standards legislation requires. If a termination provision provides less than any statutory minimum, it will likely be held to be void and unenforceable by a court.

Does a specific agreement provide for less than employment standards law requires?  While the answer to this question is often obvious, in certain circumstances it can become highly complex and technical. 

Ontario's courts are currently somewhat divided on how to interpret employment agreements that do provide for adequate minimum notice and severance, but are silent as to whether employment benefits will continue throughout the contractual notice period, as required under Ontario's ESA.

DOES AN EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT ADEQUATELY PROVIDE FOR BENEFIT CONTINUATION DURING THE STATUTORY NOTICE PERIOD?

Ontario Courts have regularly interpreted termination clauses that fail to make express reference to benefit continuation over the notice period to be null and void.

[65] “…[E]mployers should be provided with incentive to ensure that their employment contracts comply with all aspects of the employment standards legislation, including provision of adequate notice (or pay in lieu thereof) and mandated benefit continuation…” (emphasis added)
Furthermore, in circumstances where a termination clause is ambiguous on its face, it may be interpreted in favour of the employee on the basis of the doctrine of contra proferentum, which literally translates to “interpretation against the draftsman.” The rationale behind this principle is that it is the responsibility of the drafting party to be as clear and explicit as possible, particularly in an employment dynamic, where the employer has unequal bargaining power.

Where a termination clause is broadly drafted, however, to make reference in general to the minimum entitlements set out in the legislation, it may be held to be enforceable, even if it does not expressly refer to specific entitlements such as benefits. As the Court in Stevens further articulated:

It is only where a clause “attempt[s] to ‘draw the circle’ of employee rights and entitlements on termination with an all-encompassing specificity that results in the effective and impermissible exclusion and denial of [entitlements such as] the benefit continuation rights mandated by the legislation” that it may be considered null and void.

In the recent case of Oudin v Centre Francophone de Toronto, 2016 ONCA 514 (CanLII), Ontario's Court of Appeal appears to affirm that a contextual approach focusing on what the parties' reasonably understood the termination clause to mean must be taken when considering whether it actually attempts to contract out of providing the minimum entitlements required at law:
[8] The motion judge’s reasons make it clear that he understood and considered the appellant’s submission that - by referring only to “notice” - the clause ought to be interpreted as an attempt to contract out of all obligations under the ESA. The motion judge rejected this submission and found that there was no attempt to contract out of the ESA and that the parties had agreed that the ESA would be respected.

[9] The motion judge’s decision was based on his interpretation of a contract. He considered the circumstances of parties, the words of the agreement as a whole and the legal obligations between the parties. He concluded at paragraph 54:


Contracts are to be interpreted in their context and I can find no basis to interpret this employment agreement in a way that neither party reasonably expected it would be interpreted when they entered into it. There was no intent to contract out of the ESA in fact; to the contrary, the intent to apply the ESA is manifest.
It remains to be seen whether the Oudin decision, will change the course of the rather strict interpretation that the Court has often applied in favour of the employee, when reviewing termination clauses.

Overall, the validity of a termination clause must be ascertained based on a careful and nuanced review of the language used in drafting the provision; the context in which the employment contract was negotiated and agreed to; and the parties' intent and understanding of the employer's obligations and the employee's entitlements. 

Given these complexities, it is always a good idea to have a lawyer review your employment contract with you before you sign it. 

You should certainly review your employment agreement with your lawyers if your employment come to an end.  It is essential that you do so before signing any release or related settlement documentation relating to the termination.

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer, Toronto


Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday November 29, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


If your employment agreement prohibits you from competing with your employer or soliciting its customers after you leave, those restrictions may not be enforceable.

Non-competition agreements are generally unenforceable against Ontario employees. Many non-solicitation agreements may also be unenforceable. Seek legal advice if you have signed such an agreement
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday October 12, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.


A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


If your employment agreement prohibits you from competing with your employer or soliciting its customers after you leave, those restrictions may not be enforceable.

Non-competition agreements are generally unenforceable against Ontario employees. Many non-solicitation agreements may also be unenforceable.  Seek legal advice if you have signed such an agreement.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Sunday, June 24, 2012

Ontario Employment Law: Contractual Entitlement to Notice and the Question of Mitigation

In Bowes v. Goss Power Products Ltd., decided May 25, 2012, the Court of Appeal for Ontario was faced with an interesting question of law:

Is an employee, who is terminated without cause, required to mitigate his or her loss when entitled to a fix term of notice or pay in lieu of notice?

In the case, the employee, Peter Bowes had entered into a written contract of employment with Goss Power Products Ltd, which provided that he would receive six months' notice or pay in lieu thereof if his employment was terminated without case. The contract was silent as to any duty on his part to mitigate his damages in the event of a termination without cause. As it happened, only two weeks following the date of termination, Mr. Bowes was lucky enough to secure comparable employment at the same salary he had been earning with Goss.  

The employer took the position that even though the contract was silent as to any obligation on Mr. Bowes to mitigate his damages, he had an implied obligation to do so and had effectively mitigated most of his damages by obtaining this new position. Therefore, the employer argued it did not have to pay Mr. Bowes anymore than

In answering "no" to the question set out above, the Court noted that a contractually fixed term of notice is distinguishable from common law reasonable notice where a duty to mitigate is an implied term of the employment relationship. In this regard, Winkler C.J.O. stated:
When parties contract for a specified period of notice or pay in lieu thereof they are choosing to opt out of the common law approach applied in Bardal. In doing so, the parties should not be take as simply attempting to replicate common law reasonable notice.
Winkler C.J.O. continued:
In my view, there is nothing unfair about requiring employers to be explicit if they intend to require an employee to mitigate what would otherwise be fixed or liquidated damages. In fact, what is unfair is for an employer to agree upon a fixed amount of damages, and then, at the point of dismissal, inform the employee that future earnings will be deducted from the fixed amount. 
This decision illustrates that where a contract specifies the period of notice, or pay in lieu thereof, which an employee will be entitled upon a termination on a without cause basis, courts will not presume a term requiring the dismissed employee to mitigate its damages.

If you believe that you have been wrongfully dismissed, please contact a lawyer who can advise you as to your rights and entitlements.

- Robert Tanha, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, November 19, 2010

Ontario Employment Law: Restrictive Covenants 101

Employers often wish to protect their commercial and business interests by contractually limiting the ability of departing employees to use confidential information, compete with the employer, and solicit the employer's customers and staff in the period subsequent to employment.

The employment contracts that set out these limitations are known as restrictive covenants. We will be canvas these provisions in detail in a series of posts over the weeks ahead.

In this introduction, we will provide basic definitions and a general overview of the issues that typically arise in connection with restrictive covenants in employment agreements.

Definitions:

There are three major types of restrictive covenants that may typically be found in some Canadian employment contracts.
  • Confidentiality agreements prohibit employees from disclosing the confidential information of the employer during and subsequent to employment, unless authorized. A typical confidentiality agreement will define the specific categories of information that are to be protected, require the employee's undertaking of non-disclosure of such information, and detail the specific, adverse legal consequences facing an employee who fails to maintain such confidentiality.
  • Non-solicitation agreements typically prohibit a departing employee from directly or indirectly soliciting the employer's clients, prospective clients and employees for a specified time period following termination of employment.
  • Non-competition agreements have a wider ambit than non-solicitation agreements - they purport to wholly restrict competition by the employee in related commercial endeavours. Such agreements typically prohibit former employees from working for direct competitors or from directly or indirectly competing with the employer's core businesses after termination. These agreements generally apply for a specified time frame, provide extended definitions of the prohibited businesses, and define the geographical regions within which such competition is prohibited.
Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants in Ontario Courts

As a general rule, for these covenants to be enforced by courts they must entirely clear, be reasonable in scope and meet fairly rigorous tests of such reasonableness.

For example, the employer must show that the restrictions set out are no more than is necessary to protect the legitimate business interest at stake. The departing employee’s freedom of contract must be not be unduly restricted and excessive restraint of trade is not permitted, particularly if no legitimate commercial interest of the employer is protected by an impugned covenant.

As a result, where these covenants overreach by having unreasonably extended scope, they are vulnerable to being unenforceable by the courts.

There are numerous recent examples of cases where the courts have declined to enforce these covenants, not least of which is the Ontario Court of Appeal's 2008 ruling in H. L. Staebler Company Limited v. Tim James Allan, et al., an important decision that reaffirms the limited enforceability of non-competition covenants in Canadian employment agreements.

As similar outcome emerged from the January, 2009 ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada in Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC 6 (CanLII). In Shafron, the Supreme Court of Canada overturned a ruling of the British Columbia Court of Appeal that had liberally interpreted and enforced a non-competition covenant that purported to restrict a former employee's ability to work in the Greater Vancouver area. The Supreme Court of Canada held the employer to the strict wording of the covenant, which referred to the non-existent entity of the "Metropolitan City of Vancouver," and refused to enforce the covenant.

Obtain Legal Advice Before Signing

Employees who are asked to sign such agreements are strongly advised to obtain legal advice from a qualified employment lawyer before signing any documentation. While this is, of course, true of all employment contracts, it is particularly the case with respect to the restrictive covenants discussed in this introduction.

Where enforceable, these agreements can lead to highly adverse consequences for former employees upon termination, including potentially protracted financial losses.

They may limit re-employability following a termination; in some cases, new employers have been held liable for the roles they have taken in inducing breaches of restrictive covenants. Further, it is important to note that these restrictive covenants may be enforceable, even in circumstances where an employee is terminated without cause after a short period of employment.

Thus, we'll close this introductory discussion by underlining that these agreements are serious legal documents that ought not to be taken lightly by employers or employees alike.

In future posts, we'll take a closer look at the courts' treatment of these restrictive covenants in specific employment contexts.
- Garry J. Wise and Robert Tanha, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, July 07, 2009

Canada: Employment Law Update

I'll note two good articles on recent Canadian employment law rulings that are of considerable importance:
  • In Judicial Interpretation Of Restrictive Covenants, Ottawa Business Journal provides a good summary by Jordan Plener on the January, 2009 ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada in Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC 6 (CanLII). In Shafron, the Supreme Court of Canada overturned a ruling of the British Columbia Court of Appeal that had liberally interpreted and enforced a non-competition covenant that purported to restrict a former employee's ability to work in the Greater Vancouver area. The Supreme Court of Canada held the employer to the strict wording of the covenant, which referred to the non-existent entity of the "Metropolitan City of Vancouver" and refused to enforce the covenant. As Mr. Plener succinctly put it, "In arriving at this conclusion, the Supreme Court held that an ambiguous restrictive covenant is prima facie unreasonable and unenforceable."

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

WWE Wrestlers Lose Employee-Status Claims

Law.com reports on the dismissal of a lawsuit by several well-known professional wrestlers against the WWE (World Wrestling Entertainment).  The wrestlers had alleged that they were deprived of employee benefits by being improperly classified as independent contractors, as opposed to employees.

In dismissing the claims, the court upheld written agreements signed by the wrestlers in which they acknowledged they were independent contractors:

Former WWE performers Scott "Raven" Levy, Christopher "Kanyon" Kluscartis and "Above Average" Michael Sanders claimed they should have been treated as employees because the Stamford, Conn.-based WWE controls their salaries, performance locations, costumes, training regimen and the storylines they follow. Further, the lawsuit alleged, the WWE improperly withheld Social Security and Medicare taxes from the federal government because of the wrestlers' independent contractor status.

The wrestlers' attorney, David Golub of Silver, Golub & Teitell in Stamford, also claimed that the wrestlers' were denied employee benefits such as health care, paid sick time and vacation.

Golub was seeking class-action status, but late last week Senior U.S. District Judge Peter Dorsey granted WWE's motion to dismiss in federal court in New Haven. He said the wrestlers signed a contract that acknowledged their status as independent contractors.

The issue of workers' classification has been a hot topic since the late 1990s when Microsoft was found to have misclassified some workers as independent contractors and temporary employees. Employers sometimes take such steps to cut benefit and liability insurance costs.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Thursday, September 04, 2008

Ontario Court of Appeal Sets Aside $1.9 Million Award for "Client Poaching:" Restrictive Covenant Unenforceable

In an important decision that reaffirms the limited enforceability of non-competition covenants in Canadian employment agreements, the Court of Appeal for Ontario has reversed a September, 2007 trial ruling of Mr. Justice G.E. Taylor of Ontario' Superior Court of Justice.

At trial in H. L. Staebler Company Limited v. Tim James Allan, et al., two Kitchener, Ontario insurance salespersons and their new employer were ordered to pay damages of $1.9 million to the salespersons' former brokerage, H.L. Staebler Company Limited.

Staebler commenced the action after its salespersons left to join Stevenson and Hunt Insurance Brokers Limited, a competing brokerage. The employees brought their entire books of business to their new employer when they changed brokerages.

In ruling against the employees, the trial court enforced a two-year non-solicitation covenant that precluded them from "doing business" with the clients of their former brokerage for a two year period following any termination of their employment with Staebler. The court also held that Stevenson and Hunt was liable for inducing the salespersons to breach their employment agreements with Staebler.
On appeal, Madame Justice Eileen Gillese, for the Court, reviewed the law applicable to non-competition and non-solicitation agreements in Ontario. The Court unanimously ruled that the restrictive covenants in this case were unreasonable in scope, given the non-managerial roles of the salespersons involved and the "overly broad" restraints imposed by the covenants upon the salespersons' ability to freely compete in the industry:

[33] There is no dispute about the legal principles that apply when determining whether a restrictive covenant in an employment contract is enforceable, as those principles have long been settled. Several decades ago in Elsley, the seminal Canadian case on this matter, Dickson J. described the principles as “well-established”.[2] He stated the test in plain terms: such a covenant is enforceable “only if it is reasonable between the parties and with reference to the public interest”.[3]

[34] This test reflects the competing principles that must be balanced when a court is called on to decide the validity of such a covenant. On the one hand, there is the “important public interest in discouraging restraints on trade, and maintaining free and open competition unencumbered by the fetters of restrictive covenants”.[4] Open competition benefits both society and the affected employees. Society benefits from having greater choice and employees benefit as they have greater employment opportunities. On the other hand, however, “the courts have been disinclined to restrict the right to contract, particularly when that right has been exercised by knowledgeable persons of equal bargaining power”.[5]

[35] While an overly broad restraint on an individual’s freedom to compete will generally be unenforceable, the courts must recognize and afford “reasonable protection to trade secrets, confidential information, and trade connections of the employer.”[6] In the present case, there is no suggestion that trade secrets or confidential information is involved. It is Staebler’s “trade connections” that warrant protection.

[36] Reasonableness is the mechanism by which a court decides whether a covenant is “overly broad” or is only that which is reasonably required for the employer’s protection. But how is a court to determine whether any given restrictive covenant is “reasonable”? Elsley offers a framework for making such a determination. The starting point is “an overall assessment of the clause, the agreement within which it is found, and all of the surrounding circumstances”.[7] Thereafter, three factors must be considered. First, did the employer have a proprietary interest entitled to protection? Second, are the temporal or spatial features of the covenant too broad? And, third, is the covenant unenforceable as being against competition generally, and not limited to proscribing solicitation of clients of the former employer?[8]

...[54] My view that Staebler has not discharged the burden of establishing that the Restrictive Covenant was reasonable[11] as between the parties is reinforced on a consideration of the third factor.

[55] A non-solicitation clause is sufficient in conventional employer/employee situations.[12] The Employees were two of ten commercial insurance salespeople that worked for Staebler. They did not play an exceptional role in the Staebler business – they were ordinary salespeople. They were not managers, directors or key employees. They did not stand in a fiduciary relationship with Staebler.

[56] Although the Employees had close personal relationships with their clients, that is the industry norm. Those relationships were not exclusive; other Staebler employees served the clients in various capacities. This is an important difference between the role that the Employees played at Staebler and that of Mr. Elsley who “was the business”.[13] Another significant difference between the present case and Elsley is that the Employees had no special knowledge of or influence over the Staebler business whereas Mr. Elsley “had control of [the employer’s] trade connections”.[14] Furthermore, and again in contradistinction to Elsley, there was an imbalance of bargaining power between the Employees and Staebler when the employment contracts were negotiated whereas Mr. Elsley bargained as an equal when selling his business and then carried on as its general manager.

[57] The 50 mile radius clause which Staebler had with five of its other commercial salespeople is significant. Under its terms, those employees could solicit their clients and customers and conduct business with Staebler clients so long as they did so outside of a 50 mile radius of the Waterloo region. No explanation was given to justify this differential treatment among Staebler’s commercial insurance salespeople which leads me to conclude that Staebler itself viewed the 50 mile radius clause as sufficient protection of its interest. Clearly, the terms of the Restrictive Covenant are far more restrictive than are those of the 50 mile radius clause.[15]

[58] Other provincial appellate courts have affirmed that suitably restricted non-solicitation clauses are likely to be found to be reasonable for “ordinary” salespeople in the insurance brokerage industry whereas non-competition clauses are not. See, for example, Valley First Financial Services Ltd. v. Trach, [2004] B.C.J. No. 1127 (C.A.).

[59] It follows from my determination that the Restrictive Covenant is not enforceable that Stevenson & Hunt are not liable for inducing a breach of contract.

For the full text of the Court of Appeal's ruling, see: H.L. Staebler Company Limited v. Allan, 2008 ONCA 576 (CanLII)

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG