Saturday, May 16, 2009

January 1, 2010: Ontario Small Claims Court Monetary Limit Rises to $25,000

Transferring Actions from Ontario Superior Court to Ontario Small Claims Court

As we noted in our earlier posts on this topic, on January 1, 2010 the  monetary jurisdiction of Ontario's Small Claims Courts will rise from $10,000 to $25,000. 

Suppose you have an ongoing claim for $25,000 or less in Ontario Superior Court. What will happen to your case on January 1st? 

Will it automatically be transferred to Small Claims Court?

Apparently not. 

According to the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General, “proceedings in the Superior Court of Justice valued at less than $25,000 will not be automatically transferred to the Small Claims Court." 

Pursuant to Section 23 of the Courts of Justice Act. however, proceedings may be administratively transferred to a Small Claims Court  if all parties consent.  

Section 23 provides:

Jurisdiction

23.(1)The Small Claims Court,

(a) has jurisdiction in any action for the payment of money where the amount claimed does not

 exceed the prescribed amount exclusive of interest and costs; and

(b) has jurisdiction in any action for the recovery of possession of personal property where the value of the property does not exceed the prescribed amount. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (1).

Transfer from Superior Court of Justice

(2)An action in the Superior Court of Justice may be transferred to the Small Claims Court by the 

local registrar of the Superior Court of Justice on requisition with the consent of all parties filed before the trial commences if,

(a) the only claim is for the payment of money or the recovery of possession of personal property; and

(b) the claim is within the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (2); 1996, c. 25, s. 9 (17).

Idem

(3)An action transferred to the Small Claims Court shall be titled and continued as if it had been commenced in that court. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (3).

If the parties do not all consent, a transfer may only be effected by an order of the Superior Court of Justice upon a motion. There may be some interesting disputes on this issue.

Why might a transfer to Small Claims Court be opposed? 

A significant concern may be that the costs incurred in a Superior Court action already exceed the maximum costs that are  available in Small Claims Court, where costs awards will  remain capped at 15% of a claim's value.  In a $25,000 suit, for example, costs awards will thus be limited to $3,750. 

There may be other tactical advantages to remaining in Superior Court - a party may wish to to retain access to certain procedures that are available in Superior Court, but not in Small Claims Courts.  

For example, documentary disclosure and production entitlements in Superior Court actions are significantly broader than those in Small Claims Court.

In Superior Court actions, each party is required to produce a comprehensive Affidavit of Documents listing all relevant documentation touching on the matters in question.  The documentary disclosure rules in Small Claims Courts are much narrower and considerably less onerous.

Rule 13.03 (2) of the Ontario Small Claims Court Rules provides:

Disclosure

(2)  At least 14 days before the date of the settlement conference, each party shall serve on every other party and file with the court,

(a) a copy of any document to be relied on at the trial, including an expert report, not attached to the party’s claim or defence; and

(b) a list of proposed witnesses (Form 13A) and of other persons with knowledge of the matters in dispute in the action. O. Reg. 78/06, s. 27.

Rule 13.05 (1) additionally empowers a Judge presiding at a Small Claims Court settlement conference to direct that certain documents must be produced:

13.05  (1)  A judge conducting a settlement conference may make any order relating to the conduct of the action that the court could make. O. Reg. 78/06, s. 27.

(2)  Without limiting the generality of subrule (1), the judge may,

(a) make an order,

....(vi) directing production of documents

Beyond that, a party may wish to remain in Superior Court for less than legitimate reasons - for example, to avoid the speedier trial of a proceeding that will likely occur in Small Claims Court.

A cautionary note - those who unreasonably resist a transfer to Small Claims Court may face potential costs sanctions under Rule 57.05 the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure, which govern Superior Court actions:  

COSTS WHERE ACTION BROUGHT IN WRONG COURT

Recovery within Monetary Jurisdiction of Small Claims Court

57.05  (1)  If a plaintiff recovers an amount within the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, the court may order that the plaintiff shall not recover any costs. O. Reg. 377/95, s. 4.

(2)  Subrule (1) does not apply to an action transferred to the Superior Court of Justice under section 107 of the Courts of Justice Act. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 194, r. 57.05 (2); O. Reg. 292/99, s. 2 (2).

Default Judgment within Monetary Jurisdiction of Small Claims Court

(3)  If the plaintiff obtains a default judgment that is within the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, costs shall be assessed in accordance with that court’s tariff. O. Reg. 377/95, s. 4.

Disputes over transfers might be less likely if the Small Claims Court Rules change, as they did in British Columbia when the B.C. Small Claims Courts' monetary limit was increased. 

B.C. Small Claims matters are now subject to three different procedural tiers, depending on the amount claimed in a lawsuit.

Will that happen in Ontario? There’s no word yet from the Ministry about whether there will be any significant new Small Claims Court Rules, and if so, what they might be. 

Stay tuned...

- Garry J. Wise and Bill Rogers, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Friday, May 15, 2009

Brian Mulroney Cross-Examined

Oliphant Commission lead counsel Richard Wolson conducted a tenacious, but polite cross-examination of former Prime Minister Brian Mulroney on Thursday.


Mr. Wolson focused in his questioning on Mr. Mulroney's failure to fully disclose the nature and extent of his ongoing business dealings with Karlheinz Schreiber when Mr. Mulroney gave discovery evidence in his 1996 lawsuit against the federal government.

Mr. Mulroney reiterated throughout that he answered the specific questions asked on discovery, and in accordance with his lawyers' instructions at the time, did not volunteer information in the absence of a specific question.

CBC provides excerpts of the testimony at Lawyer challenge Mulroney's 1996 testimony during Airbus lawsuit:

Wolson pressed Mulroney, asking about his response to the question of whether he maintained contact with Schreiber after he left office.

Mulroney responded in 1996 that from time to time he and Schreiber had met for coffee, but didn't discuss their business relationship or the three cash payments Mulroney received in 1993 and 1994 at three hotels.

Wolson asked Mulroney if — when he testified in 1996 that he had coffee with Schreiber twice — he was "being totally fulsome, forthright, telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth."

Mulroney answered: "I was truthful in answering the specific question, which was 'Did you maintain contact with Mr. Schreiber?"

Had the question been asked whether he had a business relationship, Mulroney said he would have responded, yes, but that question never came in 1996.

"Never came because no one knew about it but you and Schreiber and [Fred] Doucet and someone in Germany. That's why it never came," Wolson responded.

"It never came because, as I say, the high-priced talent that had been retained by the government did not ask me the question," Mulroney said.

Mulroney said under Quebec law, he was under no obligation to volunteer any information.

Wolson asked if he thought Mulroney, as a former prime minister, should have testified that he had a "legitimate business relationship" with Schreiber.

"I indicated to you exactly what I was told in those circumstances from my lawyers — answer the questions truthfully. Do not volunteer information," said Mulroney.

But Wolson asked Mulroney why, if he wasn't there to volunteer information, he testified that Schreiber had retained former Liberal cabinet minister Marc Lalonde.

"How do you explain the difference? You're volunteering information about a retainer of Mr. Lalonde, not having been asked, but you don't say anything about your retainer [with Schreiber]?"

Mulroney told Wolson that Lalonde was specifically involved in the relocation of the Bear Head project to Montreal and it was in that context he mentioned him.

Later, Wolson said he could see why Mulroney might be reluctant to admit taking the money, "because it would have been like putting gasoline on a fire,”

"But I don't understand why you can't admit that you simply didn't tell him for that reason, because it would have just spread like wildfire, this poisonous atmosphere that existed."

"The answer is that he never asked me the question," Mulroney said.

He said he was in a terrible situation at the time of the Airbus accusations.

"The nine lawyers sitting there … out to crush me and my family … this was not conducive to a friendly exchange of information or compromise.

"I was fighting for my life and the honour of my family."

Students of the adversarial process will not want to miss this video. It provides a rare example of a masterful cross-examination of an extremely adept witness in a Canadian legal proceeding.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Rachel's Bits and Briefs

Here are a few legal "shorts" to keep you busy over a (hopefully) warm long weekend:

  • France Passes First Bill to Cut Internet Connection of Illegal Downloaders - Yaboo Canada News reported Tuesday that legislators in France have passed a bill to form what may be the first government agency to track and discipline online pirates. 
The bill proposes to cut the Internet service of those who frequently download films and music illegally:

…International music labels, film distributors and artists have hailed the bill as a decisive step in combating online piracy in France, where CD and DVD sales have plummeted 60 per cent in the last six years.

Some critics contend that users downloading from public Wi-Fi hotspots or using masked IP addresses might be impossible to trace. They say the law also misses the point by targeting traditional downloads at a time when online streaming is taking off, for example.

  • Busted for Boppin’ - Twenty-five years after the release of the classic dance film “Footloose” The Chillicothe Gazette reports that a 17 year-old Ohio student, who attends a Christian School that has banned dancing, has been “busted for boppin’” at another High School’s prom dance. This deceptive dancing has resulted in suspension. Kevin Bacon would be proud.

  • “Norman” – Another Wal-Mart Lawsuit - Canoe Canada News reports that a resident of Louisiana, New Orleans recently received quite the shock while shopping at her local Wal-Mart:
Rebecca White says in her lawsuit that employees at a Wal-Mart in Abbeville let a rat-tailed rodent known as a nutria run loose and scare her. She says that not only did employees know it was in their store, but gave it a pet name, Norman, and failed to warn shoppers.

For those of us who don’t know what Nutria are, the report paints a vibrant picture:

Nutria have bright orange buck teeth and can weigh up to 18 pounds. Would-be fur farmers in 22 states imported them in large numbers in the 1930s and ‘40s, then released them when they proved unprofitable. They proliferated in south Louisiana.

White is asking for compensation for suffering, pain, fear, mental anguish, disabling injuries and medical expenses currently alleged of $2,000.00.

  • Queens Park Commits Funds to Save 9,000 Daycare Spaces - Before most Canadians had heard of Stephen Harper (January 2006) they had heard of child-care funding. Parent Central reports that more than $63 million in federal child-care funds are set to run out next March 31st, 2010. No promise of continuing funding was made in the recent federal budget. According to Parent Central, "child-care operators were reluctantly preparing to chop spaces starting next fall.” Queen’s Park recently announced that the Provincial Government will step up with an additional $18 million in funding, estimated to save as many as 9,000 Provincial child-care spaces.

  • Ontario Justice of the Peace Accused of Sexual Assault - The Toronto Starrecently reported that a Brampton, Ontario Justice of the Peace alleges she was sexually assaulted by another J. P. at the Court:
    It was a deliberate full-hand grab and squeeze," she told a commission of inquiry yesterday. "By the time I had turned around he retreated to his office.
    A public hearing is determining if Justice of the Peace Vernon A. Chang Alloy should be removed from office or otherwise disciplined for his alleged conduct.
  • Ontario Attorney General Goes Higher Tech - Ontario's A.G. recently updated its website's “List of Ontario Court Addresses.” The page now provides location maps (powered by Google) to show the exact location of each court address. In addition, users may now choose to search by Municipality, and the site provides a hyperlink to each address, that when clicked on, links users to a map of the Court and general information including the telephone numbers of each court office.

Enjoy the long weekend.

- Rachel Spence, Legal Assistant, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

More on Parental Alienation

Globe and Mail Justice Reporter, Kirk Makin, continues to follow the parental alienation controversy.

Today he reports on an interview with Queen's University law professor Nicholas Bala, who has completed a study on the "syndrome:"

An escalation in parental alienation allegations is draining valuable courtroom resources, a major study of 145 alienation cases between 1989-2008 concludes.

"Access problems and alienation cases - especially those which are more severe - take up a disproportionate amount of judicial time and energy," said the study, conducted by Queen's University law professor Nicholas Bala, a respected family law expert.

"One can ask whether the courts should even be trying to deal with these very challenging cases.

Prof. Bala said that the notion of parental alienation syndrome, coined in 1987 by U.S. psychiatrist Richard Gardner, is falling steadily into disrepute.

Professor Bala's study also addresses broader issues of gender equality before Ontario's family courts:
The study also urged the justice system to enforce access orders more rigorously for the sake of its own credibility.

It said that the relatively lax enforcement of access - an issue that primarily affects fathers - contrasts sharply with zero tolerance policies in domestic abuse cases and enhanced enforcement of child and spousal support orders.

The juxtaposition can convince fathers that the system is biased against them, Prof. Bala said.

"Just as feminists have some very important and valid criticisms of the family justice system, so do fathers' rights advocates," he said.

See: Parental alienation cases draining court resources

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Update: Bill 133 Passes - Family Statute Law Amendment Act, 2009

Bill 133, Ontario's Family Statute Law Amendment Act, 2009, was carried in its Third Reading on May 7, 2009, and will become law upon receiving Royal Assent.

The Bill enacts significant amendments to Ontario's family law regime.  Highlights include changes to:
  • the manner in which spousal pension entitlements will be calculated and divided; specifically, the Bill requires pension plan administrators to provide calculations of the "imputed value of a pension entitlement for family law purposes", and allows for immediate payment of lump sums to non-member spouses from pension plans in satisfaction of their pension division claims;
  • the calculation of pre-marital assets and liabilities under the Family Law Act;
  • procedures for applying for domestic restraining orders;
  • procedures for change of name applications for children
  • custody applications by non-parents, who will now be required to file with the courts police record checks and reports by children's aid societies as to any involvement they have had with such custody applicants.
The final version of the Bill 133 is online here.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Lawyers Without Rights

Times Online reports on a London exhibition commemorating the Jewish lawyers of Nazi Germany.

Representatives of the Law Society and Bar Council also gathered for the event at Temple Church, where the exhibition "Lawyers Without Rights" will be on display until July 31.

In the keynote address, Mr Justice Beatson spoke movingly about the persecution suffered by German Jewish lawyers, which led to an outright ban on practicing law in 1938.

Many of these later perished in the Holocaust but Mr Justice Beatson - co-author of a book on German Jewish émigré lawyers - also spoke of the many accomplishments of those who survived.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Obama'a SCOTUS Shortlist

According to Ben Fuller of the Associated Press, the President has narrowed his potential Supreme Court nominees to a shortlist of six:

The six names confirmed as being under review by Obama include three judges, two members of his administration and one governor.

Officials familiar with Obama's deliberations say other people are also being discussed, including names that have not triggered public speculation.

Among those Obama is considering are Solicitor General Elena Kagan, Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano and U.S. Appeals Court judges Sonia Sotomayor and Diane Pamela Wood. California Supreme Court Justice Carlos Moreno is also under review by Obama.

Sources familiar with Obama's deliberations confirmed the names to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because no candidates have been revealed by the White House. The confirmation amounts to the first time any name has been directly tied to Obama.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Tweeting from Space

Space shuttle astronaut Mike Massimino has become the first person ever to use Twitter from space.

Call it a  small step for one man, a giant tweet for mankind. 

Video: Mulroney Testifies

Brian Mulroney's testimony began at the Oliphant Commission yesterday. Video, via CBC:

Full video of Mr. Mulroney's testimony is available at CPAC.

The Toronto Star has two wrap-ups of the former Prime Minister's evidence: Mulroney Takes Jabs at Harper and Vintage Brian Mulroney has Regrets

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Quotable: On Torture, Waterboarding, and Dick Cheney

Jesse (the Governing Body) Ventura, former Minnesota Governor, Navy Seal and professional wrestler:  
I would prosecute every person who was involved in that torture. I would prosecute the people that did it, I would prosecute the people that ordered it, because torture is against the law... I was waterboarded [in training] so I know... It is torture...I'll put it to you this way:  You give me a waterboard, Dick Cheney and one hour, and I'll have him confess to the Sharon Tate murders.
Here's the video:


The Tissue-Box SCOTUS Test

Eric Turkewitz, writer of the excellent New York Personal Injury Lawyer blog, discusses the qualities he'd like to see in Presisdent Obama's nominee for the U.S. Supreme Court seat vacated by Justice David Souter: 
I want to talk about tissues and the law... what I want to know is if the nominee has ever had a box of tissues on his or her desk. For clients.

I want a nominee that knows what it's like to have someone cry in their office. I want a nominee that has been there when someone tells them that their mother/father/brother/daughter was arrested/injured/killed and that they are desperate for help.

I want a nominee to know what it's like to see real people -- not political philosophies or corporate giants trying to add a few cents per share to their earnings -- in their office in distress, and to represent them. I want a nominee that has experienced being the last, best hope for a downtrodden individual and the problem brought in the door. I want someone who knows what it's like to be the underdog against corporate or government interests.

I want a nominee to know what it's like to make the rent. To pay an employee. From their own pocket and not someone else's. To answer the phones. To argue the case. To battle against deception. To actually practice law in the real world instead of in the ivory tower under the protective wings of others.

Well said.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Monday, May 11, 2009

NHL, Balsillie Litigate Phoenix Coyotes' Future

The battle between the National Hockey League and Canada's Blackberry billionaire, Jim Basillie, over the future of the Phoenix Coyotes franchise is shaping up as one of the most interesting - and important - professional sports litigation cases in recent history.

While its current venue is an Arizona bankruptcy court, the case may ultimately break now ground in establishing the conditions under which professional sports leagues will be permitted to limit the mobility of their franchises and protect the territorial exclusivity of member teams.  

Sports writer Howard Berger provides his take:
The battle for control of the Phoenix Coyotes has simmered for the moment, but will pick up with a vengeance when the opposing sides re-convene in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Arizona on May 19th. If Judge Redfield T. Baum rules that the Coyotes belong to Jerry Moyes, and can therefore file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection and be sold to the highest bidder [Jim Balsillie], the NHL will surely appeal the decision, delaying not only the potential movement of the franchise, but the timely completion of a schedule for the 2009-10 season.

It’s anyone’s guess as to how the dispute will be won, but I am most intrigued by
Balsillie’s accusation in a separate claim that the NHL is running an “illegal cartel”. For many years, I have wondered about the unilateral declaration of territorial claim that is common in all professional leagues, but doesn’t appear to be constitutional. In a free-enterprise system, competing factions are encouraged to exist in proximity to one another; it’s the reason a Burger King restaurant can set up shop across the street from an existing McDonald’s franchise. Such an arrangement satisfies anti-trust regulations by discouraging monopolistic tendencies.

Professional sport, however, is largely built on monopolizing lucrative territory; its clubs command astronomical indemnification from groups that wish to invade turf that is already “owned”. It is believed that team and league executives liberally collude to prevent competition – a charge, in the NHL, that is frequently brought against the Maple Leafs and the commissioner’s office. This appears to contravene the rules the rest of our society lives by and it
isn’t clear how it might withstand a vigorous legal challenge. What is clear is that such a challenge could be fashioned by money-bags Balsillie, and there’s no telling how it might impact the accepted rule in pro sport. 

The reversal of such a long-term practice could affect the most routine elements of sport – those which are overlooked in legal circles for being internally policed...
The Burger King-McDonald's analogy doesn't quite hold up - while McDonald's franchisees may well bear the risk of competition from other arm's-length businesses, they typically have contractual protection from the possibility that the franchisor will open another McDonald's outlet across the street. 

Canada.com's John Mackinnon worries that Balsillie's alleged end-run around the NHL's procedures could cause "untold damage" to the NHL boardroom:

It's a Canadian conceit that placing franchises in Winnipeg, Quebec City and southern Ontario is a patriotic imperative, while hoping the sport will bloom in the Arizona desert or flourish under Florida palm trees is outright lunacy.

...Permitting an undeniably bright, deep-pockets entrepreneur like Balsillie to dictate his own terms of entry and set up shop where he darn well pleases could do untold damage to the dynamic around the board table. It beggars common sense to think the governors are anxious to welcome a partner whose approach to franchise ownership is Robert Irsay meets Al Davis.

Irsay was the man who literally packed up the assets of the Colts in Baltimore back in March 1984 and executed the old midnight move to Indianapolis.

Davis ("Just win, baby") successfully used anti-trust legislation to move his Raiders from Oakland to Los Angeles and back again.

There was nothing the NFL could do about it.

Irsay and Davis succeeded, all right, but that sure doesn't make them role models.

Perhaps, but isn't it clear that the real reason for Mr. Balsillie's aggressive tact is that he's become justifiably convinced the NHL will never, under ordinary circumstances, award a franchise to Hamilton.  Plainly, the unbending and long-established territorial-exclusivity claims of the Toronto Maple Leafs and Buffalo Sabres organizations are not far beneath the surface of this litigation. 

The pending Coyotes litigation will likely put these territorial rights - and the NHL's ability to protect them - to their ultimate, and perhaps overdue, legal test.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

Ontario Court Permits Twitter, Live-Blogging from O'Brien Hearing

Web 2.0 took another giant step toward respectability - and functionality - in Ontario's courts yesterday, with the decision of an Ontario Superior Court judge to permit members of the media to provide real-time reporting on a trial-in-progress - using Twitter.

Via Michael Geist:
The judge presiding over the criminal trial of Ottawa mayor Larry O'Brien has blocked the use of television cameras, but given the go-ahead for live blogging and the use of Twitter.
Canadian Press has more:

Judge Douglas Cunningham... shot down the CBC's bid to have cameras follow the trial in real time, but agreed to a bid by Canwest News Service to have a reporter file instantly to a popular social networking site from within the courtroom. The judge's ruling effectively opens the gates to all media at O'Brien's trial to file real-time text stories by wireless device.

..."What we are talking about here is instant text transmission to the blogosphere, but that is the world in which we live," said Cunningham.

..."I ... recognize that some private information or protected information could inappropriately be disclosed," said the judge.

"But I'm afraid that's a risk I'll have to take, recognizing as I do the calibre of counsel I have before me in this case."

Monday, May 04, 2009

Ashcroft, Gonzales Disavow the "Nixon Defence"

From Think Progress: Gonzales And Ashcroft Disagree With Rice: Just Because A President Says It Does Not Make It Legal

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Sunday, May 03, 2009

'Scapegoat' Charles Graner Plans Appeal, Centers on Torture Memos

From the Washington Post:

Now, the recent release of Justice Department memos authorizing the use of harsh interrogation techniques has given Graner and other soldiers new reason to argue that they were made scapegoats for policies approved at high levels. They also contend that the government's refusal to acknowledge those polices when Graner and others were tried undermined their legal defenses

Graner remains locked up at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., about halfway through a 10-year prison sentence for detainee abuse, assault and dereliction of duty. His lawyer said this week that he is drafting appeals arguments centered largely on the revelations in the memos and a newly released congressional investigation into the interrogation practices

...Charles Gittins, a Virginia lawyer who represents Graner, said he has been fuming since reading the memos. He said he has long believed that there was no way Graner and the other Army Reservists invented techniques such as stress positions, leashing and the use of dogs, and he says the documents confirmed his suspicions
.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Saturday, May 02, 2009

Jack F. Kemp, 1935 - 2009

Jack Kemp, former Republican Vice-Presidential nomineee, U.S. Congressman and CFL and NFL quarterback has died at age 74. 

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Ignatieff Annointed

Michael Ignatieff has offically taken the reins as leader of the Liberal Party of Canada.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Libel - In 140 Characters or Less

The Financial Post looks at the first U.S. libel suit arising from a Tweet. The claim stems from allegedly defamatory comments made on Twitter by rocker Courtney Love:
Can you really libel someone in 140 characters or less?
The short answer, you could quickly tweet, is yes. The first libel suit against a Twitter user was launched in March, in the United States. It joins a growing class of suits against bloggers, message-board posters and social network users.In the case of the first lawsuit, notorious rocker Courtney Love is being sued by designer Dawn Simorangkir, also known as Boudoir Queen, who alleges Ms. Love made defamatory comments about her in a tweet.
The article follows with an update on defamation suits against bloggers:
While Twitter is new ground, lawsuits related to blogs are on the rise. The New York-based Media Law Resource Center says it is tracking 258 Web-related U. S. lawsuits, a sharp increase from 110 a year ago. Some of the lawsuits involve defamation, others deal with copyright infringement or fake profiles on social network sites such as MySpace and Facebook. The majority of Internet-related lawsuits are connected to blog postings, says Eric Robinson, a staff lawyer with the Media Law group. 
A year ago, blog lawsuits were a novelty, but they have been growing quickly. And so have the resulting awards -- one as high as US$12.5-million. "The Internet was the Wild West, but now the sheriffs are coming in," Mr. Robinson says.

Press Scrutiny of Family Courts

From an editorial in today's Globe and Mail:

If Canadians could cram en masse into the bitter courtrooms where child-custody disputes play out, there might be fewer nasty divorces. Since they can't, they should be allowed to read about them, which is why an Ontario judge was right to reject a request from the provincial Office of the Children's Lawyer for a gag order on the lawyers and family members in a notorious case of "parental alienation syndrome." A cautionary tale that no one can hear is not much good to anyone.

...All Canadians have an interest in making sure that the children of high-conflict divorce are protected, and that those charged with protecting them, including the courts and the Office of the Children's Lawyer, do good, and not harm. That is why the courts are open. The freedom of the press belongs not only to the media, but to all Canadians.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG