Showing posts with label termination of employment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label termination of employment. Show all posts

Sunday, May 31, 2020

Ford Government: Ontario's 13-Week Layoff Limit Eliminated During COVID Emergency

The Ford Government has made a crucial, temporary change to Ontario's Employment Standards Act (ESA) that will impact countless employers and employees in the Province.

By operation of Ontario Regulation 228/20, published on May 29, 2020, the ordinary 13-week limit on the duration of workplace layoffs has effectively been suspended. This time-limit will not apply to employees who have been laid off due to COVID-related slowdowns and closures.

The Regulation will apply from March 1, 2020 until six-weeks after the Government ends its March 17 emergency COVID-19 declaration. It repesents a significant change that many employers have been clamouring for.

Ordinarily, where an employee is not recalled from a layoff within 13 weeks, the layoff is deemed to be a termination of employment by operation of section 56 (2)(a) of the ESA. 

There are certain exceptions in the Act to this deemed termination rule. These occur:
  • Where the extended layoff is less than 35 weeks in any period of 52 consecutive weeks, and 
  • The employee continues to receive substantial payments from the employer and
  • The employer continues benefit payments for the employee.
Essentially, this Regulation means employers will no longer have a risk of liability for statutory notice or severance payments to employees who have been laid off for more than 13 weeks due to COVID-19, or to those whose hours or compensation are reduced during the COVID period.

In addition, the Regulation provides that no COVID-related reductions in employees' hours or compensation on or after March 1, 2020 will be treated as a constructive dismissal under the Act.

Many Ontario workplaces that are still closed due to COVID would have been approaching the statutory, 13-week layoff limit within the next week or two.

There was great concern among small employers and profesional practices, in particular, that they would face enormous, mandatory severance obligations to multiple employees at once at the end of the 13 week layoff period, even if they were still unable to open.

For some employers, such severance obligations could have become bankruptcy-triggering events.

As examples, most restaurants and mall-based retail outlets are not yet legally permitted to fully reopen, and after months of closure and partial-closures due the the Emergency Declaration, many could not possibly have withstood the costs of mandatory notice and severance obligations.

Similarly, many Ontario dentists - who until changes announced May 31 remained subject to significant regulatory restrictions that prevented them from providing non-urgent care, seeing recall patients or offering dental hygiene services - have simply been unable to re-open or to recall employees, given the potentially low demand for the few services they had been able to provide.

While some have argued that this Regulation represents a major blow for employees, I'm not pursuaded that there is much truth to that.

With the elimination of the 13-week layoff limit, employees ultimately get some degree of job protection. They will not automatically be deemed to be terminated. Many love their jobs and are chomping at their collective bits to get back to work, as soon as possible.  They are prepared to work collaboratively with their employers toward re-opening and do not want to be automatically dismissed by operation of the ESA.

For those that ultimately will not be returning, their entitlements to notice and severance have been delayed, not eliminated. Most are currently receiving EI or other government benefits, in the interim. That's not a perfect solution, of course, and the uncertainty about the future remains.

Without this Regulation, however, many workplaces faced a serious risk of insolvency and closure due to notice and other statutory obligations, alone.  This legislation temporarily removes that immediate risk, and gives employers additional time to get back on their financial feet so that jobs can be preserved.

Beyond that, this Regulation 228/20 gives employers and employees the flexibiity - with mitigated legal risk - to implement the gradual, staged approach to re-opending mandated by the Province and by public health authorities.

COVID closures were not the fault of employers or employees. This Regulation appears to be a fair effort to share the burden, balance the respective interests and at very least, to buy some much needed time.

As a final note, while the Regulation addresses the statutory standards set out in the ESA, it does not at first glance appear to impact or preclude Court-based claims for damages for wrongful dismissal or constructive dismissal. This is particularly important for those employees who did not expressly agree to their current layoffs and those who have not signed valid employment agreements that permit such layoffs.

It should also be noted that his new Regulation will not be applicable to those whose workplaces reduce hours or compensation for discriminatory or improper reasons that are unrelated to COVID, or to employers that otherwise go rogue. 

As always, there remains uncertainty as to how the Courts will ultimately address such claims.  Legal advice should be obtained by any employee with concerns related to COVID in the workpace.

To arrange a consultation with a Wise Law workplace and employment lawyer, click here.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, August 29, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday August 29, 2017.


Today we are talking about Employment Law.



For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit us at http://www.wiselaw.net
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, May 26, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Thursday May 26, 2017. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

In 2015, an Ontario Court awarded 27 months’ of pay in lieu of reasonable notice to a 65-year-old civil engineer who had been employed for 40.66 years.

In exceptional circumstances involving extraordinarily long-service employees, it is within the discretion of Ontario Courts to award more than 24 months’ damages. 

For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit our website at www.wiselaw.net.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, March 28, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday March 28, 2017. Today we are talking about Employment Law.



“My ex-employer just gave me a severance proposal, but I was only given 3 days to respond. Is that legal?”

The law does not address this question. As a courtesy, you or your lawyer should advise your former employer in writing if an extension is required.

For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit our website at www.wiselaw.net

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday February 14, 2017. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

For more information on Employment Law, Family Law, and Wills, Estates, and Estates Litigation, visit our website at www.wiselaw.net.



In addition to the minimum notice and severance required by the Employment Standards Act, Ontario employees are entitled to reasonable notice of termination (or pay in lieu of thereof upon termination of employment

Unless an employment contract limits an employee’s entitlements, reasonable notice will be based on duration of employment, type of position, age and many other factors.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, January 10, 2017

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday January 10, 2017. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

It is very difficult for employers to prove “just cause” for termination, unless there is evidence of gross or wilful misconduct, like theft, fraud, or intentional dereliction of duties.

To establish “cause” for termination because of performance concerns, employers must typically provide several written warnings as well as adequate opportunity for the employee to improve job performance.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, December 20, 2016

When is a Layoff Really a Termination in Disguise?

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 
Simran Bakshi

There are big differences between the ways the law treats employee layoffs and permanent terminations. 

Although the terms are often used interchangeably when describing employment that has ended, they are not the same thing at all.


A layoff, by definition, is temporary in nature, premised on the mutual understanding that the employee will in due time be recalled to return to work. In contrast, a termination is generally intended to be a permanent end of employment, and requires that the employer provide notice or pay in lieu of notice, where the dismissal occurs without any just or proper cause.


Where an employee has not consented to this arrangement, the attempted layoff may be challenged as actually being a constructive dismissal. That is, the employer may be seen as having fundamentally altered the terms of the parties’ employment agreement, by choosing to no longer actively employ the employee. In such circumstances, the employee may be entitled to treat the employment relationship as having been effectively terminated, and claim notice or pay in lieu of this notice for this termination.


It is therefore a good idea to consult with an employment lawyer if you have been laid off, to determine assess your circumstances and entitlements.An important question to consider then is when is a layoff actually a layoff, and when is it merely a termination in disguise?


Ontario's courts have long held that for an employer to legally lay off any employee, there must be an employment contract with that employee that specifically or implicitly authorizes such a layoff. 





[As a side note, in the 2013 decision of Trites v Renin Corp., the Court suggested that, contrary to this generally-accepted legal principle, there is in fact no formal requirement that an employment contract include any layoff-permitting provisions, so long as the employer otherwise complied with the ESA. This decision does not however appear to have been applied or followed by the Courts thereafter, and in fact was expressly rejected in the more 2016 case of Michalski v Cima Canada Inc.] 


The employer must also fully comply with the layoff provisions set out in the Employment Standards Act. In particular, in accordance with section 56(2) of the ESA:
Temporary lay-off
(2) For the purpose of clause (1) (c), a temporary layoff is, 
(a) a lay-off of not more than 13 weeks in any period of 20 consecutive weeks; 
(b) a lay-off of more than 13 weeks in any period of 20 consecutive weeks, if the lay-off is less than 35 weeks in any period of 52 consecutive weeks and, 
(i) the employee continues to receive substantial payments from the employer,(ii) the employer continues to make payments for the benefit of the employee under a legitimate retirement or pension plan or a legitimate group or employee insurance plan,(iii) the employee receives supplementary unemployment benefits,(iv) the employee is employed elsewhere during the lay-off and would be entitled to receive supplementary unemployment benefits if that were not so,(v) the employer recalls the employee within the time approved by the Director, or(vi) in the case of an employee who is not represented by a trade union, the employer recalls the employee within the time set out in an agreement between the employer and the employee; or 
(c) in the case of an employee represented by a trade union, a lay-off longer than a lay-off described in clause (b) where the employer recalls the employee within the time set out in an agreement between the employer and the trade union.  

The employer may not be required to provide a specific recall date (unless the employment contract provides for otherwise), but it must strictly adhere to the time frames set out in the ESA. If the employer lays the employee off for a period longer than the period of a temporary lay-off, it will be held to have terminated the employee’s position of employment.

Overall, it is important to appreciate the requirements of a layoff in order to better understand whether the circumstances presenting constitute an actual temporary layoff, or rather reflect a permanent termination of employment.

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, December 13, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday December 13, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

Can an employer lawfully terminate an exceptional employee who has had consistently good performance reviews?

Under Ontario law, an employer may terminate any employee without cause, so long as the employer provides reasonable notice, or pay instead of such notice, to the employee.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, November 22, 2016

Top 7 Tips for Getting Fired Like a Pro

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER


It is never a pleasant experience to learn that your employment is being terminated, no matter what the circumstances may be.

Nonetheless, there is a right way of handling your dismissal. If you are careful in the way you handle your exit, it is possible to protect your legal interests and comfortably make the transition to the next chapter of your career and life.

Here are our top seven tips for getting fired like a pro:

      1.  Leave your job with grace and composure

Perhaps the best advice anyone could ever give you is to take a moment, breathe and not panic.

While it may be momentarily tempting to burst into tears, or to delete all of the files you've been working on or to finally tell your boss exactly what you really think of him or her, resist the temptation.

There is very little value in lashing out at your former employer, and in fact, in many cases, doing so will likely make the situation far worse for you. While your conduct following the termination of your employment typically does not have any bearings on the reasons for the dismissal itself, there have been some cases where Courts have considered post-termination misconduct in determining whether an Employer ultimately had cause to terminate.  

On the flip side, presenting yourself in a professional manner, even in the moments after you've been dismissed can go a long way. Remember, your objective may likely be to find another job within the same industry, and your now-former employer might be one of the best sources for such references and even job referrals.

Don't be surprised by the fact that your employer may wish for the termination to take effect immediately, and may even escort you to your desk and off the work premises. While this can undoubtedly be an upsetting and embarrassing experience, try not to take it personally. Bear in mind that such workplace policies were developed to ensure that there are no breaches of security, and not to make publicly shame you. Take your time to pack your belongings, and if appropriate and permitted, to say your goodbyes to your colleagues.

Of course, if your former goes too far in acting inappropriately during your termination, you may (in some extreme cases) have additional remedies and even be entitled to added compensation.


2.  Don't sign anything!


More often than not, an employer will inform you of the termination of your employment at a meeting attended by your manager and a human resources representative.

They will likely come prepared with a Letter of Termination, which may or may not set out a severance proposal, and include a Release.

It is very important that you do not sign anything without first consulting with an employment law lawyer. Signing a release will in most cases bar you from bringing any further legal claims against your employer relating to your termination.

If your employer does offer you a severance package, it may impose a deadline by which to receive your response.  Keep in mind, that regardless of whether you accept this package by the deadline or not, your employer remains obligated to provide your minimum notice and or severance entitlements as set out by the applicable employment legislation.  You may also have additional rights to common law notice by bringing a wrongful dismissal claim.

Don't rush into signing anything, as your entitlements may be far greater than what is being offered to you in this severance package. Your lawyer can review your employer's proposal with you to help you determine whether it is reasonable in the circumstances.

While you may feel pressured by the looming deadline, keep in mind that an employer will quite often agree to a reasonable extension in time so that you can properly review the offer, understand its implications and consider your legal options.

And besides, you don't work for them any more. They don't get to give you arbitrary deadlines any more.  


3.  Get legal advice and carefully weigh your legal options


It is important that you seek legal guidance upon your termination to discuss whether you should consider taking legal action against your former employer.

A lawyer will review your employment history, the context leading to your dismissal, and any severance offers that have been proposed to determine:

(i)                 Whether it is a good idea to attempt to negotiate and/or bring a claim against your former employer;
(ii)               The nature and potential value of such a claim;
(iii)             Which forum you should consider proceeding in;
(iv)              The merits of your claim, and the legal obstacles to be aware of;
(v)                The general process, time frame and legal costs involved;

Be prepared with a copy of your termination letter as well as a copy of your original and most recent employment contract. These documents will be very telling to your lawyer with respect to what your entitlements may be.

While you certainly do not want to rush into taking any legal action, it is important that you consult with a lawyer in a timely manner as there are limitation periods, in other words deadlines, applicable to when you may be able to bring a claim, that vary depending on the nature of your claims.


4. Don't ever file an Ontario Employment Standards complaint before you have consulted with your lawyers

This part is simple. 

Under section 97(2) of Ontario's Employment Standards Act, an employee who files a Employment Standards complaint alleging an entitlement to termination pay or severance pay may not commence a civil proceeding for wrongful dismissal that relates to the same termination or severance of employment.

In other words, if you go the Employment Standards route, you give up your ability to claim damages in court for wrongful dismissal.  That could cause a significant loss of your entitlement to compensation, particularly if you were a longer-term employee.  

So get qualified legal advice first.
  
5.  Start your job hunt 

The very purpose of a severance package that may be offered to you is to support and assist you through the transition period, as you look for a new job.

It is important that you appreciate that if you make a claim for damages for wrongful dismissal, you have a duty at law to take reasonable steps to look for new employment to try to mitigate your losses.  Depending on the circumstances, starting your own business, or going back to school may also be considered reasonable steps to mitigate your losses.

Bear in mind that since the objective of severance payments is to compensate you for your income losses during a reasonable notice period, if you are successful in finding a new job and mitigating your losses, the income that you earn may be deducted from what your former employer would otherwise have to pay you.

6.  Keep detailed records of your job search

Given its importance in your claim, it is best practice to keep records and logs of your job search, including the dates on which you search, the hours you spent looking, the websites you have visited, the recruiters or employment agencies you consult and details and documentation showing all jobs yo apply for and all interviews granted.  

Keep copies or screenshots of all job applications and cover letters you send, rejection letters you receive and all job offers advanced to you, even if you don't accept them.

7.  Take advantage of resources available
Thankfully, there are resources available to assist you both financially and emotionally through your dismissal.

Perhaps the most well known resource for those who qualify is Employment Insurance ("EI"), which can provide temporary financial assistance.

Again, it is important to remember that your employment law claim is meant to compensate you for actual wages lost during a reasonable notice period.  As a result, if your former employer subsequently agrees to compensate you for a period of time during which you have already received EI benefits, you may be required to pay back the EI dollars that you have received. 

This is commonly referred to as the EI clawback.

The Ontario government has a number of programs in place to assist employees who have been dismissed from their jobs transition to new roles:
  • Through the Adjustment Advisory Program, you can meet with a support group and with an adviser to discuss how best to land on your feet following a company layoff or plant closure. For more information, visit: https://www.ontario.ca/page/adjusting-after-job-loss
Finally, as part of your severance package, your former employer may agree to pay for private services that provide vocational counseling and outplacement.

There is a silver lining that comes with your dismissal from employment. You are presented with an opportunity to start a new chapter in your life that better reflects your career goals and overall life objectives. Consulting with a lawyer, financial adviser and career counselor can often help you make this transition more seamless. 

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer, Toronto


Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, September 27, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday September 27, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


Can an employer lawfully terminate an exceptional employee who has had consistently good performance reviews?

Under Ontario law, an employer may terminate any employee without cause, so long as the employer provides reasonable notice, or pay instead of such notice, to the employee.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, July 26, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday July 26, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


It is very difficult for employers to prove “just cause” for termination, unless there is evidence of gross or wilful misconduct, like theft, fraud, or intentional dereliction of duties.

To establish “cause” for termination because of performance concerns, employers must typically provide several written warnings as well as adequate opportunity for the employee to improve job performance.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, May 16, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Monday May 16, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by null (@wiselaw) on

Did you know "use it or lose it" vacation policies are illegal?

Upon termination of employment, any outstanding vacation is owed to the employee.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Heckling the Home Team: Off-Duty Conduct and Dismissal for Cause

BY NITIN PARDAL, LAWYER, WISE LAW OFFICE

Can you be fired for booing the home team?  As this Toronto Star article points out, it might not be out of the question, at least in New York City.

While attending a New York Knicks game at Madison Square Garden with his supervisor and two clients, Anthony Rotondi yelled out, "Carmello, you stink!" [referring to Knicks' player Carmello Anthony].

The seats, owned by Mr. Rotondi's employer, ING Financial Services, were situated four rows behind the Knicks' bench. 

Mr. Rotondi's remark led to:  
  • his ejection from the arena;
  • his arrest and charges for "tampering with a sports contest and criminal trespass"; and
  • the dismissal of his employment of 12 years with ING Financial Services. 
If he were employed in Ontario, Mr. Rotondi would arguably have a cause of action against his former employee for wrongful dismissal.  In its defence, ING Financial Services would likely argue that Mr. Rotondi's off-duty conduct justified his dismissal. 

This begs the question:  What kind of off-duty conduct could justify an Ontario employee's dismissal for cause?

Dismissal for Off-Duty Conduct

As the Newfoundland Superior Court noted in a 1992 case, Strowbridge v. Re/Max United Inc., in order to establish that an employee's off-duty conduct constitutes cause for dismissal, an employer must show that there was a nexus or connection between the employee's off-duty conduct and the employment relationship and that the conduct:
  • detrimentally affected the employer's reputation;
  • caused the employee to be unable to discharge his/her employment obligations;
  • caused other employees to refuse to work with the employee; or
  • adversely affect the employer's ability to direct or efficiently mange the production process.
Here are some examples of cases where an employee's off-duty conduct did justify dismissal for cause:
  • In Hyland v. Royal Alexandria Hospital, a 2000 decision from the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta, a Internal Auditor participated in an GST-avoidance scheme when purchasing a private vehicle.  The court upheld his termination for cause;
  • In Whitehouse v. RBC Dominion Securities Inc., a 2006 decision from the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta, a senior employee brought prostitutes to the employer's premises during off business hours.  His dismissal for cause was upheld; and
  • In Marshall v. Pacific Coast Savings Credit Union, a 1995 decision from the British Columbia Supreme Court, an employee failed to pay off a credit card debt after arranging a loan from the defendant employer for that purpose. This led to a lack of confidence in the employee's integrity and according to the Court, justified his dismissal for cause.
The Case at Hand

Returning to Mr. Rotondi and his dismissal from ING Financial Services, can it be argued that his conduct at Madison Square Garden, was in fact not "off-duty?" Consider the fact that he was attending the game with his supervisor and clients, and that the seats for the game were owned by his employer.  Clearly his behaviour in this context did reflect on his employer.

Its a question of degree - it would be far more difficult to establish that the mere heckling of a professional athlete during the course of a sports event "detrimentally affected the employer's reputation" unless the heckling behaviour was seriously out of the ordinary, extreme or "over-the-top."

As for Carmello Anthony, the player at whom Mr. Rotondi's remarks were directed, he ended up with a game high of 34 points and led his team to a 89-85 win against the Detroit Pistons. 

Perhaps Mr. Rotondi's comments served as the catalyst for the Knicks win.
- Nitin Pardal, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Ontario Employment Law: Just Cause For Dismissal Doesn't Necessarily Amount to Wilful Misconduct

A finding of just cause for dismissal at common law does not automatically disqualify an employee from entitlement to statutory severance and termination benefiits under Ontario's Employment Standards Act, according to an important March 14, 2011 ruling of the Ontario Superior Court Ontario in Oosterbosch v. FAG Aerospace Inc.

In Oosterbach, a long term-employee was terminated by his employer based on its policy of progressive discipline, with termination being the last step of that process. Specifically, it was alleged that the machine operator- employee had engaged in a persistent pattern of careless misconduct over a period of approximately 1.5 years preceding his termination, despite having received a number of warnings and suspensions and numerous coaching and counselling sessions.

Among other infractions, the employer alleged the employee had falsified records and ran a number of pieces (to be used in the aerospace industry) that did not conform to prescribed specifications.

Justice Haines found that the employer had demonstrated "just cause" at common law for the termination of the Plaintiff's employment:
. . . In my view the persistence of the plaintiff's misconduct notwithstanding ongoing coaching sessions and warnings constitute a repudiation of the employment relationship. This conclusion is reinforced by the initiation of a further discipline investigation on March 28, 2008 for unsatisfactory work performance before the discipline process was concluded for the infraction on March 20 that resulted in the issuance of the fourth written warning.
Thus, the court found that the employee careless conduct disentitled him to reasonable notice of his termination at common law.

From this conclusion, one might expect that a finding of "wilful misconduct" under the Ontario Employment Standards Act, disentitling the employee to severance pay and termination pay, would inexorably follow.

But the court found otherwise, holding that his misconduct, while not to be condoned, did not rise to the required level of recklessness to meet the ESA's "“wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty” test:
A person is reckless when he engages in conduct without regard for the outcome or consequences. Notwithstanding the number of infractions recorded I do not see that the conduct of the plaintiff rises to that level. He was undoubtedly careless and the persistence of that carelessness justified his dismissal. I would not, however, characterize his offending behaviour as "wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty" that would disentitle him to receipt of termination and severance payments under the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, 2000.
This case is a significant employment law decision for a number of reasons:
  • It establishes that a finding of "just cause" at common law will not always equate to "wilful misconduct" under Ontario Employment Standards Act.
  • It reminds us that as the threshold for establishing "just cause" is a high one, numerous written warnings and counselling sessions will likely be required before any such finding is made, particularly with regard to a long-term employee.
  • It establishes that an employer's progressive discipline system is not dispositive of a "just cause" finding. Whether or not an employer had "just cause" is a legal question which requires a contextual analysis.
The ruling appears to mandate a two-pronged analysis in assessing termination "for cause." Firstly, consideration must be given to whether the impugned behaviour meets the traditionally high "just cause" threshold.

If it does, while there will be no common law entitlement to pay in lieu of notice, a second enquiry must then occur as to whether the even more stringent "wilful misconduct" standard under the ESA has been met.

If this ruling survives appeal, it it provides a ray of hope for employees who are terminated for cause.

As Stikeman Elliot's Randall Boessenkool noted in an article today, "This case is a precedent which should concern employers."

(HT: Michael Fitzgibbon's recent article on this ruling.)

- Garry J. Wise and Robert Tanha, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net