Monday, December 19, 2016

140Law: Legal Headlines for the week of December 19, 2016

Here are this week's leading legal news stories from Wise Law on Twitter



- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, December 15, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Wills and Estates

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Thursday December 15, 2016. Today we are talking about Wills and Estates.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


Everyone who applies in Ontario for a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee is required to file an Estate Information Return within 90 calendar days after a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee has been issued by the Court. 

An Estate Information Return must be filed with the Ministry of Finance. This form is used to certify the net value of the assets of an Estate and to verify the Estate Administration taxes payable by an Estate.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

The (Dreaded) Ontario Estate Information Return

Paul Adam, Wise Law
"What my thankless job managing an estate needs is more expense and paperwork," said no Executor ever.

Nonetheless, the Ontario Estate Information Return has arrived and is here to stay.

Effective January 1, 2015, every Executor or Estate Trustee who obtains a grant of probate (also known in Ontario as a certificate of appointment) must accurately complete a comprehensive 7 page report about the value of all assets of the deceased person on the date of death.

The Information Return is due 90 days after a Certificate of Appointment is issued.

What new work has been created for trustees in light of this exciting new legal requirement?

The Information Form requires the Estate Trustee to accurately disclose information to the government about:
  1. the value of the deceased's property, including real estate, in Ontario, and the value of interests the deceased had in property legally owned by someone else;
  2. the value of the deceased's investments on date of death;
  3. the balance in bank accounts on date of death; 
  4. the value of cars and other vehicles and "vessels" (which include "motorcycles, boats, all-terrain vehicles, bicycles, snowmobiles, etc.");
  5. the value of other assets (the form lists as examples: "business interests, copyrights, patents, trademarks, household contents, art, jewelry, loans receivable, etc.").
This information is utilized to update and verify information previously disclosed in the application for estate administration as to the Estate's value.  Ontario probate fees, now known as estate administration taxes, are paid at the time an application for administration is filed, and are calculated as a percentage of the Estate's value, as disclosed in the Application.

(Current estate administration taxes in Ontario for estates valued over $50,000 are $250 + $15 for each $1,000 or part thereof by which the value of the estate exceeds $50,000)

Additional estate administration taxes - or refunds - may be payable based on the new numbers, once the updated valuation information in the Estate Information Return has been filed.

Ontario Estate Information Return
Ontario Estate Information Return
The Estate Information Return is in its infancy as a legal document, but the Ontario Government has already signaled that the values reported on the Estate Information Return must be backed up by professional valuations. That means Estate Trustees will now need to have a plan (and the money) to produce an objective valuation of estate assets. 

The upside to this is that it may provide an incentive for estate trustees to get organized quickly to appraise and call in all of the assets of the estate earlier in the administration process, which saves time down the road.

The downside is that estate trustees will need even more funds at their disposal to pay the professional fees necessary to deal appropriately with reporting. This will make administering an Estate an even more costly and time-consuming operation, even if there aren't any legal disputes at stake among estate beneficiaries.

If the estate trustee needs to pay for some of the accounting and appraisal fees out of pocket, that trustee will need a few thousand dollars set aside while waiting to be reimbursed out of the Estate's assets. That's a luxury not every trustee will be able to easily afford. 

There are plenty of compelling arguments that fair taxes on inheritance, including Ontario's Estate Administration Tax (the highest in Canada) are important and necessary tools to address the tax-free inter-generational transfer of wealth, which is the main mechanism by which the wealthy stay wealthy



But, it seems that reporting measures like Estate Information Returns will put a big squeeze on small- and medium-sized estates, for which paying extra professional fees is a significant expense.

Conversely, it may not do much to stop large estates from (legally) avoiding high taxes with expensive estate planning and the preparation of complex last wills. Furthermore, instead of using the mechanism of estate taxes to redress income inequality, paperwork like the Estate Information Return may wind up redistributing a lot of hard-earned money from beneficiaries to valuators, accountants and other professionals.

- Paul B. Adam, Toronto

Wednesday, December 14, 2016

Task Force Goes Into the Weeds on Canada's Legalization of Marijuana

BY GARRY J. WISE

Matt Mauer has an epic post today at Slaw regarding extensive recommendations, now released by a federal task force, on implementing marijuana legalization in Canada.

See: Task Force Recommendations on Legalization of Marijuana: The “Coles” Notes.  

Matt has done the heavy lifting with a very detailed overview, which I highly recommend (pun absolutely not intended).

I'll touch on a few of the report's highlights:
  • The corner, marijuana-only store will be a more likely retailer of the future than the LCBO, if the report's recommendations are to be followed. The task force recommends that cannabis should not be sold in locations that also sell alcohol or tobacco products. 
  • The report also recommends that private cultivation by individuals of up to four cannabis plants be permitted
  • If the report is followed,social smoking environments such as cannabis lounges will also be allowed
  • It recommends that the law establish a limit of 30 grams, or just over an ounce, for the personal possession of non-medical dried cannabis in public with a corresponding sales limit for dried cannabis
  • To combat marijuana-related impaired driving, it recommends the government invest in the development of roadside drug screening technologies to detect THC levels.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Quotable: Ian Hu on What Clients Really Want

BY GARRY J. WISE, WISE LAW OFFICE

From LawPro's Ian Hu, via Slaw:
Clients have unique concerns. The lawyer’s job is to listen to those concerns and meet them head-on. Not every client is as interested as you are in the workings of the law. More often than not, I have found clients want an interpreter of the law, not a teacher of the law. Avoid legalese. Make it easy to navigate the legal terrain. Communicate using words and phrases the client understands. It’s far too easy to fall into the trap of talking the way you want to talk, not the way the client needs you to talk. The number one source of claims is the failure to communicate. And failure to understand and address the client’s greatest concern can cause the client to lose confidence in you.
Sounds exactly right to me.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

The Tell-Tale Signs of Parental Alienation

BY RACHEL SPENCE, LAW CLERK AND SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 

Parental alienation is sadly not all that uncommon in high conflict separated and divorced families.

In the first of our two-part blog series on this topic, we will begin by setting out what parental alienation is, and how best to recognize the early signs of such behavior. Next week, we will be turning our discussion to how the family courts may choose to address this issue.

It is imperative to have a strong understanding of what parental alienation is as well as what it is not. Unfounded allegations of parental alienation can be just as damaging to your child(ren) (and not to mention, your position before the Courts), so this issue should be broached carefully, with due consideration and caution. Where possible, you should consult with a lawyer and/or a medical professional to help you determine whether there is an issue of parental alienation presented.

What is parental alienation?

Parental alienation is the acts of a parent or family member to psychologically manipulate a child(ren) to harbor feelings of hostility, anger, fear and / or disrespect towards the other parent or family member. The objective of course is to alienate the child(ren) from the other parent, and to discourage the fostering of a meaningful relationship with the other parent.

This is a largely overlooked form of child abuse and family violence. It can often result in long-term estrangement issues, and put the child(ren) at risk of both mental and physical illness, in what has come to be known as "Parental Alienation Syndrome".

The Parental Alienation Syndrome Controversy:

The concept of Parental Alienation Syndrome ("PAS") is not without its own controversy. PAS was first developed by psychiatrist and Columbia University Professor, Richard Gardner, well over twenty years ago, in the context of trying to explain a trend of what he believed to be false accusations of child sexual abuse in child custody cases. Mr. Gardner went on to develop the "sex abuse legitimacy scale", which as you can imagine, made him quite the controversial figure.

His position that parental alienation could be characterized to be a "syndrome" with distinctive signs and symptoms caused by a particular pathological condition or disorder is quite contentious among fellow psychiatrists, psychologists and therapists as well. An interesting read on Mr. Gardner's perspective of PAS can be found here.

While the question of whether or not parental alienation is a syndrome remains controverted, the more important fact for our discussion is that parental alienation is recognized by the Courts as being a form of abuse.



What are early signs of parental alienation?
  • The child(ren) shows a sudden negative change in attitude towards a parent or guardian
  • The child(ren) perceives one parent as causing the financial problems of the other parent
  • The child(ren) appears to have knowledge of details relating to the legal aspects of the divorce or separation
  • The child(ren) appears uneasy around target parent, perhaps resorting to "one word" answers, and failing to engage openly in conversations as was previously the case;
  • The child(ren) is uncharacteristically rude and/or belligerent towards the target parent
  • Access time is not occurring as agreed upon or court ordered - visitation is being unilaterally cut back by the other parent
  • The alienating parent undermines the other parent or speaks disparagingly about other parent in the presence of the child(ren)
  • The alienating parent starts making reference to other parent as being abusive and a risk to the child(ren) with no apparent good reason
  • Allowing the child(ren) to choose whether or not to visit a parent, though not an appropriate decision for him or her to be making, particularly in the case of younger children;
  • Disclosing to the child(ren) why the marriage supposedly failed and giving the child(ren) the details about the divorce or separation settlement;
  • Refusing the other parent access to medical and school records or schedules of extracurricular activities;
  • Blaming the other parent for not having enough money, changes in lifestyle, or other problems in the child(ren)'s presence;
  • Refusal to consider routine requests for scheduling changes, for no reasonable justification, to obstruct the access of the other parent to the child;
  • False allegations of sexual abuse, drug and alcohol use or other illegal activities by the alienating parent;
  • Putting the child(ren) in a position wherein he or she is asked to choose one parent over the other;
  • Encouraging the child to harbor anger or resentment towards the other parent;
  • Setting up temptations to to interfere with the child(ren)'s visitation with the other parent;
  • Giving the child(ren) the impression that having a good time on a visit will hurt the alienating parent;
  • Interrogating the child(ren) about the other parent's personal life;
  • 'Rescuing' the children from the other parent when there is no danger.

What are the statistics related to Parental Alienation?
  •  Indian Journal of Psychiatry, 1988: A child who was separated from his or her father for a period of three (3) months or longer while between the ages of 6 months to 5 years old, suffered a 2.5 to 5 times higher risk of conduct disorder, emotional disorders and hysteria than a child that did not go through the same period of separation.
  •  Bron, Strack & Rudolph, Univ. of Gottingen, Germany, 1991: Drastically increased suicidal tendencies were found in people who had experienced the loss of the father.
  • American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1990: Children showed the most behavior problems if their parents were in a legal conflict and the visitation was not frequent or regular with both parents.
  • Acta Psychiatrica, Scandinavia, 1990, 1993: Scandinavian research found a significantly higher number of attempted adult suicides for people who, in childhood, had lost a parent through parental separation or divorce.
  • British Journal of Psychiatry, 1989: British researchers found that adults who suffered the loss of a parent because of separation or divorce have a significantly higher risk of developing agoraphobia with panic attacks and panic disorder
Going through a divorce or separation can be one of the most trying times of your life, particularly when it involves high conflict custody disputes. As you ride the emotional roller coaster that comes with this, it is so important that you remain as neutral and level-headed about your family situation as possible for the sake of your child(ren).
Next week, we will discuss the Court's recent position on the issue of parental alienation. Stay tuned!
- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk, Toronto
- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday December 14, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

Did you know that...

Where a parent repeatedly interferes to improperly prevent a child from building a positive relationship with the other parent, a court could find that parental alienation has occurred.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Tuesday, December 13, 2016

Viola Desmond to Grace the $10 Bill

Viola Desmond, known as the Canadian Rosa Parks, will officially grace the front of the $10 Canadian bill in 2018.

In 1946 Nova Scotia, Ms. Desmond refused to sit in a movie theatre balcony designated for people of her race, and went to the main floor instead. She was forcibly removed from the theatre, injuring her hip and then arrested. As if that wasn't enough, she was charged with tax evasion over the 1 cent difference between the balcony and main floor tickets and fined $20, which she paid.

Instead of backing down, she fought the charge with lawyer, Frederick William Bissett. The government’s argument at the time was that she had evaded this 1 cent tax. Bissett argued that she was wrongfully accused of tax evasion, not racial discrimination and was unsuccessful.  

In 2010, she was granted a posthumous free pardon and the government of Nova Scotia apologised to her family.

An interesting fact about Ms. Desmond is that she began the Desmond School of Beauty Culture in Nova Scotia to allow black women who were rejected from white only training, a way ahead - many went on to open businesses. 

It may be just a face on money, but it is a widespread visual reminder that rejecting what was once ‘legal’ and ‘socially acceptable’ is no longer.

- Rachel Spence, Law Clerk

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Are Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Clauses Actually Enforceable?

BY SIMRAN BAKSHI, ASSOCIATE LAWYER 

Employment agreements will often include language that is intended to restrict the actions of employees following the end of their employment. These types of clauses, typically relating to confidentiality, non-solicitation and non-competition, are aptly referred to in the employment law world as restrictive covenants.

Most commonly, many employers will seek some assurance that their once all-star employees do not solicit business away from the company. In some cases, employers may even be concerned about former employees leaving a company and going on to compete against it in the same market.

The interests of employers in protecting their businesses must of course be balanced against the rights of employees to pursue their trade of preference

Given their competing interests, it is not all that surprising that restrictive covenants are often controversial and subject to challenge before the Courts.

In determining whether such terms should be enforceable, the Court will not only give weight to the parties’ respective interests, but will also consider the context in which the restrictive covenants were agreed to. While the Court will look to give effect to the parties’ freedom to contract with one another, it will also consider the power dynamics of the parties in negotiations of terms of employment.

The legal test developed by the Supreme Court of Canada in view of these varying interests is as follows:
  1. Does the employer have a proprietary interest entitled to protection? In other words, an employer must have a legitimate reason for seeking to restrict a former employee from having contact with clients, soliciting business or otherwise competing.  Common proprietary interests often include protecting trade secrets, confidential information and trade connections. As an example, it would likely be unreasonable for an employer to include a non-competition clause for its junior administrative support staff, unless of course it had legitimate reasons for doing so.
2.     Are the temporal and geographic elements of the agreement too broad? What this means in plain English is that the restrictive clause cannot be unnecessarily broad. In order to assess this, the Court will consider whether the geographic and time restrictions imposed are reasonable, having regard to a number of factors including: the nature of the industry; the type of relationship between the parties; and the position of the departing employee including the level of trust and confidence he or she enjoyed. While it may for instance be reasonable to limit a senior financial adviser from soliciting the clients that he or she worked with while at the company for a one-year period, it would in all likelihood be unreasonable to impose an indefinite restriction for a junior level bookkeeper to have contact with any of the company’s clients, past, present and future;

3.     Is the covenant unenforceable as being against competition generally, and not limited to proscribing solicitation of clients of the former employee? In other words, did the employer really need a non-compete clause to serve its interests or would a non-solicitation clause have sufficed? As a general principle, non-competition clauses are generally frowned upon in the employment context, though it may have some greater enforceability in circumstances involving the sale of business. That is, preventing an employee from competing in some form or capacity with the employer is not generally practical. However where one party sells its business to another, it would make sense to have some limitations in place to bar the seller from opening shop down the street.

The question of whether a restrictive covenant is reasonable, and accordingly enforceable, must be viewed in context of the employment circumstances overall. What is the nature of the industry? How were the terms of employment negotiated and agreed to? Did the employee bring his or her own clients to the company? Did he or she develop clientele from the Company’s contacts, and/or using its resources? Are clients likely to leave with the employee? Is he or she in a position of trust and confidence? 

Given the nuances involved, it Is highly recommended that you consult with a lawyer, whether you may be subject to a restrictive covenant or seeking to enforce such a clause.

- Simran Bakshi, Associate Lawyer Toronto

LawFact of the Day: Employment Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Tuesday December 13, 2016. Today we are talking about Employment Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

Can an employer lawfully terminate an exceptional employee who has had consistently good performance reviews?

Under Ontario law, an employer may terminate any employee without cause, so long as the employer provides reasonable notice, or pay instead of such notice, to the employee.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, December 12, 2016

Top 10 Legal Headlines

Here are your Top 10 legal headlines from Wise Law on Twitter last week.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on


- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

140Law: Legal Headlines for the week of December 12, 2016

Here are this week's leading legal news stories from Wise Law on Twitter
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, December 09, 2016

5 Things I have Learned as a Legal Assistant

BY LARA FRIEDMAN


Between finishing school, to being a Law Clerk Co-op Student, to now being a full-time employee at
Wise Law Office I have learned a multitude of tips that will help me as my career continues.

Here are 5 important tips that have helped me as a Legal Assistant.

1. Always Meet Deadlines By Planning Ahead

Meeting deadlines are a big part of being a Law Clerk. Deadlines in the legal field are very strict.  If you do not meet those due dates you and your client may be penalized. A few tips for organizing your deadlines and making sure you meet them are:
  • Have a calendar and schedule in the due dates, reminders, and time to complete the tasks
  • Have a check list on your desk or on your computer, it will feel good when you cross the task off the list
  • Always check your to-do list or schedule way ahead of time, so that you are not rushing to get everything done on time
2. Interact with Clients on a Friendly Basis

Law Clerks and Legal Assistants have a lot of communication with the clients. You must be aware of the different personalities and different situations that can arise when you have these interactions.

Get to know your clients on a personal, but always professional level. Establish a good rapport.

The friendlier you are towards your clients, the more comfortable and responsive they will be.  That will always help them to help you and your firm build the strongest case possible.

3. Follow Up with Opposing Counsel

If you are expecting a document or response from an opposing counsel, make sure you always follow up when a specific amount of time has lapsed without the expected answer.

Remember, your client is counting on you and your firm to receive these documents and responses. Don't let deadlines pass without immediate follow-ups to the party you've been waiting on.

Be persistent.  And if you feel like you are annoying an opposing counsel who is late or not meeting set timelines, worry not.

You aren't being annoying! You are doing your job correctly.

4. Ask Early for Documents From Clients

After a client has officially retained your firm, your first step will often be to gather and organize as much key documentation as you can obtain from your client.

The earlier you get the required documentation, the better position you will be in when it comes to preparing an Affidavit of Documents, Documents Brief or Claim.

Ask early for all necessary documents, and you will always have the documents in time for deadlines ahead.

5. Update Your Clients Often

Updating clients in a very important part of our job. Keep this in mind:
  • The more regularly a client is informed on what is happening in his or her case, the happier the client is rightfully going to be. 
  • Ensure clients receive copies of all letters, emails and other communications received and prepared by your office in relation to the client's file or matter.
  • Many of our clients will be new to legal matters, and they will truly benefit from explanations that give them plenty of notice as well as an in-depth explanation as to what is going to happen next and when.
Good things happen when legal assistants, law clerks and lawyers work together to ensure our clients are informed on where their cases stand - and where their cases are heading.

Help keep clients in the loop and good results will follow.

- Lara Friedman, Legal Assistant, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, December 08, 2016

Powers of Attorney for Personal Care: Great Power with Great Responsibility


BY PAUL B. ADAM

A Power of Attorney for Personal Care is a document that sometimes gets referred to, or thought of,
as a "living will" or "advanced care directive".

Those names have been introduced into our everyday terminology by way of television and the internet, but neither capture exactly what a power of attorney for personal care is, or how much of an impact it can have on someone's life.

When most people think about a living will, or their advanced directives, they think about a documents that is used in the very final stage of a person's life. This is partly due to the obvious analogy between a "Living Will" and a "Last Will." A Power of Attorney for Personal Care can be these things, but it can be much, much more.

A Power of Attorney for Personal Care is a document that is a creation of Ontario legislation, the Substitute Decisions Act. Among other things, it allows the "attorney" (the person acting on behalf of another) to determine a huge range of questions relating to medical treatment and personal welfare for the "grantor" (the person who made and signed the power of attorney for personal care in her own name), such as where the grantor will live, what level of medical treatment the grantor will receive, how and when the grantor will see her family.

Through advancements in medical science, nutrition and a better understanding of mental illness, most Ontarians are living a lot longer.

Some of us may regrettably go through a phase in life when we are no longer mentally capable of caring for all our needs by ourselves, but with the right supports, we can live stable, happy, relatively healthy lives.

Doing all of that, however, costs money and requires far-reaching decisions to be made. For many people, the person or people making the decisions will be the attorney (or attorneys) for personal care.

The decision of what to do in the final phase of a person's life can affect the grantor for a few days, weeks or months. This is especially if the primary concern is whether a dying person should be kept on artificial life-extending measures such as mechanical respiration, or allowed to pass more quickly, and with less pain. For choices like this, it can be appropriate and preferable to leave the decision to a family member like a spouse, who may be quite elderly, but who has known the grantor best and longest.

But the decision of where a grantor should reside over a long period of time- perhaps decades, and the type and quality of care the grantor should receive is something with huge financial and emotional repercussions for an entire family. A grantor with dementia, or multiple sclerosis, who is otherwise stable, may need years of attentive and very costly medical care. The grantor may also need personal care, mental stimulation and specialized treatments that will not be attended to unless the attorney sees to it personally.

The job of an attorney under these very difficult circumstances may require numeracy, an understanding of geriatric or psychiatric care (or both), energy and above all, time commitment.

The person who is best suited to do this may be very different from the person who ought to be carrying out end of life decisions under a "simple will."

It is therefore important to choose your nominated attorney under a POA for Care, with all of life's medical contingencies carefully considered, and with input from medical, care-giving, financial and legal professionals as may be appropriate.

- Paul B. Adam, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

LawFact of the Day: Wills and Estates

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Thursday December 8, 2016. Today we are talking about Wills and Estates.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

In Ontario, you may complete a Power of Attorney for Personal Care to appoint one or more trusted persons to make medical decisions on your behalf in critical circumstances where you are unable to provide medical direction or informed consent on your own.

In your Power of Attorney for Personal Care, you may also indicate whether you wish extraordinary measures to be taken to resuscitate you or to extend your life in the event of a critical, terminally illness where there is no prospect of your recovery.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Wednesday, December 07, 2016

LawFact of the Day: Family Law

Here is your daily LawFact from Wise Law for Wednesday December 7, 2016. Today we are talking about Family Law.

A video posted by Wise Law Office (@wiselaw) on

The property rights of common law spouses upon separation are not governed by any Ontario statute.

Common law spouses may still advance family property claims, especially where property has been acquired in a “joint family venture,” or they have contributed to the acquisition, maintenance or improvement of property owned by a common law spouse.
- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net