Showing posts sorted by relevance for query small claims\. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query small claims\. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, May 16, 2009

January 1, 2010: Ontario Small Claims Court Monetary Limit Rises to $25,000

Transferring Actions from Ontario Superior Court to Ontario Small Claims Court

As we noted in our earlier posts on this topic, on January 1, 2010 the  monetary jurisdiction of Ontario's Small Claims Courts will rise from $10,000 to $25,000. 

Suppose you have an ongoing claim for $25,000 or less in Ontario Superior Court. What will happen to your case on January 1st? 

Will it automatically be transferred to Small Claims Court?

Apparently not. 

According to the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General, “proceedings in the Superior Court of Justice valued at less than $25,000 will not be automatically transferred to the Small Claims Court." 

Pursuant to Section 23 of the Courts of Justice Act. however, proceedings may be administratively transferred to a Small Claims Court  if all parties consent.  

Section 23 provides:

Jurisdiction

23.(1)The Small Claims Court,

(a) has jurisdiction in any action for the payment of money where the amount claimed does not

 exceed the prescribed amount exclusive of interest and costs; and

(b) has jurisdiction in any action for the recovery of possession of personal property where the value of the property does not exceed the prescribed amount. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (1).

Transfer from Superior Court of Justice

(2)An action in the Superior Court of Justice may be transferred to the Small Claims Court by the 

local registrar of the Superior Court of Justice on requisition with the consent of all parties filed before the trial commences if,

(a) the only claim is for the payment of money or the recovery of possession of personal property; and

(b) the claim is within the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (2); 1996, c. 25, s. 9 (17).

Idem

(3)An action transferred to the Small Claims Court shall be titled and continued as if it had been commenced in that court. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 23 (3).

If the parties do not all consent, a transfer may only be effected by an order of the Superior Court of Justice upon a motion. There may be some interesting disputes on this issue.

Why might a transfer to Small Claims Court be opposed? 

A significant concern may be that the costs incurred in a Superior Court action already exceed the maximum costs that are  available in Small Claims Court, where costs awards will  remain capped at 15% of a claim's value.  In a $25,000 suit, for example, costs awards will thus be limited to $3,750. 

There may be other tactical advantages to remaining in Superior Court - a party may wish to to retain access to certain procedures that are available in Superior Court, but not in Small Claims Courts.  

For example, documentary disclosure and production entitlements in Superior Court actions are significantly broader than those in Small Claims Court.

In Superior Court actions, each party is required to produce a comprehensive Affidavit of Documents listing all relevant documentation touching on the matters in question.  The documentary disclosure rules in Small Claims Courts are much narrower and considerably less onerous.

Rule 13.03 (2) of the Ontario Small Claims Court Rules provides:

Disclosure

(2)  At least 14 days before the date of the settlement conference, each party shall serve on every other party and file with the court,

(a) a copy of any document to be relied on at the trial, including an expert report, not attached to the party’s claim or defence; and

(b) a list of proposed witnesses (Form 13A) and of other persons with knowledge of the matters in dispute in the action. O. Reg. 78/06, s. 27.

Rule 13.05 (1) additionally empowers a Judge presiding at a Small Claims Court settlement conference to direct that certain documents must be produced:

13.05  (1)  A judge conducting a settlement conference may make any order relating to the conduct of the action that the court could make. O. Reg. 78/06, s. 27.

(2)  Without limiting the generality of subrule (1), the judge may,

(a) make an order,

....(vi) directing production of documents

Beyond that, a party may wish to remain in Superior Court for less than legitimate reasons - for example, to avoid the speedier trial of a proceeding that will likely occur in Small Claims Court.

A cautionary note - those who unreasonably resist a transfer to Small Claims Court may face potential costs sanctions under Rule 57.05 the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure, which govern Superior Court actions:  

COSTS WHERE ACTION BROUGHT IN WRONG COURT

Recovery within Monetary Jurisdiction of Small Claims Court

57.05  (1)  If a plaintiff recovers an amount within the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, the court may order that the plaintiff shall not recover any costs. O. Reg. 377/95, s. 4.

(2)  Subrule (1) does not apply to an action transferred to the Superior Court of Justice under section 107 of the Courts of Justice Act. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 194, r. 57.05 (2); O. Reg. 292/99, s. 2 (2).

Default Judgment within Monetary Jurisdiction of Small Claims Court

(3)  If the plaintiff obtains a default judgment that is within the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court, costs shall be assessed in accordance with that court’s tariff. O. Reg. 377/95, s. 4.

Disputes over transfers might be less likely if the Small Claims Court Rules change, as they did in British Columbia when the B.C. Small Claims Courts' monetary limit was increased. 

B.C. Small Claims matters are now subject to three different procedural tiers, depending on the amount claimed in a lawsuit.

Will that happen in Ontario? There’s no word yet from the Ministry about whether there will be any significant new Small Claims Court Rules, and if so, what they might be. 

Stay tuned...

- Garry J. Wise and Bill Rogers, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Update on Ontario Small Claims Court Changes

Ontario's Small Claims Courts, which are the busiest civil courts in the Province, will be getting considerably busier on January 1, 2010.

As we noted in our December 11, 2009 post, the arrival of the new year will bring an increase in the Court’s maximum monetary jurisdiction from $10,000 to $25,000 and a significant influx of new, larger cases is likely to follow.

The increased Claim limit has been under consideration for quite some time. In November 2007, former Associate Chief Justice of Ontario, Coulter Osborne, who headed the Civil Justice Reform project committee, submitted his findings and recommendations to the Ministry of Attorney General, including a recommended increase in the monetary limit in Ontario Small Claims Courts proceedings.

The recommendations were intended to enhance access to justice for Ontario residents by reducing the legal costs of litigation, and simplifying the prosecution of smaller, civil actions in the Province.

The changes ahead will bring Ontario in line with British Columbia, Alberta, the Yukon and Nova Scotia, all of which have a $25,000 Small Claims Court limit. Saskatchewan, too, will soon follow suit.

Ontario's Small Claims Court is a branch of the province's Superior Court of Justice. Examples of typical claims filed in the Small Claims Court include actions related to:

  • unpaid accounts for goods or services;
  • unpaid loans and rent;
  • compensation for property damage;
  • wrongful dismissal of employment;
  • damages for personal injuries;
  • damages for breach of contract.

The majority of the cases in Ontario's Small Claims courts are heard by Deputy Judges, who are lawyers appointed to preside, part-time, over hearings conducted at the Court.

The imminent raise in monetary jurisdiction will likely lead to a significant increase in the Court's case loads.

According to the Osborne report, 75,041 new proceedings were commenced in Ontario's Small Claims Court in 2005-2006. By comparison, during the same period, only 63,251 new civil proceedings were commenced the province's Superior Courts.

Of those 63,251 Superior Court cases, 6,555 included claims for amounts between $10,001 and $25,000, and would therefore be typical of cases likely to proceed in the expanded Small Claims Court system.

According to the Osborne Committee, the increased jurisdiction limit is likely to result in a need for additional facilities, court staff and judges.

Toronto, for example, has only one Small Claims Court, housed on one floor in a small office building at 47 Sheppard Avenue East, in the city’s Yonge and Sheppard area. According to a recent Ministry of Attorney General press release, however, a new court house is anticipated to be built in Toronto's west end. Whether the new facility will house a Small Claims Court remains unclear.

No plans have been announced yet for the appointment of additional deputy judges to service the expanded Courts, nor have amendments to the Court's Rules and procedures yet been tabled.

Time is running short for the announcement of such changes.

Potential litigants in these "smaller" $10,000.00 to $25,0000.00 claims already face daunting questions on how to proceed:

  • In which of the Province's courts should new legal proceedings now be commenced?
  • Will it be more cost-effective or strategically wise to simply wait until January to start new claims (so long as no limitation periods will pass in the interim)?
  • If a proceeding is commenced today in Superior Court that will be within the future Small Claims limit, will there be a subsequent requirement to transfer courts?
  • If an action is commenced today for $10,000.00 in Small Claims Court, will it be possible - or simple - to amend a Claim in January to increase the sum requested?

With little, specific guidance from the Attorney General's office as to the transition ahead, access to justice is not benefiting from a current paucity of information.

The expansion of the Court will have significant procedural and practical implication that must be addressed by current and future litigants - and legal professionals:

  • the ability of successful litigants to recover partial or substantial indemnity for their legal fees is significantly reduced in Small Claims Courts. Costs awards in the Court are currently capped at 15% of the value of a claim. As a result, the maximum costs award (i.e., on a $25,000 claim) will be $3,750.00;
  • Junior lawyers and articling students will require training in Small Claims Court advocacy. “Firms will have to promote the competency of their articling students to handle these files,” says Joshua Krane, an articling student with Gowling Lafleur Henderson LLP, in his March 2009 Canadian Lawyer magazine article on the pending changes. “Firms that are successful at doing so may reap the benefits of a vigorous and profitable small claims practice.”
  • As noted, transitional procedures have yet to be announced to clarify whether there will be mandatory or optional transfer to Small Claims Courts of existing Superior Court actions in which $25,000.00 or less has been claimed. Further, the procedures and costs consequences of effecting such file transfers remain undefined;
  • The fate of mandatory mediation in the Court after January 1st is unclear. Mediation has emerged as an extremely effective tool for achieving settlements in many types of Superior Court actions. While Small Claims Courts will continue to require mandatory settlement conferences before Judges and Deputy Judges, these differ in procedure, duration and scope from Superior Court mediations, which are typically convened with private mediators with specific expertise in the subject matter of the claim involved. British Columbia's Small Claims Court Rules provide for differing types of mediation, depending on the amount claimed in a proceeding;
  • Amendments will likely be required to Ontario's Rules of the Small Claims Court to expand documentary disclosure obligations and to enable case management of complex cases;
  • Questions abound as to whether all Small Claims actions will be treated alike under the new system. Will there be different procedural tiers, determined by the sums in dispute, as is the case in B.C.?

Some concern has additionally been voiced as to whether the Court's contingent of Deputy Judges has adequate judicial expertise and training to address the increased complexity of the higher-value cases that will soon be before the Court.

In a February 2009 article, Sun Media legal columnist Alan Shanoff noted that the new $25,000 monetary limit will likely bring larger and more complicated contract cases, defamation suits, and medical malpractice claims to the Court's docket.

As Mr. Shanoff astutely cautioned, "Certainly, the public deserves a full-time professional roster of judges and proper facilities. Let's not trade one set of problems for another."

- Bill Rogers, Shashi Raina and Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG • SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Friday, January 28, 2011

This Week at the Court of Appeal: 11-01-28

Each week, Wise Law Blog reviews key decisions from the Ontario Court of Appeal. Here is this week's offering:

R. v. M.B. A sexual assault case where an uncle was convicted of sexually assaulting his two nieces and his nephew. The defendant appealed both charges (one in relation to his nieces, the other to his nephew).

The Court ordered new trials in relation to both. In regards to the nieces, the Court had multiple concerns. They felt there was evidence that the two nieces had had the opportunity to talk with each other about their experiences and possibly collude or grow confused, and that the court had not given a proper warning that this might have happened. The judge also did not warn the jury that the girls' evidence was self-contradictory in some respects and that the children's evidence should be viewed in that light, which the Court of Appeal found troubling. Finally, they felt that the Crown's closing address, which was vitriolic and inflammatory towards the defendant, was inappropriate and that the trial judge's failure to order a mistrial or order the appropriate corrective instructions to the jury regarding the Crown's rhetoric.

In regards to the nephew, the Crown's case relied heavily on similar fact evidence, and the Court pointed out that under Canadian law the Crown may not rely on issue estoppel to prove its case, overturning the conviction quite simply. Read-the-whole-case rating: 3.

R. v. May. A Crown application to appeal sentences of two young men convicted of robbery. The young men (19 and 21) pled guilty to the charge and were sentenced two years less a day plus three years' probation (Mr. May) and 21 months plus three years' probation (his contemporary, Mr. Whalen). The crime itself was planned. May and two other associates (unnamed) committed a home invasion and threatened to kill the family inside. (Mr. Whalen was the getaway driver and did not enter the home.) At one point during the robbery a gun discharged and killed one of the other two members of May and Whalen's gang.

Both May and Whalen were placed on strict bail for the year and a half preceding the trial, and during that time both men were independently evaluated and found to be proceding very well along a course of rehabiliation and had "turned their lives around," as May in particular came from a bad background and both men had prior offences as youths. The Crown, however, despite recognizing their improvements as citizens, still wished for a stricter sentence.

The Court of Appeal disagreed with the Crown, stating that, although the sentences given to May and Whalen were certainly on the light end of the potential range of sentences available, measuring the need for a retributive sentence versus the need to protect May and Whalen's rehabiliation (which if successful would be extremely valuable) was a difficult task and the judge's final sentences - which were due a reasonable amount of deference in any appeal - were not outside the boundary of reasonableness. Read-the-whole-case rating: 2, if only because this is a somewhat rare sort of appeal for the Court to consider.

Grover v. Hodgins. A Small Claims Court order for a portion of legal fees that the respondents paid to prosecute a civil action relating to a condominium complex. The action was one where Ontario-based owners of the complex, located in British Columbia, agreed to share legal costs of an action related to management of the complex. One set of owners (the Grovers, the appellants) refused to join in the action, but all other owners refused. When the action successfully resolved, the respondents (Hodgins and his wife) brought action against the Grovers for damages arising from the breach of an agreement to contribute to costs, or alternately damages that the Grovers were unjustly enriched. The Small Claims Court judge decided that the breach of contract claim failed, but awarded the damages for unjust enrichment.

The Court of Appeal found that both claims failed. The Court reaffirmed the Small Claims Court decision regarding breach of contract: there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate the existence of binding contract and no moment demonstrated where they could have formed one on an informal basis. As regards the unjust enrichment claim, the Court of Appeal pointed out that unjust enrichment requires benefit conferred, a corresponding loss, and an absence of any juristic reason for the enrichment.

The issue of whether a benefit was conferred was questionable; that the Grovers' condo increased in value following the action was not necessarily relevant, since they had essentially received services, and if a defendant does not want services they do not necessarily benefit from them since they might have preferred to decline the benefit given the choice. Furthermore, the Court stated that the trial judge had incorrectly found a corresponding deprivation, since the defendants had not been deprived - they had paid for legal services and received them. Therefore, there could be no unjust enrichment.

More important than the disposition of the case, however, was that the Court agreed with both parties that Small Claims Court has jurisdiction to consider claims for equitable relief in this manner. (No previous decision of the Court of Appeal has provided binding authority for the ability of a Small Claims Court to consider equitable claims.) The Court stated that the history of the Small Claims Court is one of "progressive development toward providing increased access to justice," found that there was no statutory language explicitly preventing a Small Claims Court from hearing equitable claims matters, and finally decided that interpreting the Courts of Justice Act to say that Small Claims Courts could not hear equitable claims would run counter to the objective of providing citizens with inexpensive access to civil justice. Therefore, the Court held that where equitable claims fell under the Small Claims Court limit of $25,000, the Small Claims Court could hear them. Read-the-whole-case rating: 4 as this is a fairly major step for the Small Claims Court (and for articling students, like this writer, who are able to appear at that Court).
- Christopher Bird, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

Monday, March 17, 2008

The Anatomy of a Lawsuit - Part 1

The Nuts and Bolts of Civil Legal Proceedings in Ontario

If you've ever been involved in civil litigation in Ontario, you've probably asked these questions:

How does the court system work? What is the next step in my lawsuit? When is the other party going to file its documents? What is a motion? What happens at a pre-trial hearing? What must be done to get a trial date scheduled?

What is going to happen next? And when?

In this series of articles, we will take a brief look at the way Ontario's litigation process works. We can't promise that it will be the most exciting read we've ever offered, and the truth of it is, much of this subject matter is by definition a bit technical.

However, we hope it will be a bit of a step-by-step resource and roadmap for individuals encountering Ontario's civil courts and judicial processes for the first time - and maybe even for those who are there for the second time, too.

....

Part 1

In this installment, we'll discuss the steps involved at the beginning of a legal action in Ontario. We'll go over some basic, preliminary definitions, and then canvas the steps and timeframes applicable at the outset of an Ontario civil lawsuit.

All procedures in the Province's civil court system are governed by an Ontario Regulation called the Rules of Civil Procedure ("The Rules").

The Rules are the bible of Ontario civil litigation. They set out the groundrules covering each step in a lawsuit, often to the most minute detail. They are complex at time, and parties often require the assistance of Ontario's motions courts to interpret their intricacies.

It would not be possible to canvas the Rules fully in articles of this scope. For the benefit of our readers, however, we will address the major steps in a lawsuit, without delving into the finer procedural details.

Of course, our comments will by necessity be general in nature and are not intended as legal advice. If you have specific questions affecting you own litigation, it is important that you obtain legal advice from a licensed Ontario lawyer

Basic Definitions

A plaintiff, simply put, is a person (or legal entity such as a corporation) that has commenced a civil lawsuit. According to etymonline, the term has an interesting history:

Plaintiff - c. 1400 - from the "Anglo-Fr. pleintif (1278), noun use of O.Fr. plaintif "complaining," from pleint...Identical with plaintive at first; the form that receded into legal usage retained the older -iff spelling.

A defendant is a person or legal entity that has been sued in a civil lawsuit and must defend it. This word also has a meaningful etymolgy:

Defend - c.1250, from O.Fr. defendre, from L. defendere "ward off, protect," from de- "from, away" + fendere "to strike, push." In the Mercian hymns, L. defendet is glossed by O.E. gescildeð. Defendant is from O.Fr. prp of defendre.

A pleading is a formal legal document filed by a party to a lawsuit that sets out the party's factual allegations and legal position in the court proceeding. In Ontario's court system, the pleading utilized by a plaintiff to commence a a civil suit is called a Statement of Claim, while the Defendant's responding pleading is called a Statement of Defence.

What is Civil Litigation?

The term "civil litigation" refers generally to all court proceedings between private individuals and/or corporations in which compensation or other legal remedy is pursued by one against the other.

Typical categories of civil litigation include wrongful dismissal, personal injury, defamation, negligence, malpractice, product liability and debt collection claims.

Ontario's Courts

There are two levels of trial court in Ontario's civil justice system.

  • The Superior Court of Justice is Ontario's high court. It has branches throughout the province, and was previously known as the Supreme Court of Ontario.

  • Small Claims Courts also operate throughout the province, and as implied by the Court's name, adjudicate matters of lower financial value. Ontario's Small Claims Courts have jurisdiction to determine claims valued at up to $10,000.00. The Court has its own distinct procedures - the Ontario Small Claims Court Rules. Small Claims Court forms, which are required in all actions in the Court, are available for free download online from the Ontario Court Services website. Our comments below are not applicable to Small Claims Court actions.

Family Law proceedings also have a discrete set of rules, practices and procedures, set out in Ontario's Family Law Rules - that differ from the steps below. We will be addressing Ontario Family Law procedures in a subsequent article.

Which Court, Which Stream?

In the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, there are two procedural streams available for Ontario's civil actions.

The Court's Ordinary Procedures apply to all actions in which claims are advanced for compensation of more than $50,000.00.

The Court's Simplified Procedures apply to actions in which compensation of not more than $50,000.00 is claimed. If there is more than one Plaintiff, and if each Plaintiff’s claim is not more than $50,000.00, the action will be governed by the Simplified Procedure, even if collectively the claims exceed $50,000.00. The Simplified Procedures are intended to streamline court processes in order to limit legal expense and expedite resolution.

The main procedural difference between Simplified Procedure actions and Ordinary Procedure actions is that under the Simplified Procedures, Examinations for Discovery are not available. These examinations are part of the disclosure process, discussed further in our next installment.

Both streams follow the same processes to initiate a lawsuit in Ontario, so our comments that follow about this initial stage will apply to proceedings commenced under both the simplified and ordinary proceeding Rules.

Note: We have included hyperlinks within the text that follows to the specific Rule that relates to each document and step discussed. Clicking on the highlighed text will take you to the applicable Rule in Ontario's Rules of Civil Procedure.

Starting a Lawsuit in Ontario Superior Court of Justice

Pleadings

A legal action is commenced with the issuance of a first pleading, a legal document referred to as an originating process, at any Ontario Superior Court of Justice office.

This step, of course, must be completed before the expiry of any deadlines, or limitation periods, applicable to the proceeding. It is critical that you consult with a lawyer to determine the deadlines that may be applicable to your specific circumstances.

We will now canvas the specific legal documents that are typically required at the outset of a legal action Ontario, along with the timeframes for the delivery of each document, as set out in the Rules:

  • Certain, types of court proceedings that are specified in the Rules may be commenced with a Notice of Application, rather than a Statement of Claim. Please note that we will not be addressing procedures in these kinds of cases in this article.

  • Timeframes for delivery of a Statement of Defence: Once served with a Statement of Claim, each Defendant who has been served in Ontario has twenty (20) days from the date of service to deliver Statement of Defence. If a Defendant is served elsewhere in Canada or the U.S., the Defence must be served within forty (40) days. If a Statement of Claim is served elsewhere in the world, a sixty (60) day deadline applies. A Defendant may automatically obtain a ten-day extension of the applicable deadline if a Notice of Intent to Defend is delivered within these timeframes.

  • A Plaintiff may deliver a Reply to the Statement of Defence within 10 days after service of Statement of Defence. If no Reply is filed, all allegations in the Defence are deemed to have been denied.

  • If either party wishes that the action to be tried by a Jury, a Jury Notice must be served before close of pleadings (pleadings are deemed to have closed when a Reply to the Defence is filed or the time to file a Reply expires).
  • Counterclaims, crossclaims, and third party claims - A defendant may advance its own claims against the Plaintiff(s) by delivering a counterclaim. A defendant can also advance claims against another defendant in the action by delivering a crossclaim. A claim against another person or entity that is not already named in the lawsuit may also be advanced by a Defendant upon delivery of a third party claim. These claims must be defended after service within the timeframes set out above for delivery of a Statement of Defence.

  • If a claim is not defended, a Plaintiff may proceed to default judgment. In simple cases, this may be done by filing a Requisition for Default Judgment with the Registrar of the court. In more complex cases, it may be necessary to proceed before a Judge with a motion for default judgment, at which proof of the allegations in the Statement of Claim must be tendered.

Once all pleadings are in place, the next step in an Ontario civil lawsuit involves documentary disclosure - the delivery and exchange of Affidavits of Documents and the production and disclosure by all parties to each other of all relevant documents and information that relate to the issues in the litigation.

Under the Ordinary Rules, parties are at this stage also entitled to examine each other under oath in a process known as Examination for Discovery. Examinations for Discovery are not permitted, ordinarily, in Simplified Rules proceedings

We'll be discussing discovery and documentary production in our next installment. In future installments we'll also be addressing:

  • Motions
  • Mediation
  • Pretrials
  • Settlements
  • Trials
  • Costs
  • Appeals
  • The Family Law Rules

Finally, we'll be providing what we feel will be a most important conclusion to this series, our upcoming article, "To Sue or Not To Sue."

That article will look at the practical and economic considerations involved in proceeding with a lawsuit in Ontario, including a frank look at what courts can - and cannot - typically do for litigants in the Province.

- Garry J. Wise and Shashi K. Raina, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Ontario Small Claims Court Limit to be Upped to $25,000 in 2010

Significant changes were announced today by Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley that may revolutionize the way civil claims are handled in Ontario's court system.

The amendments, to come into effect in January 2010, will provide that:
  • The monetary jurisdiction of Ontario's Small Claims Courts will increase to $25,000.00 from the current $10,000.00 limit;
  • The streamlined simplified procedures in Ontario Superior Court's will apply in cases where up to $100,000.00 is claimed, up from the current $50,000.00 ceiling.
The new regulations will also establish limits to a party's entitlement to extended examinations for discovery in Superior Court proceedings. Under the proposed legislation, all discovery by a party is to be confined to one day, unless agreement is reached or an Order is obtained permitting extended discovery.

See the Attorney General's news release on the initiative, for additonal backround.

The proposed changes are intended to tackle the access to justice problems that have plagued the Province's court system.  

The Toronto Star reported on the Attorney General's announcement of the new procedures:
"This will provide greater access to justice to all Ontarians and to all Ontario businesses," Bentley said during a news conference at the Law Society of Upper Canada. It was attended by several high-ranking judges and prominent litigators who have been pressing for reforms to the civil justice system to make the cost of going to court more affordable.
I can respect the good intentions behind this initiative.  I am not particularly sold, however, on the notion that a leaner justice system will ultimately prove to be a wiser system. 

Certainly, the Small Claims Court sytem will require a massive overhaul, in terms of infrastructure and court procedures, to prepare for the exponentially more complex and voluminous caseload that lies ahead.  

Will mandatory mediation be preserved for cases in the new system?  Certainly, there has been no tool more effective in achieving expedited and cost-effective dispute resolution.

I'll review the new legislation in entirety before commenting further, but for now, I'm more than a bit skeptical of a civil procedure system that elevates cutting corners to the level of a primary, organizing principle.

Are there really any shortcuts to justice?

Friday, November 25, 2016

Increase in Ontario Civil Filing Fees

BY RACHEL SPENCE AND LARA FRIEDMAN

As of November 6, 2016, Ontario civil and small claims courts have increased their fees, the new amounts can be found here.

This will impact both legal professionals and Ontario citizens involved in legal battles as the amount to have any document issued or filed has increased anywhere between $10-$20, which naturally increases the cost of the process but also aligns with the consumer price index increases.

Examples of some of the changes in fees:

  • Small Claims Court Plaintiff's Claim issuance is moving from $75.00 to $95.00 (infrequent claimant); 
  • Small Claims Court Defence filing is moving from $40.00 to $50.00;
  • Superior Court of Justice Statement of Claim/Notice of Action issuance is moving from $181.00 to $220.00;
  • Superior Court of Justice Statement of Defence filing is moving from $181.00 to $220.00;
  • Superior Court of Justice Notice of Intent to Defend filing is moving from $144 to $175.00;
  • Superior Court of Justice filling of a Trial Record is moving from $337.00 to $405.00;

- Rachel Spence and Lara Friedman

Visit our Toronto Law Office website: www.wiselaw.net

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Random Outtakes and Unfinished Business for 2010

January 1, 2010 doesn't seem that long ago, does it?

But four hundred and forty (440) Wise Law Blog posts later, we'll be heading into our winter break tomorrow, Friday, December 24, 2010, at noon or so. Our office will be closed until January 4, 2010, and our blogging will likely be sporadic over the holidays.

I've had a number of random thoughts over the months gone by that I never got around to writing about. They are fitting for a near year-end wrap up, I think, so let me just put them out there.

Consider them my 2010 outtakes. This post is the box set.
  • Mandatory Mediation and the Shrinking Trial Bar - I'm squarely in the camp that believes mandatory mediation in Ontario civil cases has been a great gift to the public and the legal profession. Given the high rate of settlement through mediation, however, and the very low percentage of cases that make it to trial these days, it appears to me that the Ontario litigation bar might ultimately have to evolve into two discrete specialties - dispute resolution and trial advocacy. While most litigators are now well able to switch hats as required, it is a reality that the skills utilized in these two critical processes are not readily interchangeable and fewer and fewer litigation lawyers of the future will have the opportunity to develop their trial chops through actual experience in the courtroom. The increasing use of summary judgment motions to achieve final disposition of cases under Ontario's new rules will only compound this problem. How will legal educators and regulators respond?
  • Small Claims Courts aren't So Small Anymore - One year into Ontario's new, $25,000.00 Small Claims Court limit, I am more than a little impressed with the speed at which cases are being processed, in the Toronto Small Claims Court system, at least. While we probably won't have statistics for a while on the actual caseload increase this branch of the courts has experienced, so far, the system seems to have held up well, and there's no sign it has buckled at all under the pressure. Settlement Conferences are typically scheduled within three months or so following the filing of a Defence. Trial dates are set within a similar time frame thereafter, with a full turnaround to trial happening within six months or so. That's a fairly remarkable record, and a great success for the Attorney General's office. A pet peeve, however, is that lawyers' offices are not consulted by the court before it schedules appearance dates. This leads to schedule conflicts, too many adjournments due to counsel's unavailability, and inefficiencies in the system that could easily be avoided.
  • My Twitter Tiff with Simon Fodden - Simon got a bit peeved at me a few months back for tweeting too much. I'm not sure if he stopped following me, but he certainly made it clear my multiple Twitter posts were bogging down his feed. Since then, I've tried to do my mass-volume tweets (many of which find their way into our daily 140Law reports) during off-hours, so people's feeds don't get too overwhelmed. Having said that, our Twitter follows have quadrupled since we started doing these posts, so hopefully the benefits outweigh any inconvenience for most. Professor Fodden and I did get over it, by the way, and as readers will know, he is one of my CLawBie nominees this year.
  • Employment Law Reform - Wouldn't most Ontario wrongful dismissal litigation be eliminated if the province's Employment Standard Act was amended to provide for mandatory, minimum severance payments of (for discussion purposes) three weeks per year of service upon termination without cause, unless the parties have agreed to a higher amount, with further common law claims limited to cases where the duration of employment exceeds five years or other aggravating factors (such as inducement, bad faith, harassment, discrimination or misrepresentation) can be demonstrated? What is the public policy justification for a statutory regime that establishes minimum severance standards that are so much lower than the compensation inevitably granted by the courts?
  • Family Law Reform - In a modern world where both parents are typically employed full-time and more often than not, they have jointly parented their children before a separation, the time has clearly arrived in Canada for a presumption that joint custody is in the best interests of children upon separation, unless a court can be convinced otherwise. Just as the introduction of the Child Support Guidelines eliminated a huge proportion of the nation's litigation over quantum of child support, a rebuttable presumption of joint custody could take most custody squabbles of the table. It would further enshrine a legally-mandated culture of cooperative parenting after separation and eliminate the invitation to conflict now presented by current legislation that offers little guidance beyond a "best interests" test that is subjectively so pliable that it brings out the worst in just about everyone caught up in a high conflict separation. With judges now openly mocking the behaviour of custody litigation's worst offenders, perhaps the solution lies in addressing our anachronistic family law legislation. Too often, it invites adversity, rather than cooperation, within families in crisis.
  • The New Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure - Just a question: How does more needless paperwork and a maze of extra administrative steps at nearly every juncture of a lawsuit create improved access to justice?
  • Technology in the Courtrooms - ...and in particular, mandatory videoconferencing for nearly all motions, set-date hearings, (and hearings to determine the date of set-date hearings) may be 80% of the solution to most of our access to justice problems. One of the reasons litigation is so expensive is that the public pays for so much lawyer waiting time. Lawyers are often required to linger in court for several hours, waiting for short procedural hearings to be reached on long court lists. Wouldn't it make a lot more sense if lawyers remained in our offices, video cameras ready, and addressed other productive matters as we wait for the court to contact us when the Judge is ready to hear us and we're "on-deck?" That way clients would pay only for the 20 or 30 minutes of actual video hearing time, rather than the hours of dead, waiting time. Please explain to me why this isn't now happening. I don't want to hear about infrastructure. If need be, do it by Skype. But do it (end of rant).
  • Is blogging dead? No. But I do tweet a lot of stories I might have blogged about in the past. And that's a good thing. A headline or short blurb often tells you everything you really need to know in order to stay reasonably current. But sometimes you want the details and the analysis. That's what blogs are for - still. Will this always be the case? Probably, in some incarnation or the other, but it is a positive development that we also have the microblogging option to make a point, short and sweet.
  • Facebook Pages, Like Buttons and other Busts from the Man of the Year - Facebook is a wonderful tool, but most of its new initiatives are gimmicky, and seem to lose steam shortly after the fade of an initial burst of hype that insists the digital world has yet again forever been changed.
  • 25 Years of Law - April 2011 will mark the 25th anniversary of my call to the Ontario Bar. This is a bald fact I find extremely bewildering, particularly coming on the heels (as it does) of a reference to me elsewhere in the blawgosphere as one of Canada's "elder statesmen of legal blogging." Time does not stand still, so they say. Someone should throw me a party, I think. And can I possibly hope for a Stanley Cup in Toronto at least once before I retire in about 35 years?
  • The G20 was the Story of the Year - I haven't written much about the G20 on Wise Law Blog, largely because of a case I am involved in. I must frankly say, however, that the Toronto G20 debacle represents the absolute low point in my lifetime for the rule of law and protection of civil liberties in this nation. May it not be a sign of things to come.
  • The Small Firm is the Future of Law - I poked a bit of fun in Monday's CLawBie nominations post at legal pundits who are forever predicting the end of the legal profession's universe. These dire forecasts are inevitably based on some development adversely affecting the continent's largest law firms. What these pundits often fail to consider is that a primary cause of the tremors on BigLaw's fault lines is the increasingly effective competition large firms face from smaller firms via the internet for BigLaw's traditional client base. The largest firms used their size, stature and decor for decades to play a smoke and mirrors game that implied they deliver superior service. Small firms could not successfully compete with that imaging when cost-prohibitive mass media was the only means of reaching the wider public with information. That has changed forever. Many smaller firms are enjoying great success and growth. The market for legal services is not shrinking. Larger firms are just getting less of the pie, because they no longer have a built-in optical advantage. That is not a crisis for the legal profession. It is a breakthrough.
  • My RSS Reader is Getting Awfully Full - And there's nothing I want to cut from it. Oy, that's a lot of reading.
  • Omar Ha-Redeye - I am fortunate that law blogging has facilitated a good friendship with this rather remarkable and knowledgeable gentleman, now completing his articles. Jumping from Law Is Cool to the Lawyers Weekly in one year or less, he is already a major player and clearly is a future leader of and in our profession.
  • OMG! Law Talk - Hopefully, Omar, Michael Carabash and I will find a bit of time over the holiday break to do another OMG! Law Talk taping. I intend to ask Michael all kinds of questions - on tape - about his Dragon's Den appearance (still not aired) and hopefully, we can all watch him squirm under my cross-examination to avoid breaching his confidentiality agreement.
  • Barack Obama - I'm not terribly impressed by his lack of engagement (particularly given the wallop of his charisma, when he unleashes it), but style aside, he does seem to be stringing together an awfully impressive list of accomplishments, no?
  • Articling Students Should be Permitted to Do More In Court - Yet another obvious part of a solution to the Ontario access to justice dilemma is to permit articling students to appear in Family Courts and at non-substantive civil hearings before judges that are now restricted to lawyers and unrepresented litigants. Such a change would enhance students' training, and provide a further cost-effective option for litigants.
  • Mandatory Continuing Legal Ed for Ontario Lawyers Arrives in 2011: Will Law Blogging Meet The New "Writing" Criteria? - The Law Society of Upper Canada's Continuing Professional Development Guidelines' - Eligible Educational Activities seem to leave quite a bit of wiggle room on that question, but my interpretation is that seriously-crafted, quality law blog posts on case law, law reform, and legislation, among other things, will likely qualify. The requirements are below:
Writing and editing books or articles (to a maximum of 6 hours per year)
The content must be law‐related and within the CPD definition, must have been prepared solely by the person seeking the credit, and intended for publication or use in course materials, rather than primarily for personal use or marketing purposes. Credit for an article or book may only be claimed once. The credit may also be claimed for editing legal texts or case reports and for preparing case headnotes, with the same restrictions as set out for writing. There is no limitation on the audience for whom the work is
written.
  • Launching our Law Office Management Software in 2011 - In 2011, Wise Law will be launching a full featured law office management tool with a lot of bells and whistles that uses a simple desktop platform to integrate and automate a typical law firm's ordinary daily tasks, from accounting to docketing to document generation, ticklers and scheduling. We've been quietly working on it for several years and are very proud of the product we have built. Stay tuned for updates and announcements.
Finally, a word about our law office staff.

I could spend several pages telling you all how grateful I am that the Wise Law Office team includes Rachel Spence, our firm's very capable legal assistant, who is better known to our readers as Wise Law Blog's daily 140Law correspondent.

While the lawyers typically get most of the glory, our staffs, associates and students are more often than not the real reason we have wins rather than losses, happy clients rather than discontented clients, and workplaces that we genuinely look forward to coming to every workday.

I'd like to salute Rachel and the the rest our own group, which includes articling students Robert Tanha and Christopher Bird (both of whom are also well known to our readers), my long-time friend, Visvaldis Freimanis, who will be licensed as an Ontario Paralegal in February, and my associate of six years, Shashi Raina, who is now splitting his time between our office and his own private practice in Mississauga.

We have had many successes together this year. I'd like to thank them all for their contributions (and for being a such a swell group to work with).

Thanks as well to the many assistants and staff at the other law offices we've encountered over the year. Your courtesy and collegiality have been noticed. On the whole, you are a group of true professionals.

Season's greetings to all.

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, November 07, 2008

Law in the Trenches: Ontario’s Rule 76

A 'Legally Speaking' update from Alvin Starkman M.A., LL.B.

After writing about antiques and multi-million dollar claims in two of the three last installments of Legally Speaking, it’s time to return to the type of lawsuit which most likely applies to our readers’ circumstances … claims involving much more modest sums of money, and how we can proceed without breaking the bank on legal fees, and get them settled within our lifetime.

Back in the 1990’s government legislators began contemplating how to provide access to justice for litigants whose potential lawsuits exceeding small claims court monetary jurisdictions, yet were claims not involving enough money to warrant paying lawyers exorbitant fees and fighting in court for years on end. Hence, provinces developed what became known as the “simplified procedure” whose goal was to promote cost effective litigation and the expeditious resolution of disputes without compromising procedural fairness.

Earlier this year the first reported case in the country which centres upon a claim involving antiques, and was fought pursuant to the rule governing the simplified procedure mechanism, was published in the legal reports. Liu v. Donya Enterprises involved a claim for damage to merchandise in an antique store resulting from water leakage caused by the landlord’s negligence and failure to maintain “quiet enjoyment” for its tenant. The case proceeded using Ontario’s Rule 76, the province’s code for the simplified procedure.

The workings of the procedure vary somewhat from province to province, but the objectives and essential characteristics are the same, countrywide. Since it’s an Ontario case, we’ll outline this province’s procedures. Then we’ll deal with the facts and the outcome of the particular case, and finally conclude with a look to the future.

In Ontario, most claims that involve a plaintiff seeking $50,000 or less must be commenced under the simplified procedure. If the defendant does not object, lawsuits with more than this amount at stake can proceed using the rule. The mechanism does not permit pre-trial out-of-court oral examinations of the parties (known as examinations for discovery) or other witnesses, provides for disclosure of potential trial witnesses very early on in a case, and streamlines other procedures, making advancing a lawsuit easier, much quicker and cost effective. A judge has the power to control a great deal of the process, the result being that it’s more difficult for unsavory litigants and their lawyers to drag out matters and force the other side to incur unnecessary expense.

Our spotlighted case is not at all unique, nor ground-breaking from a legal standpoint. That’s why it’s important. It shows us how we can proceed, obtain fast justice, and in fact win, with a set of facts perhaps familiar to many of us. Only two decades ago such a case would have been extremely expensive to litigate, and taken years to reach a conclusion. I’ve litigated cases using the procedure, and had a judge’s final ruling within a year and a half or so after commencing the court action. So it does work.

Heidi Liu’s antique store, Lotus Lamp Company, had a lease with Donya Enterprises from December 2000 to January 2005. In May, 2004, the landlord contracted to have renovations done to the apartments above the store. In the course of some plumbing work, water leaked down into Ms. Liu’s store, damaging some of her merchandise.

Water damage is perhaps one of the most common scenarios causing problems between landlords and tenants. In this instance the landlord admitted before the trial that it was in fact negligent, and that it breached its implied warranty to provide quiet enjoyment of the premises. Aside from a couple of issues which are irrelevant for our purposes, the battle became one of Ms. Liu proving her monetary losses. She had to convince the judge in the face of cross-examination by the lawyer representing the landlord, and defense witnesses, that specific antiques were damaged as a result of the leakage, and their cost of repair or replacement.

The antiques purportedly ruined consisted of nine carpets and 10 handmade silk paintings (all Tibetan), two cabinets one of which was a red wedding piece, a coral artifact, and a wooden lion dog carving.

The evidence consisted of witnesses who testified on behalf of each side, and exhibits which included some of the actual pieces, photographs of the items claimed to have been damaged, and receipts evidencing their purchase price. The defendant’s position was that not all of the damage was caused by the leakage, the invoices for the purchase of the antiques were suspect, and in any event the damaged pieces could have been repaired.

The judge accepted virtually all of the evidence presented by the lawyer representing Ms. Liu and her company because it was the best evidence available. No expert reports were tendered about how the damage was caused, whether repair as opposed to replacement was a viable option for some of the items, or regarding their cost. In the absence of expert evidence, and without convincing testimony casting doubt on Ms. Liu’s reasonable version of the facts, the judge was compelled to accept the plaintiff’s allegations. Madam Justice Allen repeatedly noted that expert evidence contradicting the claims was lacking. She therefore accepted what the plaintiff’s witnesses said, and the exhibits illustrated.

The case suggests that for a relatively small claim you can keep costs down by submitting convincing oral testimony and exhibits which help you to prove your case, and as long as the other side doesn’t go to the expense of retaining experts, you’ll win without your own experts. The courts are aware that experts are expensive, but will often be critical if you try to refute a reasonable version of the facts without their use to bolster your contention. If there had been credible evidence to refute Ms. Liu’s position, she might have lost, and been ordered to pay the cost of the defendants’ expert reports and testimony.

The use of the simplified procedure worked well, with Ms. Liu prevailing. Her judgment was for $29,459, plus interest, plus legal costs of $15,000 fixed by the judge. Presumably the costs award covered most if not all of her lawyer’s actual fees.

In the foreseeable future the monetary jurisdiction of Rule 76 will probably be increased to $100,000, making justice more accessible to those with higher claims. However, some of the safeguards which until now have kept costs and delays from escalating may be whittled away by the legislators. It’s already happened in some provinces.

- Alvin Starkman, M.A., LL.B, Oaxaca

Alvin Starkman received his Masters in Social Anthropology in 1978. After teaching for a few years he attended Osgoode Hall Law School, thereafter embarking upon a successful career as a litigator until 2004. Alvin, a good-standing member of the Law Society of Upper Canada, now resides with his wife Arlene in Oaxaca, Mexico, where he writes, leads small group tours to the villages, markets, ruins and other sights, is a consultant to documentary film production companies, and operates Casa Machaya Oaxaca Bed & Breakfast. The views expressed are those of the guest blogger, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Wise Law Blog and its authors.

........

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net


Friday, February 04, 2011

Ontario Employment Law: Parallel Jurisdiction of the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal and Courts in Dismissal and Discrimination Claims

In a recent case, Salvador v. Genpak LP, an applicant made an application to the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal alleging discrimination in employment on the ground of disability. The respondent employer opposed this application on procedural grounds, aruing that the application should be dismissed since the applicant had already had a parallel civil claim in that he had already filed a Statement of Claim against it in Small Claims Court alleging that he had been wrongfully dismissed.

Section 34(11) of the Ontario Human Rights Code, upon which the employer relied, states:
34 (11) A person who believes that one of his or her rights under Part I has been infringed may not make an application under subsection (1) with respect to that right if,

(a) a civil proceeding has been commenced in a court in which the person is seeking an order under section 46.1 with respect to the alleged infringement and the proceeding has not been finally determined or withdrawn; or

(b) a court has finally determined the issue of whether the right has been infringed or the matter has been settled. 2006, c. 30, s. 5.
The respondent employer essentially argued that because the Small Claims action dealt with the same set of facts as the application before the Tribunal, section 34(11) required dismissal of the Code application.

The Tribunal found that this factual overlap alone was not enough to oust its jurisdiction in this case:

Having reviewed the Application and the Statement of Claim, I find that the applicant has not triggered section 34(11) because he has not raised the Code in his civil action. Similarity in the facts does not amount to duplication of legal issues. The determinative factor in this decision is that the Claim makes no mention of the Code or of any allegations of discrimination. Duplication of legal proceedings arising out of the same facts is not a basis for declining jurisdiction over an Application: see Baker v. Sears Canada, 2009 HRTO 1014 (CanLII), 2009 HRTO 1014 (CanLII), at para. 12:

The fact that the case could potentially have been commenced as a single court action alleging both wrongful dismissal and discrimination is a matter of personal choice the legislature has left up to individuals bringing such cases. It is not within the Tribunal’sjurisdiction or mandate to instruct parties where to bring their cases. The Tribunal’s function is to determine whether it has the jurisdiction to accept the Application as filed. In this case, I find the Tribunal does have jurisdiction over the matter.
If you have been wrongfully dismissed or discriminated against, contact a lawyer to be advised as to your legal rights and entitlements.
- Robert Tanha, Toronto
Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

Friday, November 23, 2007

The Osborne Report: Ontario's Civil Justice Reform Project

The Honourable Coulter A. Osborne, Q.C. 's Civil Justice Reform Project has reported to the Ontario Attorney General with an extensive list of recommendations aimed at streamlining civil court processes, reducing the cost of litigation and improving access to Justice in the Province.

Among Osborne's key and most interesting recommendations:

  1. More judges must be apppointed by the Federal Government;

  2. The monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court should be increased to $25,000. The increase should be staged. The court's monetary jurisdiction should be increased immediately to $15,000 with a further increase to $25,000 within two years. There should be no right of appeal from Judgments for less than $1500.00

  3. Litigants should be able to be represented by a paralegal or agent in Small Claims Court appeals and enforcement (contempt) matters in the Superior Court or the Divisional Court.

  4. The monetary jurisdiction of simplified procedure matters under rule 76 should increase to $100,000 on a province-wide basis, to be implemented as soon as practicable. Summary determination and trial procedures should be extended.

  5. The Courts of Justice Act should be amended to permit the court to dispense with a civil jury on its own motion.

  6. The Office of the Chief Justice of the Superior Court of Justice should consider issuing a Practice Direction that would state the court may refuse to grant any discovery relief, or may make appropriate cost awards on a discovery motion, where parties have failed to consider and, to the extent reasonable, apply the E-Discovery Guidelines and The Sedona Canada Principles, in particular, the requirement to meet and confer regarding the identification, preservation, collection, review and production of electronically stored information;

  7. Judges skilled in negotiation and with expertise in the relevant subject matter should, where possible, preside over pre-trial conferences.

  8. Amend rule 50.04 to permit the pre-trial judge to preside at trial where the parties consent.

  9. The Civil Rules Committee should consider and recommend to the Attorney General changes to the Courts of Justice Act so that only orders finally disposing of an action/application would be appealable to the Court of Appeal. Appeals from all other orders would be to the Divisional Court. The Civil Rules Committee can best determine if leave should be required and, if so, on what basis leave would be granted.

  10. A committee of nine - comprised of a member of the bench, bar and courts administration from a small, medium and large court location in Ontario - be struck to make recommendations, jointly to the Attorney General, the Chief Justice of the Superior Court of Justice and the Chief Justice of Ontario, on technological improvements that may be made at each of the three court locations. Recommendations should be detailed, taking into consideration policy, legal, cost and operational impacts. They should also include a process to evaluate any improvements implemented.

  11. Rules 1.08 and 37 should be amended to permit a party to propose, or the court to order on its own initiative, that any matter referred to in rule 1.08 be heard by telephone or video conference.

  12. The Office of the Chief Justice of the Superior Court and the Regional Senior Justices of each region consider:
    -The introduction of 9:00 or 9:30 a.m. chamber hearings to deal with ex parte, scheduling, consent or other matters that need less than 10 minutes and that would otherwise appear on motion lists. The chamber hearing would be in person or by teleconference.
    -The use of more specific time slots for the hearing of motions (e.g., morning and afternoon slots) to reduce wasted waiting time in court.
    -Greater use of teleconferencing for short motions. Amend rules 1.08 and 37 to permit the court to schedule and hear a matter by teleconference on its own initiative, or where requested by a party.

  13. Judges should move to zero tolerance mode when confronted with uncivil behaviour in the courtroom. There is an array of remedies available, including moral suasion, reporting the offending counsel to the Law Society, cost orders and, in egregious circumstances, the contempt process. Lawyers should not be reluctant to report instances of uncivil behaviour to the Law Society. If the Law Society does not know about uncivil conduct, it can hardly be blamed for not responding to it;

  14. The Rules of Civil Procedure should include, as an overarching principle of interpretation, that the court and the parties must deal with a case in a manner that is proportionate to what is involved, the jurisprudential importance of the case and the complexity of the proceeding.

  15. Counsel should be required to prepare a litigation budget and review it with a client prior to commencing or defending any proceeding. This budget should be updated at least when examinations for discovery are completed. The Law Society of Upper Canada should also consider making this an express requirement for the profession under the Rules of Professional Conduct.

The Ministry is soliciting feedback to the Osborne Report here.

For the Toronto Star's coverage, see: Justice for all: A blueprint

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW • CIVIL LITIGATION • WILLS AND ESTATES • FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE